Wednesday, September 2, 2009

"All you need is love."

September 20, 2009 at 11:25 A.M. "Errors" were inserted and corrected, again.

September 3, 2009 at 11:08 A.M. "Errors" were inserted overnight in this essay. I have done my best to correct them. This vandalism suggests the continuing use of government resources in New Jersey to engage in cybercrime and censorship. ("Stuart Rabner and Conduct Unbecoming to the Judiciary in New Jersey" and "How Censorship Works in America.")
September 2, 2009 at 9:20 A.M. This has been a difficult month in terms of cybercrime. I will continue to struggle. It is reported in today's newspapers that the C.I.A. is stonewalling in response to the U.S. Attorney General's requests for information concerning torture and interrogation techniques, apparently in response to criticisms of the White House by Mr. Cheney. These techniques of obstruction and obfuscation are common in Anne Milgram's office in Trenton.

If an agency of the federal government can ignore requests for information from the U.S. Attorney -- an agency operating secretly within the nation and beyond the boundaries of law -- then we have lost the Constitution along with the rule of law. Where are those reports by Tuchin and Riccioli, Mr. Rabner? Mark Mazzetti, "C.I.A. Resists Disclosure Of Records On Detention," in The New York Times, September 2, 2009, at p. A11. (Deliberate disregard of legal orders combined with crimes like theft, obstruction of justice, and much worse.)
August 14, 2007 at 9:26 A.M. I discovered new "errors" inserted in this essay since my last reading of it. I will now correct them, then re-post the essay, only to find these "errors" again when I next read this work. Frustration and exhaustion are commonly used techniques of psychological torture. They are intended to discourage or eliminate dissent in many societies. How does a Jew become Mengele, Terry? How does a Jew become Eichman, Stuart? For my opposition to antisemitism, see "Martin Buber and Diet Judaism" and "Why I am not an ethical relativist."

My experience is not unique. In recent years illicit governmental tactics are more blatant in America. Due to viruses, the formatting and template of this blog/group and some posts have been affected. I have tried to keep the site going as best I can, despite my daily battles with censors. In light of the events of the twentieth century, it is mind-boggling that any Jewish person would wish to assist with the torture and censorship of others in America -- or anywhere. ("Psychological Torture in the American Legal System.")
On February 18, 2007 at 1:12 P.M., I re-posted this essay after correcting "errors" in the posted version that were not found in my saved copy or in the print-out of this same text. Spacing may be affected and new "errors" may be inserted at any time.
Please get James Baldwin's The Price of the Ticket: Collected Non-Fiction 1948-1985 (New York: St. Martin's, 1985). These are some of the finest essays in American literature, as good as the best of Mailer, Vidal, Updike, Morrison, Sontag, Franzen, Foster-Wallace, Lurie, Styron.
I. "Make Love, Not War."
At the center of the raging political and cultural controversies in the United States today is a sharp disagreement about the meaning and significance of the decade of the nineteen-sixties. The fundamental underlying issue, which is often unstated by those who disagree politically and with regard to cultural matters -- usually dividing neatly along party lines -- is whether that decade should be seen as a time of liberation and cultural renewal, or whether the sixties should be viewed as a period of cultural and moral collapse, responsible for the visible decline in standards of public behavior and in the quality of aesthetic and intellectual life in contemporary America.
My answer to this question will please no one, certainly not ideologues of the Left or Right. I think that the sixties have left us with an ambiguous legacy, one that is to be celebrated in some ways while being deplored in others. Those seeking simple slogans and party-lines will be disappointed in this response -- and in anything that I write, for that matter -- since I have no desire to please anyone by my opinions, which are bound to be complex and nuanced when dealing with such a subtle and difficult issue as this.

Do not look for "bumper sticker solutions" to complex issues. And feel free to put that slogan on a bumper sticker.
To the extent that the sixties were about liberation from the straitjacket of outdated sexual mores and vicious racism, while ensuring civil rights for previously excluded people, gender equality, and an end to the Vietnam struggle, then I am an admirer and a proud child of sixties' values.

However, if by the sixties we refer to a "Yippiesque" attitude of dismissiveness towards all values, whether aesthetic or ethical -- or to an irrational anti-Americanism and embrace of nihilism that would undermine the very sixties values of freedom and equality that I celebrate -- then I am not an admirer nor an adherent of this extreme form of so-called sixties' radicalism.
During the sixties both of these strands or sets of messages were woven together. The task for us is to disentangle these strands or "mixed messages" from that period, so as to see whether we can learn what is of continuing value in the radicalism or revolution of that important decade, and what lessons of the sixties are worth preserving now, as we enter a new century and millennium. Just as 1848 is the crucial year to understand the revolutionary spirit of the nineteenth century, so it appears that 1968 is the most important year for appreciating the cultural revolutions of the late twentieth century and beyond.
One glance at the way that people appeared and dressed in the late fifties and early sixties is enough to make it clear that imprisonment in nuclear families, girdles, helmet-like hairdos, suits and ties at the dinner table on a daily basis, and "teen wildness," as defined by the likes of Pat Boone or Perry Como, was doomed from the start -- or at least from the election of President Kennedy as he flashed that friendly smile at the unforgettably attired Marilyn Monroe's rendition of "Happy Birthday, Mr. President!" ("Miss Monroe, uh, I don't think that I have ever heard 'Happy Birthday' sung in quite that way before ...")
I have no doubt that President Kennedy had a very happy birthday on that occasion. (I have just corrected this previous paragraph in the same way for the tenth time, possibly, and it will be necessary for me to do so again.)
Sexual freedom was long overdo as the sixties arrived. As a matter of fact, by 1962, everybody was pretty much ready to put down their briefcases and take off their clothes. And they did. President Kennedy's assassination was a collective reminder of mortality, and of the folly in the fifties' creed of deferring life until a mythical trouble-free future time when the mortgage would be paid and the kids would be in college. This new awareness may have provided the final shove into the boudoir for America's middle class white couples. The best chroniclers of the suburban bedroom, incidentally, are John Updike and John Cheever, both of whom, evidently, "got some" during that decade. ('Revolutionary Road': A Movie Review.")
African-Americans, despite the agonies of the civil rights struggle, arrived at sexual freedom long before white suburbia did, assuming that it has even now. In his great essay, "The White Negro," Norman Mailer, controversially, spelled it all out for the "squares":
"Since the Negro knows more about the ugliness and danger of life than the white, it is probable that if the Negro can win his equality, he will possess a potential [sexual] superiority so feared that the fear itself has become the underground drama of domestic politics. Like all conservative political fear it is the fear of unforeseeable consequences, for the Negro's equality would tear a profound shift into the psychology, the sexuality, and the moral imagination of every white alive. [Notice Mailer's most important point:] ... With this possible emergence of the Negro, Hip may erupt as a psychically armed rebellion whose sexual impetus may rebound against the antisexual foundation of every organized power in America, and bring into the air such animosities, antipathies, and new conflicts of interest that the mean empty hypocrisies of mass conformity will no longer work."
African-Americans are natural existentialists, according to Mailer, because they have been forced to live with the realities of danger on a daily basis. African-Americans are forced to discover their courage and find their freedom in the passion of the moment, and in the assertions of a self-made imperative against the attempted imposition of a false and stereotypical identity.

To be an African-American -- male or female -- is to understand Hemingway's definition of courage as "grace under pressure" very early in life.
This radicalized existentialism is also a protest against the ever-present possibility of early death. Sex matters because it is freedom -- if only briefly -- from an oppressive social order, and not because of any inherent physical superiority in African-American males.

This claim to physical difference is another racist myth, which is really an attempt to demean people of color. Sexual bliss is the only paradise that we are likely to experience. Yet that bliss is not about physical attributes or sexual gymnastics, sexual ecstasy (or love-making) is about the achievement of connection and meaning through "touching" or contact with another human being. It is essentially spiritual.
There is nothing all that new in this universal yearning for eros as freedom and as the "home-coming of the soul," as Opera fans will know. Think of the first act love duet in Verdi's Otello. Listen to Gershwin's Porgy and Bess, "Bess, you is my woman now..." begins an aria and duet with all the lyricism and lush melodic power of the best of Puccini. From this music to earlier work by Scott Joplin, followed by Luis Armstrong and Billie Holiday, the connections between African-American music and European Romantic Opera come down to the expressions of eros and tragedy in accessible music. They are easily found by anyone who cares to look and listen for them. (Read Oscar Wilde's short story "The Nightingale and the Rose," then listen to any good recording by Miles Davis: What "associations" or comparisons can you make?)
The real "black superiority," if it exists (and I think that it does in some areas), is spiritual and it is acquired, because it has to be, by young people who refuse to be destroyed by racism. More than athletics, spiritual and aesthetic life is an arena for African-American genius. In the film Bulworth, Amiri Baraka sings it for the audience: "We don't need no ghosts now, we need spirit."

Such superiority is indeed what "psychobabblers" describe as a "defense mechanism." People develop spiritual resources when survival requires them to do so. No wonder these thoughts are dangerous and hateful to some powerful people -- an entire worldview based on race is challenged and opposed by me in every word that I write. Some of those words will have to be lynched, brutalized, scarred ... like me. ("Is Western Philosophy Racist?" and "America's Holocaust.")
Eros is life-force, as Marcuse and Reich, along with many others have demonstrated. Eros cannot be confined within the prison-house of politically correct panaceas nor in the nostrums and platitudes of Christian fundamentalist repressions. To deny the life-force in you is to embrace death whereas to choose love or life-force -- which is creativity -- is to choose transcendence over violence. For this reason and many others, I am in favor of gay marriage rights. ("Foucault, Rose, Davis and the Meanings of Prison" and "Is there a gay marriage right?")
It is impossible to miss the presence of eros in African-American music, which is the source of just about all of the good music in the United States, including Rock music today. As a Cuban-American, I am aware that Afro-Cuban music comes from a similar territory of the soul. Anyone who has not discovered the voice of Ibrahim Ferrer or the sounds of "The Buena Vista Social Club" is in for a treat. Next you may want to listen to Perez-Prado's "Mambo Number 5" or Nat "King" Cole's Spanish-language recordings of classic Cuban ballads from the forties and fifties. Anything by Celia Cruz and the Fania All Stars is recommended. And the relationship between jazz and rap should be obvious to the most casual observer and listener. If poetry is alive anywhere in contemporary America then it must be in rap and in the street corner "poetry slams" that are "real" literature by anyone's estimation.
To the extent that the credo "Make Love, Not War," is attributed to the sixties' cultural revolution, then it is my mantra in life, now and always. Love is better than hate. It really is not much more complicated than that. Freedom is as necessary as air to breathe, and with love and freedom, we can create satisfying work and express what we have within us as opposed to wallowing in a tempting rage and violence.

We have it within our power to contribute to our communities, constructively and creatively, by focusing on energies of connection rather than division. We can choose to feed the hungry and heal the sick, or we may lash out at perceived enemies, but we cannot do both at the same time. Whether you like it or not, I am going to write my story and put it out there somehow. ("How Censorship Works in America.")
More than focusing on revenge for past slights, insults, and torments, we can give -- and in giving, we receive -- while always insisting on justice. We can hope to do good work that will be useful to others, deriving satisfaction from that feeling of usefulness. This is my interpretation of Dr. King's message and of the meaning of the civil rights movement that he led on behalf of all Americans, but also as an example for humanity.
I can hear the fashionably cynical chuckle of the nihilists and postmodernist professors, "Make Love, Not War!" is too simple, my boy. It is impossible in this time of false images and media domination of the subject. My answer: "Why, then, are you trying to get laid like everybody else? Who floats your boat when things get tough on the tenure committee? Do you not live your life in search of love and beauty in opposition to hatred and violence? And if you do, then why be so hostile to sharing such ideals and to the existence of hope for the young?"
To borrow James Baldwin's question, "Would you care to explain to my twelve year-old nephew that it is hopeless to work for peace and social justice in order to build a better world?" I thought not.

To see the world from the point of view of an American "street kid" (which is what a part of me will always be), whether you are male or female, whether you like it or not, is to possess -- to that extent and for the rest of one's life -- a black or African-American "sensibility" in what is still a racist "white" society.

If you are a hipster of any complexion or ethnicity in America then you are, unavoidably, a black man or woman and you did not know it. Congratulations.
In my experience it is not (for the most part) African-Americans who react with hostility to such a claim. They are usually amused by it. The typical response from African-Americans is something like: "You don't know what you're letting yourself in for!"

I know what they mean. Many whites still find a person's CHOICE to identify with the African-American experience, for the lessons to be found in that experience about coping with suffering, both unbearable and offensive. Not surprisingly, much the same may be said about identifying with the Israeli experience -- with the history of the Jewish people -- and for the same reasons. There is nothing and no one more despicable (to me) than a Jewish Nazi or an African-American racist. ("The Audacity of Hope" and "Israel heightens Gaza Crisis.")
"None of you white guys want to change places with me," Chris Rock says in his concerts, "and I'm rich!"

Again: To choose the company of oppressed people -- to prefer slaves to their masters -- is to call into question an entire philosophy of racial supremacy. This challenge against racism is an unforgivable offense to some powerful people in New Jersey. My essay on the work of Amiri Baraka has been hacked into and defaced at least fifty times, so far. Mr. Baraka was "poet laureate" in New Jersey, forced to leave his position because people cannot understand the difference between a poem and a police report.
Terry Southern said that a hipster is someone "who has deliberately decided to kill a part of himself to make life bearable."

Well, every African-American person who has to function in a white society, whether professionally or socially, has to do exactly that. To be a hipster is to be an underdog, a dreamer, an outsider, a romantic -- African-American culture is highly romantic. It is "to rage against the dying of the light," as Dylan Thomas, a "white negro" himself and a Brit, expressed it.
Mailer was right to see himself and outsiders like him and me -- you too, if you're white, since you are reading this! -- as "White Negros" in the American context, that is, as persons of an indestructible African-American sensibility, however you may feel about it. Congratulations, again, folks. Incidentally, you may wish to recall Toni Morrison's description of President Clinton as "our first African-American president." One begins to see what she means.
Peter Gabel, in his wonderful recent book The Bank Teller and Other Essays on the Politics of Meaning, speaks of the theme of the last forty years of American history as the "struggle between desire and alienation." I am on the side of a "Streetcar Named Desire." So were the sixties. I believe that African-American culture expresses that side of the American psyche -- love and life-force, desire, passion as methods of survival -- better than any other. To desire is to hope. This choice of desire over alienation is not a difficult decision for me. When you listen to Barack Obama speak of hope, think of this source which, I am sure, few people in this country (even in Senator Obama's staff) thought of when discussing his primary campaign theme:
Our "purpose," Fr. Gustavo Gutierrez writes, "is to let ourselves be judged by the word of the Lord, to think through our faith, to strengthen our love, and to give reason for our hope from within a commitment that seeks to become more radical, total, and efficacious."
A Theology of Liberation (New York: Maryknoll, 1993), p. xiii.
Father Gutierrez includes gay men and lesbian women in this teachings concerning love and hope in Catholicism. This shared insight concerning "hope" for those with nothing else is why President Lula of Brazil offered a handshake to Mr. Obama that very few other American public officials would receive.

Secretary of State Clinton and Vice President Biden are among the politicians getting that handshake because they understand one important thing. People who have nothing still have love and they can, therefore, hope. With hope, you can get up in the morning and deal with your reality, whatever it is. Without hope, you won't bother to get up in the morning.

I trust that Marilyn -- and every person I love -- will continue to hope. Never give up, Marilyn.
This moment between Obama and Lula (a brother's handhake) captured in an already historic photograph was the recognition of solidarity between rich and poor, suffering and struggling people, powerful and powerless segments of our world. The image means a lot to people in many parts of the world.

Do you begin to see why "President" Obama has a credibility that many other American politicians do not have in the developing world? That handshake should be on t-shirts.
You are witnessing a form of censorship and psychological torture directed against someone who has experienced much worse with the cooperation of political power in America. What does this tell you about U.S. society today? ("Is This America?" and "Psychological Torture in the American Legal System.")
The first draft of this essay was written during the presidential campaign. I have changed the title of "Senator" to "President" several times when describing Mr. Obama, only to discover that the correction has been nullified when I next review the essay. This is meant to be amusing or discouraging. I will continue to write. I will no longer make this correction, but I will transform the inserted "error" into a weapon against those engaging in cybercrime. Lo que no perdonan es la dignidad ... (Fidel Castro in "Memories of Underdevelopment.") (No accents available when I wrote this essay.)
In reacting against Mailer's essay, James Baldwin (who did not like it, though he agreed with much of it) and Gore Vidal (who did like it, though he rejected most of the rest of Mailer's work) agreed on the importance of sex as liberation. In his classic essay, "The Black Boy Looks at the White Boy" James Baldwin says:
"... to become a Negro man, let alone a Negro artist, one had to make oneself up as one went along. This had to be done in the not-at-all-metaphorical teeth of the world's determination to destroy you. The world had prepared no place for you, and if the world had its way, no place would ever exist. Now, this is true for everyone, but in the case of a Negro, this truth is absolutely naked: If he [or she] deludes himself about it, he will die." (emphasis added).
Sexual liberation always implies political liberation. By the same token, attempts to suppress sexual freedom and sexual forms of expression, always becomes a mechanism of wider social control. This is especially true when it comes to the sexuality of women, about which we are still shrill and divided as a nation. It is time to recognize (and to ask why we have not yet done so) the equal sexual need of women, a need for meaning as well as satisfaction. This is the sort of feminism that I respect, the insistence that women be seen as fully equal PERSONS, for it is a feminism that does not involve any effort to demonize men nor excessive attention to the bogus issues of political correctness.

Political correctness is a distraction from fundamental questions of power to which women must turn their attention.
The feminism that I admire is concerned with social justice, power, and freedom as belonging (equally) to women and men. Political correctness issues are derivative from the resolutions of those fundamental questions of power in society. The terms "masculine" and "feminine" must not become prisons that determine sexual possibilities, or the form and scope of desire, or the range of emotional options for either men or women. The theoretical work of Judith Butler, can be brought into dialogue with the writings of my earliest teachers on this subject Susan Sontag, Angela Davis, Erica Jong, Germaine Greer, not to mention Myra Breckinridge.
Women should not be stigmatized for active and intense sexual lives; neither should men become objects of ridicule for choosing to limit sexual life, for the sake of fidelity in a loving relationship, or very few relationships over a lifetime. The crucial question is whether such choices are expressive of the persons making them.
The work of Michel Foucault has been found helpful by feminist scholars seeking to explore these issues in a context of entrenched sexist repressions (impositions of power) that become pervasive and invisible, even within feminism. My greatest concerns as a father raising a daughter -- a daughter taught to be free and strong -- was to cope with all of the subtle bullshit in culture aimed at diminishing my child's status as a PERSON, who is a woman. I wanted to be the person she asked to iron a shirt that she would wear for a party. I intended to be the person to whom she brought her clothes for washing. It was my goal to play in the park with her and help with schoolwork. Nothing means more to me than having done those things for many years. ("Not One More Victim.")
Deleting a letter from one of my words or inserting any other "error" in this essay has no effect on these arguments, except to demonstrate (once again) your inability to respond in a meaningful way to what I am saying. Lois McNay, "From the Body to the Self," in Foucault and Feminism (Boston: Northeastern University Press, 1992), pp. 83-116. One way of highlighting the arbitrariness of traditional sexual roles is to reverse them. (See my story "The Taming of Somebody.")

The goal for men and women who love one another is simply a sharing in freedom. This is true however each of them defines freedom. I learned from John Lennon that artistic creation, poetry and painting as well as music, and early child-rearing, might be more satisfying work (and yes, home and child-care is work) for a man than more traditional forms of "office work." John never regretted his decision to turn over his finances to Yoko Ono, who was actually good with money, devoting himself to mastering the intricacies of diaper-changing, a subject on which we might have compared notes, in order to make his own art.
A woman burdened with familial responsibilities -- against her will -- must always be much easier to control (for this reason, I am pro-choice) than someone without such concerns. She will dress conservatively, so as not to alarm the boss and in order to inspire confidence in the "client"; she will be "unprovocative," so as to be deemed safe in the boardroom; and she will only invoke her sexuality, discreetly and unoffensively. Just the opposite is the case when it comes to the sexuality of men: aggressiveness is encouraged as a sign of "drive" and "ambition." It is time to be free of such nonsense. In defense of Henry Miller's frank eroticism and plea for artistic freedom, Erica Jong writes:
"[Miller] understood that we would rather relegate sex to a commodity -- alternately condemned and slavered over [we disapprove of "sex workers" and yet instill in our daughters, through our media, a desire to achieve the appearance of an impossible sexuality much too early in life!] -- [rather] than try to understand its deep and pervasive power in our lives. He became, like so many prophets -- the victim of his own predictions. He railed against America's sexual schizophrenia and he was rewarded by being banned, burned, pirated, deprived both of his [earnings] and [of] his power to reach his potential audience. He railed against the conformity and ugliness of America's treatment of the non-conformist, the poet, the artist, and became the victim of that treatment. Ironically, he was silenced first by ... feminists pursuing sexual honesty and gender fairness. It fell to him both to express and to exemplify the role of the creative artist in a world that has increasingly little use for dissent, for art (except as a saleable item), for honesty, for any kind of entertainment or information but that which lulls the senses or sells a product -- from a president to a war to a pair of jeans." ("Quills" and "Shine.")
The sixties as liberation from sexist or racist, religious or ethnic, militarist and marketing stereotypes, in the quest for authenticity and freedom, for a more honest and just society, must be seen as the great cultural revolution in our lives. But the struggle went too far when the impulse to destroy, out of frustration at the lack of comprehension and the slow pace of change, led to the neglect of the principles and hopes that had inspired cultural revolution in the first place. It may sound naive and unrealistic -- which has no bearing on its undeniable truth -- yet this is the greatest wisdom of the sixties and we owe it to the Beatles, spiritually, "all you need is love."
April 1, 2010 at 12:20 P.M. besides the obscene phone calls earlier this morning, a call was received from 732-649-6125 at 11:54 A.M.
August 14, 2007 at 10:04 A.M. New "errors" and defacings of these writings have taken place. I wonder why Barack Obama's photo was blocked in my essay on Cornel West's writings? Perhaps Bernard Kerik's photo in my 9/11 essay will be next. I previously posted this section of my essay, but hackers altered it. Luckily, I kept a copy of my original text, which I will now re-post.
February 17, 2007, at 11:58 P.M. "Errors" inserted and corrected. I fully expect to have to do the same "correcting" again in the future.
II. "Love is War."
The conservative reaction when it came was hot and heavy (no sexual innuendo intended). Richard Wolin quotes Michael Kramer of The New Criterion:
"We are still living in the aftermath of the insidious assault on mind that was one of the most repulsive features of the radical movement of the Sixties. The cultural consequences of this leftward turn in our political life has been far graver than [is] commonly supposed. In everything from the writing of textbooks to the reviewing of trade books, from the introduction of Kitsch into museums to the decline of literacy in the schools, [from] the corruption of scholarly research to the effect on the life of culture has been on-going and catastrophic."
What conservatives object to is a sixties-inspired hostility to the very idea of intellectual and aesthetic standards, loss of civility, loss of respect for all authority -- including the notion of legitimate authority in some areas of life, in culture and academia, for example -- and a visceral hatred for the founding principles of American society and its institutions, which are alleged to be implicated in "evil" worldwide and nothing more. ("Nihilists in Disneyworld.")
I think there is a deeper suspicion on the part of conservatives concerning the "realities" of human nature. They are proud of their worldly "realism," which is the most unrealistic thing about them.

"Love is not enough," conservatives warn, "because most people are not to be trusted with power, or will be grasping and self-seeking, incapable of altruism or respect for duty and the claims of others."

It is difficult to be an optimist about human nature after the events of twentieth century. Politics in America -- in fact, the Constitutional experiment as a whole -- is a wager on the possibility of human goodness. It is the expression of an Elightenment hope that persons can be made or become good, through the elimination of what makes them evil, social injustice, corruption, bad government, all attempts at indoctrination and conditioning. American law is trust in reason. In a better social setting, better persons emerge. The obvious philosophical sources are Rousseau and Marx, but also (this may surprise you) Kant and Jefferson. The word that you will most encounter in reading American law is "reasonable."

Are "reason" and "reasonable" understandable in exclusively racist and sexist terms?

I refuse to accept such a claim. Out of "the crooked timber of humanity," it is at least possible to carve subjects abiding by the moral law, endowed with rights that are reflective of their dignity. This is a Kantian-Jeffersonian sentiment that I share. It demands that we respect the creative and intellectual work of critics. Conservatives as well as liberals are encouraged to read Isaiah Berlin's The Crooked Timber of Humanity: Chapters in the History of Ideas (new York: Vintage, 1992), pp. 1-20 and Isaiah Berlin, Four Essays on Liberty (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1969), pp. 118-173 ("Two Concepts of Liberty"), finally, you will thank me for this classic: Isaiah Berlin, "The Hedgehog and the Fox," in Russian Thinkers (London: Pelican, 1979), pp. 22-81. If you are still confused about these arguments, please consider this Kantian observation underlined by me at age nineteen:
" ... no theories can possibly fit the immense variety of possible human behavior, the vast multiplicity of minute, undiscoverable causes and effects which form that interplay of men and nature which history purports to record."
Ibid., at p. 35.
Theory provides only the foundations or "groundwork for the metaphysics of morals." Theories allow us to make meaningful (or "interpret") our facts. Allan Bloom's best work is a protest against the sixties' alleged betrayal of eros:
"The de-eroticization of the world, a companion to its disenchantment, is a complex phenomenon. It seems to result from a combination of causes -- our democratic regime and its tendencies toward leveling and self-protection, a reductionist-materialist science that inevitably interprets eros as sex, and the atmosphere generated by 'the death of God' and of the subordinate god, Eros."
Love and Friendship, p. 15.
Some of the more irresponsible statements of leading sixties radicals might be quoted to support the case for the Right. It was not unusual to find even so intelligent a critic as Susan Sontag bemoaning the "malignancy," "evil" and "greed" of the American administration. Jane Fonda's well-meaning pacifism was manipulated by the Vietnamese Communists in ways that she may now regret. Other examples are available. There is nothing "un-American" about eros or the satisfactions of libido, about dumping the Brooks Brothers' suit and opting for cheaper and more comfortable fashions. Listening to Hendrix and patriotism are entirely compatible, so is opposing a particular policy of the government, while loving America.

Ms. Fonda's greatest achievement in the sixties was reminding us that protest for civil rights and love of America were and are compatible. I am sure that Jane Fonda would have fought, as she said in the sixties, in the war her father fought in -- World War, II. I suggest that we take on the conservatives on the meaning of America and patriotism. ("Manifesto for the Unfinished American Revolution.")
Is Bloom's veiled attack on feminism as the murderer of eros and romance justified? I think not. However, there are tendencies in feminism -- and throughout American culture -- that are hostile to excellence, beauty, classicism, Romanticism, especially chivalry -- and these tensions are damaging to love in our times. Chivalry (like every other inherited value in our civilization) is subject to reinvention. ("Master and Commander" and "The Taming of Somebody," then please see the films "The Kiss of the Spider Woman" and "The Crying Game," then the Mel Gibson classic, "Gallipoli.")
Gender freedom and unfettered sexual preference are entirely compatible with a commitment to social justice in the United States and in the world, both are expressions of patriotism because they are celebrations of freedom.

The Cuban film Strawberry and Chocolate is one of the bravest works of art ever created in Cuba which serves as an illustration of this point about the ubiquity of post-sixties' freedom. It is not a film that could have been made prior to 1959. Although it appeared much later, it is a product of the flowering of the director's (Tomas Alea Gutierrez) sixties' sensibility.
September 20, 2009 at 10:57 A.M. "errors" were inserted in this essay, again, after my previous review of the work a few days ago. For a discussion of the tactics and goals served by psychological torture methods, see the introduction to "Roberto Unger's Revolutionary Legal Theory." Please see also: "Fidel Castro's 'History Will Absolve Me'" and "American Hypocrisy and Luis Posada Carriles."
A Cuban-American community that tolerates or seeks to protect a mass murderer has lost all credibility on human rights issues in Cuba or any other country. If it is true that Mr. Posada-Carriles is responsible for placing a bomb in a jet airplane that caused the deaths of 77 persons -- many children and old people, Cubans as well as non-Cubans were among the victims -- then his continued presence in America stains all of us with moral blame. Mr. Posada-Cariles should be deported for trial to Venezuela. No more phone calls today? I call upon Mr. Lincoln Diaz-Balart, Ms. Iliana Ross-Lehtinen, Mr. Robert ("Bob") Menendez to join me in demanding the arrest and deportation of this alleged "terrorist" (Posada-Cariles) and the freeing of Mumia Abu-Jamal. ("Freedom for Mumia Abu-Jamal" and "Mumia Abu-Jamal and the Unconstitutionality of the Death Penalty.")
Those of us who are critics of the human rights record of the current Cuban government should also acknowledge and applaud human rights and creative achievements, such as Strawberry and Chocolate. For purposes of comparison and as a measure of just how impressive is the film's mere existence, see a work addressing the same themes by a critic of the regime Before Night Falls. A culture that produces Strawberry and Chocolate has come a long way in the struggle for liberation whatever legitimate human rights criticisms may be raised against it.
The sixties mood was international. It was defined at one extreme by Paris, in May of 1968 (read the autobiography of Angela Davis for an eyewitness account of those years), but also by the violence of the Democratic convention in Chicago. People said and did silly things during the sixties, which may have had something to do with all of the new substances being ingested during that decade. Young peoples' anger and frustration is understandable. Vietnam clearly was a terrible and tragic disaster for all concerned, not least for the damage to America's own sense of community and prestige in the world. The delays in the implementation of civil rights legislation and the disregard of Supreme Court decisions striking down racist laws, eventually required federal enforcement, conveying (I hope) a false impression of the extent of corruption in American institutions.("New Jersey is the Home of the Living Dead.")
It occurs to me, since I am now reading Janet Todd's excellent biography of Mary Wollstonecraft, that there is an analogy between Ms. Wollstonecraft's experiences living through the key events of the French Revolution in Paris, at the end of the eighteenth century, and Angela Davis, also in Paris during the events in May, 1968. These philosophers were afforded a "front-seat" at the fulcrum of historical events at a crucial moment in the development of Western thought. Wollstonecraft was present at the maturing of Enlightenment thought (Modernity); Davis was a witness and participant at the alleged demise of Modernity and emergence of something new (postmodernism). An interesting dissertation in intellectual history would compare and contrast these women's experiences leading to some conclusions concerning revolutions and women. A young feminist scholar may wish to take up this challenge.
Make no mistake about it, there was and is corruption in local settings throughout the nation -- especially in some of the least enlightenned jurisdictions with a history of corruption in politics, like New Jersey, but there are powerful forces for legality and the defense of Constitutional principles -- even within those jurisdictions. It is the ultimate test for American institutions whether concern for human rights and the protections of the Constitution are only a matter of "lip service," or something for which the nation will continue to make the ultimate sacrifice. I will always bet on the U.S. national commitment to the Constitution and to "doing the right thing," in Spike Lee's terms, which -- slowly and falteringly to be sure -- is what the United States does to the best of its ability, over the long run, in my opinion. Sometimes after a much needed shove in the right direction from protesters. (See Mr. Lee's "Malcolm X.")
We live in a nation where state governments too often are tainted by corruption. Decisions by organized crime-political bosses, and not the law, explains what happens in some county courthouses -- including some that are closer than you think, like in New Jersey -- "occurences" which can then be denied, publicly, by officials. Anthony Suarez, Esq.?

This reality of "power through intimidation" is more important than anything that takes place in public hearings or in courtrooms that is aimed at public consumption. These realities are countered by an ever-vigilant federal and local law enforcement establishment, attempting the difficult task of protecting against itself together with the misuses of power by other forces in society.
Perhaps it takes a "law-enforcement-military-industrial-complex" to guard against misdeeds by the "political-industrial-corporate-complex" in society. Think of this as the principle of "fighting fire with fire." You cannot consistently object to giving greater resources to the Justice Department and FBI, while at the same time asking those agencies to protect against corruption and the misuse of power by ever-more powerful and subtle forces in society. Trust (but verify) and give them the tools they need.
Over the long run, America will always be a safer and more free society. The framers designed a self-correcting system for fallible human beings, so that, if we are fortunate, there is always someone observing and reporting on the (mis)uses of power. They never imagined that they were constructing a Utopia and were far from starry-eyed about human nature. By this understanding of American politics, the institutions of society -- like each of us -- is engaged in a never-ending project of self-correction. ("Manifesto for the Unfinished American Revolution.")
Ronald Dworkin has spoken of American law working itself "pure." The metaphor seems most applicable to our Constitutional tradition. ("Ronald Dworkin's Jurisprudence of Interpretation.")

A healthy part of the spirit of the sixties is shining the light of public scrutiny into those dark places and smoke-filled rooms of the past and present where political decisions are made, "unofficially" of course. We can use some of that light right now. ("Law and Ethics in the Soprano State" and "Is America's Legal Ethics a Lie?")
H.L. Menken described America's Supreme Court Justices as "nine old metaphysicians" burdened with the project of achieving ever-better definitions and understandings of our great Constitutional principles and values, through a sometimes painful process of conflict and advocacy, argument and reflection. In that process, the sixties were a crucial decade of growth and maturity for both Court and nation. My "feeling" is that we are living through a similar time right now. Oliver Wendell Holmes more accurately described America's Supreme Court as a "gathering of nine scorpions in a bottle."
As a child in the late sixties I recall the traumatic effect of seeing newsreels depicting the violence in the streets. The fear of becoming the next victim of police wielding billyclubs was very real for me. In a way, those fears may have been confirmed by many of us who never realized to what extent the police might become criminals and the violence perpetrated upon us might become much more subtle than anything we saw on television then. ("What is it like to be tortured?" and "Terry Tuchin, Diana Lisa Riccioli, and New Jersey's Agency of Torture.")
Foucault's writings on the pervasiveness and internalization of power may be cited at this point. Terry Eagleton's book on "ideology" comes to mind, so does much of the work of Antonio Gramsci on "hegemony" and Lukacs on "class consciousness." Yet we also absorbed a fear of the police in the late sixties that is not always warranted in today's reality. It is the police who protect us from the police, while keeping us from hurting one another, which is no easy job. The extent to which this is accomplished -- while preserving civil liberties in the majority of cases -- is a great achievement of the U.S. political and legal system which merits recognition, with all exceptions granted. There are lots of exceptions to the norm of legality and transparency in government, especially in America's "Soprano State."
This is not to deny the constant struggle against insidious racism that wears a friendly smile and appears as a friend concerned for our welfare. That political protest was and still is possible in America, and that a largely peaceful (and very rarely, anything but peaceful!) revolution in politics and in the courts literally transformed society over a short period, I think, for the better -- making it a more open and less racist nation -- is one of the most powerful things to be said for the greatness of American society.
It is true that such phenomena as "Star Trek" programs are now deemed college courses, allegedly, over and above Shakespeare seminars. And the dismissals of the crowning achievements of Western civilization as merely the works of "Dead White European Males" is a dismal and unsettling side-effect of the sixties' revolution for many traditionally-minded intellectuals, or just for rational people.

With the freeing-up of the curriculum in universities, strangely, many formerly prized works were displaced or declared irrelevant overnight. This is ill-advised and sometimes disastrous for the education of young people. The art created by white males in other epochs is an invitation to a conversation -- an opportunity to improvise -- extended to young people, including African-Americans, today. ("Shakespeare's Black Prince.")
The disdain for philosophy spoken by teachers (or "others") and repeated by trusting young people on their way to colleges and universities is distressing and sad (for me) because of all that is denied or surrendered by those young people before they can appreciate the error of their ways:
"It is easy to deride philosophy as the search by a blind man in a dark cellar for a black cat that is not there. But there is one argument for philosophy to which I do not know any answer, namely that it is unavoidable, and that if one must do it, it is better to do it well. Almost every issue we talk about runs out into philosophy in the end. We try to get clear what in a given case we ought to do, and the question arises how we know when anything is our duty -- and that is ethics. We wonder whether we can hold on to a certain religious belief, and the question arises how we can know that any belief is true -- and that is epistemology. We start wondering about the meaning of the great little words of the language -- 'I,' 'time,' 'space,' 'cause,' 'life,' 'mind,' 'God,' -- and at a step we are in metaphysics. The question is not whether we shall think about these things, but whether we shall think about them in a disciplined and responsible way or in a loose and hit-or-miss way. 'Metaphysics,' said Bradley, 'is the finding of bad reasons for what believe on instinct.' Philosophy is not at enmity with common sense or science. It is the attempt to carry through to the end lines of reflection that arise in those fields inevitably."
Brand Blanshard, "In Defense of the Humanities," in The Uses of a Liberal Education, pp. 71-72 (emphasis added).

For those still upset at my views expressed in "Why I am not an ethical relativist," see: Tom Stoppard, "Professional Foul," in Every Good Boy Deserves Favor and Professional Foul (New York: Grove Press, 1978), pp. 43-93. (Is it all relative?)
What Shakespeare, Mozart, Da Vinci and Austen or Plato and Kant are saying to you is this: "Here's my music, now you take it and play yours." No wonder they want to destroy this essay and essayist. When disdain for the achievements of the past is combined with a lesson of hatred directed at fathers, uncles, or all men (primarily), something has gone seriously wrong with so-called "feminism." Or is it "feministing"?

Legitimating obnoxious behavior is also unnecessary, as are ridiculous "politically correct" attempts at censorship. (See the film Blast From the Past for an amusing defense of what used to be called "manners," but which is now known simply as "being old-fashioned.")
How polite you are or should be depends on how politely you are treated by others. Never resort to violence. On the other hand, make it clear to people that you are to be respected in order for others to be respected by you. "By any means necessary!"
Let us admit that there are indeed "timeless" cultural and intellectual standards. Some artists and thinkers are better than others, even if they happen to be (in some cases), much-dreaded white males. In referring to Jonathan Franzen's recent novel The Corrections, one brain-dead critic said that "it is an important book right now, but ten years from now it won't be." Well, if it is really an important book right now, speaking to the human condition, then it will always be an important book. Look up Shakespeare, Sophocles, Cervantes or Fitzgerald -- Aren't they still "important"? I sure think so. And so does Harold Bloom, who refers to academic nay-sayers on the subject of the canon as: "The School of Resentment." This may be a good time to insert another "error." ("Barack Obama and 'The New Yorker.'")
There is indeed such a thing as truth (Terry Eagleton says so), including ethical truth. Try denying this while remaining logical. Everybody knows this at some level. Except for professional philosophers, of course, who are usually beyond rationality. ("Cubanazos Pose a Threat to National Security" and "Miami's Cubanoids Protest AGAINST Peace!")
"What is rationality, Glaucon?"
"Who the hell knows, Socrates!"
And they're off.

Philosophy does not require solemnity. If we decide to live by the sixties' maxim "Do Your Own Thing" and your own thing turns out to be crime, then the State has the right to punish you for it, without itself committing a crime of course. This is not only legal, but ethically correct, even when the crime is corrupting local politics or stealing from the public treasury, time-honored traditions in certain parts of the country -- like Jersey City -- you will deserve what you get if you are caught and you probably will be. There is nothing anti-sixties in this notion. The State must not become a criminal in order to punish crime. OAE? Only in New Jersey does law enforcement commit crimes to punish the innocent. ("New Jersey's 'Ethical' Legal System.")
Also, the role of the United States in the Vietnam conflict simply did not fit into the picture that most people had absorbed of the United States and its mission of extending the scope and applicability of human rights in the world. Evidence of U.S. torture of persons within and outside of its borders -- which is still dismaying and even more so now! -- has forced us to recommit the nation to the cause of human rights in this country and throughout the world, especially when it comes to the rights of the most powerless members of society, such as the mentally-ill or incarcerated persons, also members of minority groups and the poor. Again, the problem of racism is always with us. ("New Jersey Covers Up Immigrant's Torture and Murder.")
If the United States or local governments are involved in the deliberate torture of persons, including psychological torture anywhere (even in prisons) and nothing is done about it, then we are no longer the society that we hope to be or have thought ourselves to be in the past. For then, we will have betrayed our most fundamental principles. I do not accept that this is the case. The United States will always "do something" about such evil. We will not be silent, as a people, or cease our protests until it does. I will not be silent. This is one legacy of the sixties.("Freedom for Mumia Abu-Jamal.")
A puzzled generation of parents in the sixties sighed: "We did not question authority." And their children a generation later abandoned idealism all-too quickly, finding it necessary to sell stocks and bonds or insurance in order to preserve the "lifestyle" for themselves and their children to which affluence has accustomed them, helping to underscore -- in the public's mind anyway -- the immaturity and ephemeral quality of many of the sixties' gestures of defiance, like the burning of draft cards and bras.
"We were so impractical then," everyone says. "We need more than love. We need a Mercedes Benz and two weeks in Barbados." I say : No, we need love, but it would be nice to have the car and the vacation, after we are all fed and sheltered.

"That's just idealism," you say. My answer is: "I hope so, because we need ideals." Boy, do we need ideals. The tension in the American dialectic between need and desire is eternal. At the moment, we have forgotten this distinction and debate.
Before anyone points to Bill Gates or "The Donald" and starts whining about how evil the rich are, let me emphasize the Rawlsian point that those gentlemen have made it possible for millions of poor people to live better lives, to eat and learn in ways that would have been impossible without them by increasing the total wealth in our society. Rather than demonizing the wealthy, let us hope that there will be more of them, paying their taxes (sometimes!), and creating revenues and opportunities for others.

You tell me that wealth should be better distributed. I answer that it would not exist at all, there would be nothing to distribute, but for its creators. If the scriptures are correct that the "rich and the poor are with us always," then let us encourage the rich to make the rest of us richer while they are at it.

In the immortal words of Mae West, "I've been rich and I've been poor ... and rich is better."
Sixties' values do not require us to hate the rich. As for the ethics of wealth, much depends on the uses to which that wealth is put. Is it possible to hold on to the idea of standards in intellectual work and in the arts, while democritizing universities as well as publishing and the media, so as to make "culture" available for, and reflective of, all people in our society? Can we be civil to one another and respectful in disagreement? Can we recognize the difference between legitimate authority conferred by the democratic process and assumptions of cultural power that are illegitimate and to be trashed? Can we criticize those aspects of American society that are in need of reform while admitting that we live in a great country for which we must be grateful? Can the two U.S. political parties stop their bickering and mutual attempts by politicians at personal destruction long enough to cooperate in accomplishing what needs to be done for the country? I still hope so.
Saul Bellow writes: "The heat of the dispute between Left and Right has grown so fierce in the last decade that the habits of civilized discourse have suffered a scorching. Antagonists seem no longer to listen to one another. It would be a pity if intelligent adversaries were not to read Professor [Allan] Bloom's book [The Closing of the American Mind] with disinterested attention." ("Nihilists in Disneyworld" then "Whatever" and "Carlos Fuentes and Multiculturalism.")
American intellectual life has indeed suffered as a result of the necessary sixties' revolution in sexual mores and inclusiveness. Civility has suffered in some necessary and also some unnecessary ways.

What can we do to keep what is best about sixties' values and discard what is not so great?

Let's start by trying to understand one another.
III. "Love is War Against War."
One of the things that love -- or just caring about and for people -- teaches is that there is always so much that needs to be done, in a practical sense, if people's lives are to be made better. Foucault said to an interviewer: "You want something to do? Very well then, start with prison reform and an end of torture."

There is always a need for more education and health care, food and water, housing, and an end to avoidable military conflict and yes, an end to torture.
The largest issues on a global level have not changed much since the sixties. And the militants who get distracted by "ego issues," such as the political correctness nonsense or the more irrational forms of knee-jerk anti-Americanism, are as counterproductive as the reactionaries -- and more stupid, too.

Cynicism about love itself has become fashionable, as I say, together with ludicrous forms of ethical and cultural relativism, as a reaction to the sixties, from both Right and Left. "Love is a battlefield," sang Pat Benatar in the eighties. Many self-styled "radical feminists," in particular, now seem to agree. The trashing of romantic love, but (evidently) only among heterosexuals, by Shulasmith Firestone, being a case in point.
Kate Millet's attack on Mailer and Miller falls into the category of overstated and overgeneralized criticism leading to absurd results. Mailer's counterattack in The Prisoner of Sex scores a knockout. I will pass over in silence Andrea Dworkin's and Susan Brownmiller's alleged claim that all heterosexual intercourse is a form of rape by a man of a woman. Hatred directed at men is just as deplorable as hatred directed at women. Feminists must be among the first to recognize this. Andrea Dworkin stated that "intercourse is a means of physiologically making a woman inferior"; that romance is "rape embellished with meaningful looks"; and that "all men are shits and take pride in it." (O.K., when she's right, she's right.) Ariel Levy's "The Prisoner of Sex," in New York, June 6, 2005, at pp. 34-35.
Scholars and political activists, who happen to be women, should be among the first to say that such statements are not acceptable and do not represent mainstream views among women, activists, or liberals. Everyone should refrain from censorship. Imagine those same statements made by a man about women. The abandonment of "values issues" by the Left in the United States, so that no one will be offended, is a colossal blunder that has already cost Democrats more than one election. It will continue to do so, until people in the party realize that leaving ethical values out of politics is like baking a cake without flower, eggs, sugar or water. It is the best way of allowing the far Right of the political spectrum to define values for the nation. Peter Gabel writes:
"There is only one way to combat the power of the religious Right, and that is to recognize that they are addressing something real and valid in people's experience and to challenge them on the merits. If the spiritual/emotional/intuitive dimension of reality is acknowledged as an aspect of the world [that is real and important, and] that can be known, then we no longer have to stand idly by and listen to these lunatics tell us that God doesn't want us to sleep together before we're married or that the Bible must be read as literally true."
The Bank Teller and Other Essays on the Politics of Meaning, pp. 64-65 (emphasis added).
Democrats and liberals also have values. In the sixties people knew that.

Leftists should not be afraid to enter into ethics debates that voters insist are important to them. To put this in terms of a bumper sticker for political pundits: "You can't beat something with nothing." Mere criticisms of the values of the opposition will not win elections if you fail to articulate, persuasively, values of your own and also to acknowledge the reality of the need for those values. Ms. Clinton's "advisers," please remember this next time: "On the one hand, but on the other hand ..." is not going to do it (it will not "be sufficient") in the future for most voters. Right Senator Bob? ("Senator Bob Struggles to Find His Conscience" and "Is Senator Bob 'For' Human Rights?")
Please do not try to prevent Secretary of State Clinton from speaking of values and principles. Ms. Clinton is exactly the American public official who should speak of values to the world. The Obama administration (thank goodness) is not afraid of values issues and debates. I have been trying to make the point that we not only need values, but that we cannot escape valuing. This need for values is something for the next Democratic candidate for the U.S. Presidency to bear in mind.

Ethical relativism, hostility to the symbols of the nation and disdain for patriotism -- core values that are dismissed as "corny," hatred of American institutions as "evil," will not win elections. This is fortunate. Both Mailer and Miller, regardless of their opinions, are simply better writers than Kate Millet, but neither one is a better critic than, say, Toni Morrison.

Recognition of standards of excellence -- even in moral life -- allows us to make comparative judgments.
Duncan Kennedy agrees that not all hierarchies are evil. Of course, this may have something to do with the fact that he is a tenured Harvard Law Professor, but it's the thought that counts.

Love is always the best force to call upon to clear the battlefields and halt the carnage. We do not need more hostility and hatred -- nor more "macho" posturing by women, BY WOMEN! -- who should know better. Women especially should appreciate the ways in which so-called feminine "quiet" power can be so much greater and more effective than aggression, as a response to aggression. Maybe that very idea of love's ubiquity is one of the most important lessons of the sixties. ("Skinny People Dressed in Black.")
I remember former Texas Governor, Ann Richards (I would've voted for her for anything!), who responded to a hostile and aggressive male heckler with a beatific smile: "Does your mamma know you go 'round saying things like that?"

The heckler was silenced, with a laugh, and he probably voted for her.

We need new forms of loving activism now, more flowers placed in the muzzle of a rifle, and much less violence. In the spirit of that great decade, we always need more peace and love.

Are these the thoughts that you wish to suppress and censor in America? Any more death threats aimed against me? How about another inserted "error" in one of my writings? All such tactics are and can only be the ultimate "cop out."

Friday, August 28, 2009

Incoherence in "The New Yorker."

September 26, 2009 at 1:13 P.M. I am in receipt of a notice indicating that my Yahoo settings have changed. My e-mail cannot be accessed at Yahoo. As a result, I will not return to that site. My Amazon account was similarly hacked into. I went through the usual war to get to this site. I will go to public computers at new locations later today, then I will return to this computer. I surmise that this is part of the licensed "frustration inducement" effort from New Jersey. ("New Jersey's Feces-Covered Supreme Court" and "North Bergen, New Jersey is the Home of La Cosa Nostra.")

New arrests are expected soon in New Jersey. Good luck with the IRS and FBI, fellas! Don't forget to dress warmly, cool weather is coming.

August 30, 2009 at 9:39 A.M. Several "errors" were inserted by New Jersey's hackers overnight. Images are blocked at this site, access to MSN is obstructed, no web sites can be safely visited by me on this computer. Several corrections of this text have been made on more than one occasion. Cybercrime and harassment continues on a daily basis. ("Is Paul Bergrin, Esq. an Ethical New Jersey Lawyer?" and "Neil M. Cohen, Esq. and Conduct Unbecoming to the Legislature in New Jersey.")
Hide your children from politicians and judges in New Jersey.


August 27, 2009 at 12:00 Noon -- Written under adverse and noisy conditions. "Errors" will be inserted in this essay on a regular basis, cyberattacks have intensified lately. ("Law and Ethics in the Soprano State" and "Is Senator Menendez a Suspect in Mafia-Political Murder in New Jersey?")

James Wood, "God in the Quad," in The New Yorker, August 31, 2009, at p. 75.
Terry Eagleton, Reason, Faith, and Revolution: Reflections on the God Debate (New Haven: Yale University Press, 2009), $25.00. (More like $27.00 at Barnes & Noble. Eagleton has to pay for that summer home in Ibiza.)

C.S. Lewis, The Seeing Eye: Selected Essays From Christian Reflections (New York: Ballantine, 1967), pp. 99-112.
Thomas Merton, The Seven Story Mountain (New York & London: Harcourt Brace, 1946), pp. 166-225.

A recent New Yorker "blesses" us with the wisdom of Harvard "don" James Wood concerning the subject of God, God's critics, and the new atheism by way of what purports to be a review of Terry Eagleton's recent book. Has Mr. Wood read that book? I doubt that he has read it.

Eagleton's book is a compilation based on his Gifford Lectures delivered at Yale University. Eagleton was delighted (to the point of experiencing sexual and non-sexual orgasms) at being invited to provide these talks to eager students in a nation Eagleton has dismissed as "greedy and cruel" -- except, of course, when it offers large sums of money to British academics to lecture on the new atheism.
"I love Americans!" Mr. Eagleton was quoted as saying when informed of the fee that he would receive for these talks. ("Why Terry Eagleton Hates Americans.")

Mr. Wood looks on with envy. Professor Wood shares his philosophical meditations with readers of this prestigious publication who know even less philosophy than does Mr. Wood. Perhaps Mr. Wood will give next year's Gifford Lectures. You scratch my back, and I'll vote for your tenure application. This article is a disappointment to the extent that it has much to say on the subject of God's "existence," as it is couched with qualifications in the passive voice and third as well as first person: "I am inclined to think that Gould had a point." (p. 75.)

What does that mean, Jim? Are religious persons "idiots" (like Debbie Poritz and Stuart Rabner of New Jersey) as you suggested in your first article on the same subject for this magazine? ("Is this atheism's moment?") Or have the new atheists gone too far? I suspect that Jimbo's view of the matter is best captured in a sentence that escaped his pen exactly as the British acquired their empire -- "in a fit of absent-mindedness":

"Since belief in God is clearly MADNESS, the new atheists must scrabble around for quasi-biological explanations of this stubborn malady." (p. 75.) (emphasis added)

Among those mentally-ill or insane persons burdened with this so-called "malady," we must include "scrabblers" like Simone Weil, Malcolm Muggeridge, C.S. Lewis, Dietrich Bonhoeffer, Barack Obama, Hillary Clinton and about 90% of the population of the planet who remain unenlightened, as do I, by the new atheists. We sufferers from this "malady" (if we are religious) will persevere in our life's journeys. To his credit, Mr. Wood grudgingly admits:

"The new atheists do not speak to the millions of people whose form of religion is far from the embodied certainties of contemporary literalism, and who aren't inclined to submit to the mad mullahs and the fanatical ministers. Indeed, it is a settled assumption of this kind of atheism that there are no intelligent religious believers (the philosopher Daniel Dennett has advocated that non-believers call themselves 'brights' -- the better, I suppose, to contrast with dullard philosophers like Charles Taylor, Alasdair MacIntyre, or the late Leszek Kolakowski), and that any working scientist who professes to believe in God is probably lying ..." (p. 75.) (emphasis added!)

As one of the semi-intelligent agnostics and "pseudo-intellectuals" who is much more respectful of religious believers than either the new atheists or Mr. Wood "appear to be" (as Mr. Wood would express it), I am dismayed at discovering James Wood's curious reasoning prominently displayed in The New Yorker. "Oddly, despite God's general discrediting," Mr. Wood tells us, "theology is thriving." (p. 76.) It sure is, kid.

These paragraphs by Mr. Wood shine with the earnest wrongheadedness and dull lack of comprehension associated with the wooden prose of Mathew Alper. For example, I direct readers with strong stomachs to Mathew Alper, The "God" Part of the Brain: A Scientific Interpretation of Human Spirituality and God (New York: Rogue Press, 2001).
Would Mr. Alper participate in or condone censorship? I wonder whether Mr. Alper has visited my sites in order to criticize my writings under a pseudonym?

Here's a little theology for you, James. Do you think that a person is using the concept of God properly if he or she is under the impression that God has been "discredited"? I have my doubts on that subject. ("Is it rational to believe in God?") How does Mr. Wood's statement concerning the "madness" of believers jive with this little chestnut:

"What is most repellent about the new atheism is its intolerant certainty; it is always noon in Dawkins's world, and the sun of science and liberal positivism is shining brassily, casting no shadows." (p. 76.)

Eagleton's intelligent comments on religion and profound criticisms of the new atheists (I have only glanced at his book in the bookstore) is a whole lot better than the "drek" in the new atheist category (Hitchens, Dennett, Dawkins are all best known and admired, appropriately, for their non-religious writings).
In an important recent book, theologian and philosopher Mark Johnson refers to these popular writers as the "undergraduate atheists." As a former undergraduate atheist, I concur. Mr. Alper is a high school atheist.

What pisses me off about many of the lobotomized morons who have debated me on these issues is not their "disagreement" with my expressed opinions nor their dismissals of the entire history of philosophy because "it's not science, duh!" I don't give a shit whether you agree with me about anything. I am "O.K." with your choice to be a moron. I object to people censoring my writings or suppressing books that they are incapable of understanding. Am I being "over sensitive"? I don't think so. I am not overly sensitive, only rational and well-informed on this issue. Any more inserted "errors," gentlemen? Ladies of all genders are invited to disagree with my views, but not to alter my writings. Sam Harris is not a writer to emulate for his philosophical acumen, even if we admire his knowledge of science.

Eagleton has understood the meanings of religious writings and their necessary connection to our aesthetic and moral lives. Christ speaks to us today (metaphor) of politics and revolution as well as poverty and wealth. Eagleton is "shining brassily" in this book and in his earlier works on aesthetics, which are not unrelated to the new theology. Eagleton is a theologian of liberation. Eagleton's book-length essay on Marxism and Marxist aesthetics is highly recommended. I have only read 6 of Eagleton's books. Hence, I may not know Eagleton's work as well as Mr. Wood does in his profound English-studies kind of a way.

The offensive and patronizing accusation by Mr. Wood that Eagleton's "religiousness, like a limp, has become more pronounced," (p. 76.) is not overly bothersome, I am sure, to a man who recognizes what Mr. Wood does not. ("Pieta" and "God is Texting Me!")
I wonder whether Mr. Wood has read my short stories? Was this comment intended as an insult? ("David Denby is Not Amused.")

Eagleton recognizes the lesson and instruction in the scriptures of the great religions that we must stand with the poor and afflicted masses of humanity, choosing to share in the suffering and anger at injustices that torture our fellow human beings, many of whom are far less fortunate than Mr. Wood and less inclined to indulge in Harvard (or is it Yale?) easy chair ironies about plague or famine. Do you agree, Mr. Alper? Do you really have a Ph.D., Mr. Alper? Diploma mill?

I am happy for anyone who has been fortunate enough to attend one of the world's great universities. It takes a whole lot of effort from many family members to get young people to those schools, usually that effort is exerted when the young graduate is a child, and some luck does not hurt. Many brilliant people will not get to any university because they are too busy trying to survive. I am thrilled that I attended graduate school at a fine Catholic university and was admitted to a Ph.D. program at NYU. I was lucky to go anywhere. However, my discipline in reading about a book every two days, my four languages, my intense studies are a matter of personal choice. No school is responsible for my mind, such as it is. Also, I am not intimidated by anyone in discussions of these issues at (what I am assured) is my advanced old age of 50. Got it? Mr. Alper, you have the choice of weapons. I can only hope that further censorship and cybercrime will not be one of those weapons.

Billions of us are hungry, sick, tormented by separation from loved-ones, exploited, violated, raped and denied our due recognition in this world, whereas mediocre talents (like Mr. Wood or myself, perhaps, you decide) are absurdly privileged. Eagleton recognizes himself as among the ridiculously fortunate; Mr. Wood does not. Eagleton feels himself called to share in the misery and pain of his neighbors; Mr. Wood will be spending the summer on the beach at Long Island or some place like it. Whether you call yourself "Wood," "Halper," or "Alper" -- the lack of reading shows.

I prefer the company of Terry Eagleton to that of Mr. Wood (based on this article) -- even if Eagleton purchases that house in Ibiza -- because Eagleton cannot help standing with his less fortunate neighbors by feeling their anger, pain at cruelty, insults, sleights along with non-recognition and articulating that anger for them or all of us. Eagleton knows, as I do, that many of the world's simplest people have more interesting things to say about religion, politics, revolution than we are likely to read in Mr. Wood's forthcoming essays in The New Yorker. No doubt it is because some of us who are not members of New York's "media club" have interesting things to say that we are censored and our writings are suppressed. ("Why Terry Eagleton Does Not Like Americans" and "How Censorship Works in America.")

Mr. Wood, who has just received from me and Terry Eagleton (for no tuition cost!) the benefits of the sort of instruction that he provides to readers of The New Yorker magazine and Harvard students, complains that the anti-atheists, presumably, "accuse atheists of wanting to murder an overliteral God, while they themselves keep alive a rarefied God whom no one, other than them, actually believes in." (p. 78.) "Them"? Who them? This guy is an English professor? at Harvard?

Does Mr. Wood mean that "no one other than they" actually believes in this God? If so, then Mr. Wood is not only afflicted with a tin ear for the English language -- and poor syntax -- but mistaken concerning the merits of his claim. I suggest that Mr. Wood say three Our Fathers and sin no more.

The God highly intelligent and sane persons accept is a moral force -- or overwhelming love -- that allows for sharing with others and enduring heinous sufferings in Auschwitz and places like it. I regard such a God as anything but trivial or laughable. There is no belief in the supernatural required in my kind of religion or in faiths that I respect -- not in religious beliefs and practices that I admire -- only recognition is required of the love that we feel, if we are persons, for others, especially for the afflicted among us. Like truth, for Michel Foucault, religion and God are things of this world. If you wish to dispense with the word "God" and speak of love, that's fine by me.

A capacity for feeling is, indeed, crucial to an appreciation of religious sensibility and ecstasy. Feelings are disappearing from what appear to be human lives, along with any appreciation of why they are needed to cope with life's losses and pain as well as the confrontation with evil and death.

If the word "God" is what bothers you, as I say, then just speak of love as compassion. This is anything but vague or unclear as a belief or set of secular values. This empowering love is God. This is the dream, articulated by Dr. King as well as many others, for all human societies, the dream of which Senator Edward Kennedy spoke to a naive or foolish nineteen year-old college student that I was: " ... and the dream shall never die."

This is a summary of what religions amount to, as a life-lesson communicated in the archetypal language of poetry or symbolism, from which they are inseparable. For a professor of literature at Harvard University to imagine that God is a mythical Old Testament figure and nothing more or that a phenomenon like religious belief is "silly" or "outdated" (Richard Dawkins) is hard to take seriously. This is the sort of simplistic view of such matters attributed to fundamentalists -- at the other extreme of the spectrum -- such as Mullah Omar of the Taliban. Qualifications aside, this is what Mr. Wood "seems" to be saying. I find it difficult to believe that James Wood wrote every word in this essay. I say this as someone who read, enjoyed, and admired Mr. Wood's first novel which certainly was not mediocre. James Wood, The Book Against God (New York: Farrar, Straus & Giroux, 2003), p. 171:

"What interests me is your certainty, ... It's one thing to say that the world is a horrid place -- if indeed it is -- but it's another to say, 'Ergo God doesn't exist.' I'm not sure you can make that leap. I mean, if you suddenly lived in a world without any pain at all, would you then say to yourself, 'This is such a happy world that I am convinced that God does exist'? I don't think so. Arguments from design are always a bad idea, whether practised by believers or atheists, and that's what you're doing."

Mr. Wood "appears" much more reasonable and profound (through his literary characters in a novel) than in these unfortunate articles in The New Yorker. Is there an editor to blame for this catastrophe? What happened to this once extraordinary magazine? (See the fothcoming essay: "Atheists in Disneyworld.") You can't shake off this kind of argument or criticism by inserting an "error" in my essays or altering the spelling of a name. This would be a good time to insert another "error," Mr. Alper or Mr. Wood, or Mr./Ms. X.

Mr. Wood must know better than the criticisms that he articulates from a suitable ironic distance so that his friends in Cambridge will not be shocked at his expression of anything but aloofness from the religious delusions of the unwashed masses. I am one of the unwashed masses. Hence, I will be blunt: Although I am not religious, I am deeply respectful of religion and certain that love is what life is about. Does that make me a "fool" to Mr. Wood? I am sure that it does. This does not greatly trouble me, as I have not attended Harvard University. I am not likely to do so. "Never say never." I've heard about a great hamburger place in Boston.

"Salvation is not so much about saving our souls as 'a question of feeding the hungry, welcoming the immigrants, visiting the sick, and protecting the poor, orphaned and widowed from the violence of the rich.' ..." (p. 77.)

Is it possible that Mr. Wood does not realize that this has ALWAYS been how genuinely religious persons see themselves as "saving their souls"? Salvation is a moral concept that is and must be other-regarding, like love. You save your soul only when your concern is not about saving your soul, but at the suffering of the other. Those of us who have experienced torture, denigration, insulting condescension, censorship and suppressions of speech in America, humiliations and much worse from the likes of Mr. Wood and his ilk -- or whoever wrote these offending passages -- derive comfort from realizing all that such persons will never know because they cannot experience true powerlessness and utter misery or despair in this world. There may be a response to the existence of evil in this observation. Love is what remains when everything else is taken from you.

We simple folks (this is non-Harvard irony) are enriched by such knowledge, even when it is painful. We pity them, the James Woods of this world. Yes, there are many of them. As a deaf person cannot understand a symphony so Mr. Wood will never "get" religion. I am truly sorry for him. Let us pray for him, if we are religious persons, so that "God will fill his soul with understanding." Eventually, like all of us, Mr. Wood will certainly come to know suffering and death. Maybe religious ideas will seem more interesting at such a difficult hour:

"We are saved, [Eagleton writes,] 'not by a special apparatus known as religion, but by the quality of our everyday relations with one another.' ..." (p. 77.)

That is the "bottom-line" in religion, Jim, our non-supernatural relations with one another:

"Heaven is not really about a world to come but about the transformation of the world we have." (p. 77.)

Same thing. The transformation of the world we have is the world to come. Wood's mention of Wittgenstein is confused and pointless. The difficulties raised concerning the concept of God are dealt with, easily, by Thomas Merton in The Seven Story Mountain or C.S. Lewis in The Seeing Eye. Here is Merton drawing on the metaphysics of John Dun Scotus ("Erigena"):

" ... the word is aesitas. [Absolute] In this one word, which can be applied to God alone, and which expresses His most characteristic attribute, I discovered an entirely new concept of God -- a concept which showed me at once that the belief of Catholics was by no means the vague and rather superstitious hangover from an unscientific age that I had believed it to be. On the contrary, here was a notion of God that was at the same time deep, precise, simple and accurate and, what is more, charged with implications which I could not even appreciate, but which I could at least dimly estimate, even with my own lack of philosophical training." (p. 172.) ("'The Adjustment Bureau': A Movie Review.")

"The monastery is a school -- a school in which we learn from God how to be happy. Our happiness consists in sharing the happiness of God, the perfection of His unlimited freedom, [this is true love,] the perfection of His love." (p. 372.) ("The Soldier and the Ballerina" and "Beauty and the Beast.")

I will quote C.S. Lewis, who provides a warning for Dick Cheney and his "co-religionists" on the Right, as William F. Buckely, Jr. used to say:

" ... the disease that will certainly end our species (and, in my view, damn our souls) if it is not crushed [is] the fatal superstition that men can create values, that a community can choose its ideology as men choose their clothes. [Do we choose our science? Do we create the reality revealed by science?] Everyone is indignant when he hears the Germans define justice as that which is to the interest of the Third Reich. But it is not always remembered that this indignation is perfectly groundless if we ourselves regard morality as a subjective sentiment to be altered at will. Unless there is some objective standard of good, over-arching Germans, Japanese and OURSELVES alike whether any of us obey it or no, then of course the Germans are as competent to create their ideology as we are to create ours. If 'good' and 'better' are terms deriving their sole meaning from the ideology [power?] of each people, then of course ideologies themselves cannot be better or worse than one another." (p. 101.)

Our moralities choose us. The moment we object that, say, 9/11 is an evil event (which it is) we have entered the moral domain and are engaged in theological speculation. I suggest that we cannot avoid doing so. The only issue is whether we will do so, engage in valuing, rationally or irrationally. This need to valorize exists not because we are all insane or suffering from a malady, as psychobabblers -- who are often insane and suffering from a malady -- would have it. Religion is needed to make sense of our inescapable moral lives. Valuing involves us, necessarily, with what we may call God. ("Is it rational to believe in God?" and "Is this atheism's moment?")

I urge philosophically-minded readers to turn to Dieter Heinrich's elegant essays examining Kant's aesthetics and rights theory. We cannot remain persons if we are denied a spiritual and ethical as well as aesthetic component in our lives. What is meant by religion is highly elastic and can include art, eros, philosophy or social meliorism. Anything that is a giving of the self to others can be religious, including love-making. Copulation (not the same thing as love-making) and eating regularly, purchasing expensive things and driving large cars will not be enough for us, if we are persons. This may even be true at Harvard University's English Department.

James Wood gets a "C" for his efforts in this essay. Try harder next time, James. Any more cyberattacks and defacements from Trenton or its "employees"?

Wednesday, August 26, 2009

No Internet Access, More Cybercrime!

September 30, 2009 at 5:40 P.M. Numerous essays were damaged overnight. There was quite a struggle earlier today to make corrections. This is usually a good sign that new indictments will be handed down in New Jersey. ("Is Senator Menendez a Suspect in Mafia-Political Murder in New Jersey?" and "Senator Bob Says -- 'Xanadu and You are Perfect Together!'") "El Bobo" Menendez has lots of problems these days. This would be a good time for more inserted "errors."

August 27, 2009 at 7:49 P.M. An attempt to review my essay "America's Holocaust" was prevented by attacks on my security system. Cubanoid racism. I was forced to reboot my computer, again. I am writing these words from a public computer. Rumors of pending arrests in New Jersey can neither be confirmed nor denied -- at this time. Joe ("The Enforcer") Doria, Esq.? Payback for Ms. Brown? Or part of the Xanadu disaster? How about Anthony Suarez, Esq. for New Jersey Attorney General?

August 27, 2009 at 10:20 A.M. An irremovable notice purporting to come from my security provider has appeared on my screen informing me of "updates." This is strange since I have an automatic live update service. I make use of it every day. Apparently, as a result of this attack against my security system, I am unable to back-up files. This usually means that defacements of writings may be expected. I will continue to struggle. ("'Che': A Movie Review" and "New Jersey's 'Ethical' Legal System.")


August 26, 2009 at 8:32 P.M. Access to the Internet was obstructed all day. I am now in a position to post the comment below.

Scott Shane & Mark Mazzetti, "Records Show Strict Rules For C.I.A. Interrogations: Details of Harsh Treatment Were Overseen by Managers, Lawyers and Doctors," in The New York Times, August 26, 2009, at p. A1. (The photos of Thomas Jefferson and Abraham Lincoln have been blocked, probably by American public officials, access to the Internet from my home is denied to me.)
"The Torture Papers," (Editorial) in The New York Times, August 26, 2009, at p. A22. (" ... lawless and morally repugnant detention policies" OVERSEEN by American physicians, lawyers and politicians.")
David Kociniewski, "New Jersey Prosecutor Who Got Loan From Christie Quits," in The New York Times, August 26, 2009, at p. A18. (Ms. Brown -- unlike Anthony Suarez, Esq. -- resigned her office as the Democrat-Mafia machine in New Jersey "spends millions on negative attacks and play down and dirty in order to win ...")

August 26, 2009 at 9:45 A.M. I am, once again, denied access to the Internet as part of New Jersey's harassment, censorship, and silencing effort. I will do my best to find a public computer to post a warning about what has happened to me today. Censorship may happen to you. I will attempt to post this essay, part of which appeared under the title "The Long Goodbye" on a prior occasion when Trenton's state-sanctioned censorship obstructed my Internet access. If only I were a corporation -- a fictitious person with lots of money -- then my "free speech" rights would be respected.

I do not believe that China or Cuba would be worse in their treatment of writers expressing opinions than the people responsible for these tactics that are used against a person who has experienced psychological torture, financial guerrilla warfare, theft, many kinds of rape and other assaults. The control panel at the bottom of my computer is gone, after restarting my computer. Scans are impossible because updating is impossible. If I mention "Fidel Castro" new attacks are directed at my writings. Therefore, I will make it a point to mention Fidel Castro even if I happen to disagree with him. ("Fidel Castro's 'History Will Absolve Me.'")

Liu Xiaobo -- a Chinese dissident possibly facing criminal charges -- has not been raped, beaten, abused during his period of incarceration. He is subjected to the same legal process as other alleged offenders. A report has been prepared by police investigation. Prosecutors have the right to reject or accept a recommendation to proceed against the accused who will be notified of charges, if any, and have an opportunity to respond. Liu Xiaobo may be released, after pre-trial detention, if charges are not filed or dismissed. By any rational standard, this person is vastly better off than America's detainees and many alleged offenders in this country subjected to "secret" proceedings and psychological torture for decades. Keith Bradsher, "China: Police Send Report on Dissident," in The New York Times, December 10, 2009, at p. A20.

I express my concern and solidarity for Mr. Liu and his family members together with the hope that this gentleman may be returned to his family soon.

To speak to me of "ethics" under these circumstances, as these torture tactics continue and provide a spectacle for an audience that knows them to be criminal and unconstitutional, is absurd. YOU are the criminals, not me. I will not stop writing. I will not alter my opinions. I will continue to post writings on-line. I will not be intimidated by anyone. Your ignorance and shameful inadequacies in losing debates with me will not be changed. You will not become any smarter or any less mistaken in your views if you silence me. Philosophical and legal controversies are not settled by violence or brutality, nor by censorship. You cannot beat up ideas.

Something frightening is on display in this theater of human cruelty and intolerance of dissent. This is not the country described in America's Constitution nor in our self-presentation to the world. This is harmful to me, personally, but it is vastly more wounding to America's Constitution and to the U.S. Senate, also scary for every artist or dissident struggling to think and create his or her work in this environment. Ironically, the pattern is now clear as, almost a year ago, the same brutal censorship was implemented. America is not a Banana Republic, as I have said many times, controversial opinions may and should be expressed. Disagreements are welcome; censorship is not. ("Does Senator Menendez Have Mafia Friends?")

The world no longer believes America's claims concerning freedom of speech and conscience. What follows was written almost a year ago today. These tactics did not work then; they will not work now. How does a Jew become Mengele, Terry Tuchin? How does a Jew become Eichman, Stuart Rabner? How can you be a part of this cybercrime and call yourself a decent human being, let alone an attorney? Whatever your ethnicity, race, sexual-orientation and whatever you feel about me -- these crimes should trouble you. ("What is it like to be tortured?" and "What is it like to be plagiarized?")

It is a beautiful morning in New York. Later I will walk in the city. I felt that I should try to post these words, as a farewell of sorts. I am unable to access the Internet or my sites, again. I cannot -- as of 10:40 A.M. on August 7, 2008 -- communicate my opinions and feelings at my home computer. I will search for another computer beginning today. I suspect an illegal interference with my cable service provider, an illegal network, and other nefarious disruption of my communication efforts. What else is new?

August 21, 2008 at 11:12 P.M. Images were blocked earlier today. I do not know whether I can post images at Critique. I will try again to do so. If I am unable to attach images to these essays, then I will provide links in order for readers to view the images that I wish to associate with these essays. I will struggle to continue writing no matter what new obstacles come my way. ("Censorship and Cruelty in New Jersey.")

Yesterday, once again, several of my essays were damaged, some have been altered on so many occasions that it is now impossible for me to estimate the number of times when I have been forced to make corrections. The goal of this process, which I have experienced for years and documented extensively, is to crush the spirit of a human being. The destruction of a life and mind is a means of controlling a person by transforming him into something that is less than human. After all of his tortures, Winston Smith's greatest performance was the sincere love of Big Brother. ("How Censorship Works in America.")

The mega-societies in which we live -- I am sure that the phenomenon that I describe and endure, every day, is bigger than any one country -- constrain the human spirit in order for public authority to become pervasive and total. The aim of postmodernist governments is to replace God in the human scale of values. To argue that such an ambition is unethical or evil is absurd because, we are told, governments define the scope of good and evil. When government is in bed with organized crime -- as in New Jersey -- things are even worse. China is Switzerland by comparison with New Jersey. (See "Law and Ethics in the Soprano State" and "New Jersey's 'Ethical' Legal System.")

"Right and wrong is relative to power." There is no love. No goodness. No justice. "Money is the meaning of life." These things have been said to me by American attorneys, judges, officials. The same persons sworn to uphold freedom of speech, privacy rights, democracy are responsible for censoring a tortured dissident and intellectual whose greatest offense is to think and speak of the collective loss of our "souls." "There's no such thing as the soul," I am told. It is still my only crime to think and speak freely. Are you one of my torturers? Your silence is complicity in atrocity. ("Stuart Rabner and Conduct Unbecoming to the Judiciary in New Jersey.")

My words are written in sand. My essays may be destroyed at any time. Each morning dozens of "errors" are inserted in writings that I have struggled to compose, with great care, sometimes for hours and days, weeks and months. The energy and resources devoted to the infliction of suffering on a person whose unforgivable crime is independence of thought and opinions as well as righteous anger at the pains of injustice reveals the depravities of power together with some people's sick need to dominate others. I understand what people in other countries mean by "imperialistic" policies aimed at denying independence and enslaving people. I will not accept enslavement or intellectual colonization. I will not endure or live with philosophical slavery. I will struggle against the embargo placed on my life.

Does this explain the pointless hostility between the U.S. and Cuba? A small nation's insistence on independence? This appetite for domination is enhanced by our newest technologies of sadism. I have no privacy when reading on-line or writing my works. Do you speak to me of ethics, Stuart Rabner? ("Stuart Rabner and Conduct Unbecoming to the Judiciary in New Jersey.") Please see Emma Graves Fitzsimmons, "4 Teenagers Charged in Youth's Beating Death," in The New York Times, September 29, 2009, at p. A27. (The culprits videotaped their exploits, perhaps as part of a class assignment in psychology.)

This is not a situation that the Chief Justice of a state riddled with legal and political corruption -- where violations of the First Amendment made possible by state action are a daily reality -- can afford to ignore or continue to cover-up. Perpetuation of gross injustice, corrupt, biased legal proceedings in so-called "ethics matters" undermines the credibility of New Jersey courts and judges in all matters. No legal system can tolerate this sort of criticism, made publicly, which sinks into the marrows of the courts and undermines all actions by that system's tainted judges.

My pain is greatest when I think of the harm to the American Constitution resulting from sanctioned government censorship. The experience of torture (I believe) at the hands of Cuban-American Fascists protected by the American legal system and its corrupt managers (in violation of the U.S. Constitution), together with American attorneys, is a graduate education in the politics of the real world. Far from discouraging or destroying my values, this nightmare has confirmed my sense of their urgency and truth. Winston Smith's greatest achievement would be to persuade Big Brother to love human freedom, respecting the DIGNITY of men and women by demonstrating that -- even when faced with enormous pain in Orwell's room 101 -- we may still affirm our humanity by asking that the worst be done to us and not to our loved-ones, while insisting on dignity, pride, and the reality of goodness. I will continue to point out to New Jersey's power-structure: This is what you are. This is what you have become. ("Babalu and Free Speech Too!" and "More Problems for Menendez -- Tapes!")

If Terry Tuchin will not respond to my requests, then perhaps Stacy Tuchin, M.D. of Paramus, New Jersey will respond to my requests for information. ("An Open Letter to My Torturers in New Jersey, Terry Tuchin and Diana Lisa Riccioli.")

If I am in a prison cell and torture chamber -- if I cannot exit this hell of censorship and insults -- then I will insist on my right to love a few persons freely (publicly), to think and speak as I deem best, to accept no injustice without struggle, refusing to deny what I know is true: 2 + 2 = 4. It has been said: "... man tends to achieve his being inasmuch as he develops love and reason. We could say that man is able to love and reason" -- both are forms of communication, languages -- "because he is, but also and conversely, that he is" because he is "capable of reasoning and loving." (Eric Fromm) Please see: "Is it rational to believe in God?" (As of December, 2009 this essay concerning the rationality of deism has been vandalized and censored, again.)

To deny speech, words and the ability to communicate to a person, suppressing and destroying his writings and books, deeply injuring him (deliberately!) -- for years -- in an effort at conditioning, is to dehumanize and enslave a person -- really everyone in society. Naturally, this may be less true of laboratory rats. However, since I am not a laboratory rat, I feel pretty certain that it is true of me. No alleged claim of offense concerning my statements in The Da Vinci Code essay-review justifies censorship in a free society. My statement concerning Christ and St. John was a quotation from a celebrated and unchallenged scholarly work.

Your hatred of gays in Hudson County does not alter the truth in that statement or in my position. You cannot beat up values. You cannot change truth through censorship. ("What is it like to be tortured?" and "Terry Tuchin, Diana Lisa Riccioli, and New Jersey's Agency of Torture.") I am not threatened or intimidated by the PROMISE to describe me as a "homosexual." Call me anything you like. ("Carlos Fuentes and Multiculturalism.")

"This is what many of the great philosophers, mystics, and theologians of the East and West have believed. For all of them there is within man [and woman] a spiritual reality that is born precisely because he can know himself and others, and that is a part of [human] life itself."

Eric Fromm & Ramon Xirau, eds., The Nature of Man: A Reader (New York: McMillan, 1968), pp. 9-10. ("Is this atheism's moment?")

We "pseudo-intellectuals" (I have been dismissed in such terms) hope to compensate for our ordinary minds with wide reading and scholarship, without any loss of originality. Perhaps respect can no longer be expected by Americans from their government officials. However, respect is still demanded by the American people -- and all others in the world -- as the first ingredient of political association. This respect is guaranteed to all persons under the American Declaration of Independence and Bill of Rights. Human dignity and respect are not gifts of the State. My rights are not negotiable because they are "inherent" in my humanity. My freedom and rights are part of what I am, not merely things that I have. ("What is 'Homeland Security'?" and "Habeas Corpus," then Meditatio ad Malum et Caritas.)

My computer has been battered, repaired several times, subjected to a relentless assault. My security system has been disabled and made ineffective. My t.v. signal is regularly obstructed. But then, much the same may be said of me. I have been violated and severely damaged. My psychic "security system" has been under attack for many years, injured beyond repair perhaps. I may be denied the means to write -- like a man whose oxygen supply is cut off -- in order that "experts" may observe one person's fascinating death throes and spiritual suffering. Is it interesting for you? Can you learn from my torments? (Again: "Terry Tuchin, Diana Lisa Riccioli, and New Jersey's Agency of Torture" and "What is it like to be tortured?")

Do I still live in America? What happened to the U.S. Constitution? Inducing anxiety and stress, threats to family and one's peace of mind, can force a person into himself, imprisoning the "subject" in silence. Silence and apathy are the co-conspirators of illegitimate power, as are secrecy and surveillance, economic threats and pressures. I have decided after 21 years of torture and theft against me -- noise fills my room again -- to reaffirm my commitment to this struggle to think and speak freely, ALWAYS, in opposition to all attempts to control, discipline, coopt, subjectivate or manipulate the human mind and spirit by reducing human beings to the status of things. "Objects." ("Richard A. Posner on Voluntary Actions and Criminal Responsibility.")

My daily encounter with torturers is an immersion in a barrel of shit -- the shit of Cuban-American Fascism, racism, homophobia, and ethnic hatred protected and sanctioned by government in one poisonous American jurisdiction run by the mafia, New Jersey. I hope it is only one American "jerseydiction." ("Mafia Influence in New Jersey Courts and Politics" and "Law and Ethics in the Soprano State.")

October 29, 2009 at 4:55 P.M. "Errors" inserted in this essay since this morning have now been corrected.

For any Jewish person to lend him- or herself to such evil, after the events of the twentieth century, is tragic and discouraging. It saddens me to know that such horror is possible. I am not a slave. I am not a laboratory animal. I will not "accept" or "adjust to" such a diminished moral status. I love all of my family members -- equally. Whatever pain I feel, I will do my best to shelter all of you from my sufferings. This is especially true of one woman who needs to know that she cannot lose my love. I will love you no matter what cost I have to pay for that love. I am absolutely unconcerned with whether New Jersey's soiled judiciary "approves" of my loves, ideas, values, or opinions.

My ability to communicate may be taken from me at any time. It has been taken from me in the past at irregular intervals, illegally. It was taken away from me today, despite the provisions of the First Amendment. I cannot avoid expressing my disgust and dismay at the actions of so many members of the Cuban-American community and their friends, at corrupt judges and tribunals in the Garden State, for what they have made of the gift that is the U.S. Constitution. Fortunately, what this document says about human freedom and equality for every person under a government of limited powers cannot be destroyed or made untrue by anyone. ("Is Senator Menendez a Suspect in Mafia-Political Murder in New Jersey?" and "Does Senator Menendez Have Mafia Friends?")

What have we become that we remain indifferent to the public torments of any person? How can I believe in America after what I have experienced? It is my American independence that tells me that what I have suffered is evil. God (or love) is beyond the control of laws and men, as are the fundamental ethical and spiritual freedoms of human beings. This includes (I believe) the equal, spiritual love among gay men and lesbian women. If I am beaten or censored for saying this, I will repeat it -- same-sex and heterosexual love are equally "holy" (if you wish to use that word) and deserve identical public respect under our laws. You are invited to disagree with me, not to silence or censor me. Censorship from public officials (or their agents) is a criminal violation of civil rights:

"We cannot give up on utopian hope or socialism. We cannot give up on progress. They are not less apt in light of what we know about the bad side of human nature. They are more necessary."
" ... To accept the world as it (more or less) is, is to help to prolong a state of grave danger. This world, accomodating and countenancing too much of what is not to be tolerated -- plain, persistent injustice, stark, avoidable human suffering -- is a world very receptive to present and future atrocity, a world overpopulated with bystanders. It is one in which the idea is harder and harder to resist that just anything may be done to people while others look on; and there be no consequence. As long as the situation lasts, it degrades the moral culture of the planet. It poisons the conscience of humankind."

Norman Geras, The Contract of Mutual Indifference (New York & London: Verso, 1998), p. 120.

"Would you have helped Catherine 'Kitty' Genovese?" and "Fidel Castro's 'History Will Absolve Me.'"

Tuesday, August 25, 2009

"The Two Marys": Duality in Christian Feminine Identity.

August 26, 2009 at 4:45 P.M. My Internet connection from my home computer is obstructed. I am posting this notice from a public computer. I will try to continue writing from public computers. None of my opinions have changed. Please see, "Time to End the Embargo Against Cuba" and "Law and Ethics in the Soprano State." I cannot say whether, where, or when I will write again. I will try to restore my home Internet connection.

June Singer, Androgyny: Toward a New Theory of Sexuality (New York: Anchor, 1977).
Elaine Pagels, The Gnostic Gospels (New York: Vintage, 1979).
Reynolds Price, Three Gospels (New York: Touchstone, 1996).
Cynthia Freeland, "The Women Who Loved Jesus: Suffering and the Traditional Feminine Role," in Jorge J.E. Gracia, ed., Mel Gibson's Passion and Philosophy (Chicago: Open Court, 2004), p. 151.
James Lawler, "God and Man Separated No More: Hegel Overcomes the Unhappy Consciousness of Gibson's Christianity," in Mel Gibson's Passion and Philosophy, at p. 62.
Raymond Plant, Hegel (London: Routledge, 1997), p. 18.
Judith Butler, Gender Trouble: Feminism and the Subversion of Identity (New York & London, 1990 & 1999), pp. 18-33 (especially, "Theorizing the Binary, the Unitary, and Beyond").
H.D., Pilate's Wife (New York: New Directions, 2000), (original date of manuscript, 1929).
Brian Greene, The Fabric of the Cosmos (New York & London: Penguin, 2005).
Errol E. Harris, The Reality of Time (New York: SUNY, 1988).

I am unable to post images in my blog today, but I refuse to be silenced. As I type these words, I have no idea whether they will find their way on to the blog/group or disappear into the electronic ether. My refusal to alter my opinions or to refrain from expressing them is only confirmed and reinforced by these encounters with hackers, viruses and spyware. I have lost count of my passwords at this point. I am running a scan right now, though it doesn't seem to do much good. It helps me to think that it is always the fifteenth round when I log in and try to write something. My recently posted short story, "God is Texting Me!" was altered overnight. I believe that I have made all necessary corrections, for now.

I can't be intimidated at this stage in my life. I am weirdly unafraid of anything and determined to persist in my struggle. I hope to face people who have harmed me -- along with many others -- also to find someone I love. I may not succeed in my effort to do these things. I promise you that, if I don't succeed, I will at least die trying to do them.

My review of The Da Vinci Code has generated a lot of controversy, including responses from persons who think of that novel as a kind of Gospel. Frightening. I am considering whether to include a revised and expanded version of the review in my forthcoming essay collection, which will make a lovely Christmas gift for one and all. Regrettably, my book will not be sent to online book-sellers. ("How Censorship Works in America" and "Censorship and Cruelty in New Jersey.")

I wish to reaffirm my commitment to the sanctity of same-sex love and equal marriage rights for gays and lesbians. You cannot beat up ideas. You do not prevail in discussions by censoring or suppressing the speech of adversaries. My quotations from Professor Boswell's book concerning Christ and St. John remain accurate. The continuing experience of censorship and violations of privacy is deeply painful to me, personally, but much more wounding to the Constitution of the United States of America. Someday, all of us will enjoy freedom of expression in America. ("Does Senator Menendez Have Mafia Friends?" and "Fidel Castro's 'History Will Absolve Me,'" then "American Hypocrisy and Luis Posada Carriles.")

Readers have expressed an interest in my comment concerning the "two Marys." Mary Magdalene and Mary the Mother of Jesus are aspects of the "eternal feminine" in Christianity that are always in relation. They should be seen to constitute a kind of dialectic. A stupid misreading of this idea is to believe that I am suggesting something like a crude Freudian dichotomy between madonna and whore, the mother/prostitute bifurcation appropriately detested by feminists. Some feminists' solution is to create an even more crude division between "good" (feminine) and "evil" (masculine), as evidenced by several responses to my essay-review of The Da Vinci Code.

Take a look at your son, if you have one, then tell me that every male child is inherently evil by virtue of his genitals, then explain -- in your next breath -- why it is wrong to judge women on the basis of their reproductive equipment. Such ludicrous forms of knee-jerk, sophomoric "femi-Nazism" are as loathsome as the sexism and misogyny they oppose. In fact, hatred of men is a kind of sexism.

The relation between the two "Marys" (I am told that "Maria" is too "ethnic") in Christian symbolism (there is no such thing as "symbology") is temporal as well as thematic. It is an attempt to articulate -- in the language of archetypes and images -- the idea that a woman's identity encompasses roles governed by the "biological clock" as well as culture, not to mention freedom or choice in reacting to or interpreting those roles, with love. What do those roles mean today? Wife? Mother? Daughter?

The crucifixion depicts a man suffering on the cross; but there is another crucifixion, usually unappreciated, taking place at the foot of the man on the cross. It is the suffering of women depicted in a mother's pain at the agony of a son, who is dying before her eyes; and a woman's pain at the suffering of a man she loves, from whom she is parted and whose extreme agony she knows very well -- since she is also LIVING IT -- and she has no choice about sharing in this agony. Among the sufferings of women forming traditional subjects in mythology and folklore is the absence of choice, powerlessness, the struggle against fate. I urge you to visit the Smithsonian Institute to see Leonardo's "Ginevra Di Benci." I will never regret or relent in my commitment to the women I love. ("The Soldier and the Ballerina" and "God is Texting Me!")

It is essential to woman's love, especially, that what happens to the beloved also happens to oneself. "Christianity thus advocates," Cynthia Freeland suggests, "typically female behaviors of caring, love, [empathy,] ... and compassion." The point being made by Professor Freeland is metaphorical. She is alluding to what is done by women, mostly, in our world, which is healing and repairing our moral wounds. Professor Freeland is also appealing to what is female in everyone, a quality that recognizes this need to comfort and care for others. The ritual of washing the feet at Easter is symbolic of this traditionally powerless role for women and others deemed "like" women, which is morally empowering for persons in such positions, who shall "inherit the earth." ("'The Reader': A Movie Review" and see the duality between Susan Sarandon's and Kate Winslet's characters, which are really one woman, in "Romance and Cigarettes.")

I invite you to read my short stories "The Soldier and the Ballerina" and "Pieta," then consider which character in each story is playing a more feminine role? Don't be fooled by what French critics describe as a literary character's "costume." ("The Taming of Somebody" and "Beauty and the Beast.")

See the faces of mothers whose sons return in body bags from war; look at the wives and sisters of those dead soldiers. Do they not suffer just as much or more than those wounded or dying men? I think so. Notice how those women cling to one another. Now I ask that you read my essay: "What is it like to be tortured?" How does a Jew become Mengele, Terry Tuchin? How can anyone bring about such suffering because it is "interesting" or because you can "learn from it" or for a "fee"? ("What is it like to be tortured?")

The two "Marys" are made one by embodying women's pains in this world at the sufferings of men they love, which adds to their own sufferings, in a way that no man's pain for a wife or mother equals. It works the other way too: Men hurt when women they love suffer. I can attest to that. Yet it is women who seem to have a special aptitude for suffering in this world since they are (usually) burdened with greater poverty and much less power than men.

Among important philosophers, the recent writings of Martha Nussbaum should be mentioned because she is concerned with these questions regarding the feminization of war and poverty. The part of me that suffers or hurts "for" others -- I know that this is paradoxical -- is feminine. Think of child-birth, joy at pain in giving life to another, an experience which is reflective of the ultimate paradox in all human life. The joy and sweetness we experience is always, partly, a result of life's fleeting character and the pain of loss in life.

Feminine identity is essentially relational, social, communal (Hegel); masculine identity is more individualistic, alienated, autonomous (Kant). These identities are choices or options for everyone. They are cultural phenomena and not necessarily biological. ("Judith Butler and Gender Theory," see also an essay which has been vandalized many times, "'Shoot 'Em Up": A Movie Review" as well as "'Holy Smoke': A Movie Review.")

This feminine aspect of "empathetic imagination" is also found in most men, including those who are unaware of it. Empathy is a feminine attribute: by hurting "for" others, men can find their feminine sides more easily. This takes courage. Admitting to such feelings takes even more courage for heterosexual men in sexist societies. These archetypal representations of feminine and masculine forms of suffering are within each of us. To divide the world into one good and another bad gender is to live in a highly simplistic and false setting. Worse, to deny half of your nature is to maim your own sensibilities and affective capacities.

"Female" is a concept equal to many things, including the unity of love and death in the paradox of identity as self-giving: Kenosis. ("'The American': A Movie Review.")

"Were not the Hegelians justified," writes Donald McKinnon, "in construing the Noli me Tangere of the risen Christ to Mary Magdalene in the record of the fourth Gospel as a concrete mythical expression of the demand that Christians discard the bondage of a false attachment to the details of a particular history, and adhere within themselves to a way of life which they must realize in circumstances altogether strange to those who first listened to Jesus?"

A woman's identity includes roles as lover and wife, mother and matriarch at different points in a life's journey. Identity for a woman is inclusive of eros, caritas, filia on a daily basis. Hence, what or who a woman is must be more complex and much more intersubjective than identity for a man.

Every woman you know will be both "Marys" -- the Magdalene and Virgin -- every day (at different moments) and, certainly, over her lifetime. These are points on a spectrum. The analogy to "acting" a role in life, Shakespeare's great metaphor, should be obvious. ("What you will ..." and "Shakespeare's Black Prince.")

The Hegelian "reaching-out" to others as social identity (Stillichkeit) can result in absorption of the other (masculine domination) or celebration of otherness (feminine pluralism). Both are human and universal. Which option do you like? ("'The French Lieutenant's Woman': A Review Essay" and "'Holy Smoke': A Movie Review.")

Women are the keepers of lived-time. Bergson's "time as duration" is a woman. Women weaving the texts of our lives is a common motif in world mythology: Woman is language-giver, time-keeper, nurturer and healer, companion at birth and death. Philosophical explorations of the concept of time have been better at recording time's feminine identity as opposed to scientific discussions of time's reduction to what is objectively discussable. Contrast Brian Greene, "The Frozen River," in The Fabric of the Cosmos (New York & London: Penguin, 2005), pp. 127-142 with Errol E. Harris, "Biological Time," in The Reality of Time (New York: SUNY, 1988), pp. 61-79. (Not surprisingly, the hour glass is a universal symbol of the womb and 9 month cycle of gestation.) ("A Review of the T.V. Show 'Alice.'")

Love the women in your life. Surprise her with a gift or a rose, make her laugh, sprinkle a little stardust into her evening. And don't forget to get the toilet paper and throw out the garbage while you're at it. And don't be home too late.