October 24, 2010 at 9:14 A.M. Two letters were altered in essays, other "errors" may have been inserted in writings with the goal of maximizing "frustration-inducement." I have done my best to correct all inserted "errors," often the identical corrections have been made dozens of times in this work.
July 28, 2010 at 4:17 P.M. I am shocked to discover "errors" inserted by hackers in a number of my essays. I can only hope to have made all necessary corrections.
August 24, 2009 at 10:43 A.M. This essay has received more than the usual number of attacks, defacements, and blocking of images. This may have to do with hatred of the Church. The Pope would say: "Pray for them." I will revise this work to correct errors inserted in it. I will attempt to attach an image to this essay-review, once again, then I will await further tampering and alterations, so as to make the same corrections once more. I am blocking:
http://ad.doubleclick.net/ad/N4359.MSN/B218937... (NJ)
New errors have, indeed, been discovered which were not found in my earlier versions of this essay. I will make the corrections again.
November 30, 2007 at 11:39 A.M. I received a call from 303-395-2345 and blocked:
http://view.atcmt.com/iview/msnnkhac001728x90xWBCBRB00110msn/direct;wi.728;hi.90/01 (NJ, OAE?)
More "errors" added and corrections made. November 2, 2008 at 9:38 P.M. This is actually better than I expected. I will wait overnight to re-post the essay, since several essays were vandalized today. More will probably be damaged tonight. My daughter is also experiencing difficulties with her lap top, for some reason. She complains of stomach pains. I am sure this is coincidental. I will continue to struggle.
People who hate Dan Brown's The Da Vinci Code and those who love it have had their say. No minds have been changed. Even a movie starring Tom Hanks -- who is upstaged by the city of Paris -- is now part of the Code experience. Mr. Brown's reviews have not been great, especially among scholars. Mr. Brown is making a lot of money and probably does not care very much what university professors think. I don't blame him.
The novel is standard pop entertainment which does not merit much commentary. Mr. Brown has laced his potboiler with allusions to scholarly works, bizarre criticisms of the Catholic Church, allegations of a conspiracy to suppress the "truth" about Jesus and Mary Magdalene, woven an allegory concerning the quest for the Holy Grail into his plot and made a number of controversial historical and philosophical claims, not to mention allegations concerning the "meaning" of several great works of art by Leonardo and others. All of this literary game-playing is just kind of thrown into a very thin text and mixed together. It is difficult to know where to begin to impose order on Brown's chaos. When it comes to the history of art, "Leonardo" is kind of like Elvis in Las Vegas -- you only need a first name.
I will first summarize the plot and Brown's most important symbolism, without giving away too much, in case someone has not yet read his book. Then I will examine some of Brown's theological claims and charges against the Church (which are mostly ludicrous); next, I will focus on Brown's interpretive claims concerning famous works of art and various texts; finally, I will say a word or two about the role of Mary Magdalene and women in Christianity.
Dan Brown is no theologian. He is not a historian, mythologist, nor a philosopher. Brown's book is pulp fiction and no more. Do NOT take it seriously. Incidentally, the name Mary the Magdalene or Magdelen is a subject of dispute among historians. If you are interested in the themes inadequately or incompetently explored in The Da Vinci Code -- which are certainly important and fascinating to me -- then there are many fine novels available where you will find them better discussed and more accurately analyzed.
My suggestions for those who are interested in the feminine principle or "sacred feminine" and in literary explorations of this theme today, is to read A.S. Byatt's novels, especially The Game (New York: Vintage, 1992). Also, Lindsay Clarke's The Chymical Wedding (London: Picador, 1990). Gore Vidal's Julian (New York: Random House, 1962) will guide you through the first centuries of Christianity, so will Anthony Burgess in The Kingdom of the Wicked (New York: Arbor House, 1985). I strongly recommend a book that I have read only in parts because it is difficult to find: Marina Warner, Alone of All Her Sex: The Myth and the Cult of the Virgin Mary (New York: Random House, 1976) and Tikva Frymer-Kensky, In The Wake of the Goddess: Women, Culture, and the Biblical Transformations of Pagan Myth (New York: Free Press, 1992), pp. 32-44 (women-goddesses as the collective source of intellectual and artistic life).
Those who are more philosophically inclined should consult Robert C. Solomon, Love, Emotion, Myth and Metaphor (New York: Prometheus, 1990) and Robert C. Solomon & Kathleen M. Higgins, The Philosophy of Erotic Love (Kansas: University of Kansas, 1991). On the Grail myth, see Emma Jung & Marie-Louise Von Franz, The Grail Legend (Coventure, 1986); and compare Anne Barring & Jules Cashford, The Myth of the Goddess (London: Viking, 1991), with Robert Graves, The White Goddess (which I can not find on my shelves), also Lindsay Clarke's retelling of Parzival (London: Thorsons, 2001).
For historians, you can not do better than Professor Elaine Pagels, Adam, Eve, and the Serpent (New York: Random House, 1988) on the gnostic texts and women's role(s) in early Christianity. Also, take a look at Edward Gibbon's Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire. Notice A.S. Byatt's use of "serpents" as phallic (evil?) metaphors, then Iris Murdoch and Mircea Eliade on "Sacred and Profane Loves." (See also Evelyn Waugh's masterpiece, Brideshead Revisited.) Finally, Louis Mackey's "Eros Into Logos: The Rhetoric of Courtly Love," in The Philosophy of Erotic Love, p. 336 is a must. Irving Singer's second volume in his massive work The Nature of Love should be compared with Denis De Rougemont's Love in the Western World.
Woman or the feminine principle in Jungian analytical psychology is the "other self" that opens the door to the personal and collective subconscious, equally, usually one woman or a duality of women perform this role and not just for individuals, also for entire cultures. Maria Luisa Von Franz, "The Anima: The Woman Within," in Carl Jung: Man and His Symbols (New York: Dell, 1964), pp. 195-196, then Walter Pater, "Mona Lisa" in Harold Bloom, ed., Selected Writings of Walter Pater (New York: New American Library, 1974), pp. 31-52 (Mona Lisa is "our muse ... mistress of unity in being") and Kenneth Clark, "Mona Lisa," in Leonardo da Vinci (London: Penguin, 1963), pp. 110-113. ( "Mona Lisa is one of those works of art which each generation must reinterpret.") Please see my essay, "Arthur Schopenhauer and The Metaphysics of Art."
For an ironic destruction of Brown's claims, see Sigmund Freud's Leonardo Da Vinci (New York: Vintage, 1947), pp. 76-77 suggesting that Mona Lisa captures the duality of women when, as now appears likely, the work is partly a self-portrait of the artist. Freud's difficulties with Leonardo's "androgynous nature" and the impossibility of fitting this awesome genius within Freud's homophobic and sexist view of life was a source of perplexity for the good Viennese doctor who misperceived the duality that Leonardo wished to depict. Maybe Freud could have used some therapy. Sherwin B. Nuland, Leonardo Da Vinci (London: Phoenix, 2000), pp. 59-81 (The lowdown on "The Last Supper.") Still the standard work, according to Mr. Nuland, on Leonardo's mind is Edward McCurdy's The Mind of Leonardo Da Vinci (London: Jonathan Cape, 1928) and I am currently completing Robert Payne's Leonardo (New York: Doubleday & Co., 1978), pp. 194-204 ("The Importunities of Isabella De Este").
Mythologically and psychologically, Joseph Campbell's "The Mythology of Love," in Myths to Live By (New York: Bantam, 1972), at p. 152 is a work to which I will refer later in this essay. Augustine and Plato are the classic sources in this area, then Shakespeare and (sadly) Freud's essay, again, on Leonardo Da Vinci should be looked at, though Jung is much better on these issues. Hans Urs Von Balthazar in Love Alone is Credible (San Francisco: Ignatius, 1961), p. 56 speaks of "absolute love," which is represented in feminine terms in the form of the Holy Spirit (one symbolic meaning of spread wings as embrace is clear):
"The plausibility of God's love does not become apparent through any comparative reduction to what man has always already understood as love; rather, it is illuminated only by the self-interpreting revelation-form of love itself. And this form is so majestic that we are led to adore it from a reverent distance whenever we perceive it, [like a "great lady,"] even if it does not explicitly command us to do so."
The association of perfect love with the distant lady of Platonic adoration in courtly romances is not difficult to trace, neither is the emergence in the twelfth century of the cult of the Virgin Mary. To get a full blast of the power of feminine love and the "sacred feminine" in Christianity, I suggest that you stand, as I did, before the rose window at Notre Dame Cathedral in Paris. I promise you that, as the sun shines through the centuries-old stained glass, very early in the morning, you will understand the centrality of feminine as well as masculine representations of divine love in Christianity. Augustine, then Pico Della Mirandola, and the Florentine Neo-Platonists at the home of Lorenzo de Medici ("Il Magnifico") -- where the young Michelangelo absorbed this Platonism -- should be mentioned. Hence, Michelangelo's "Pieta" (both the early high Renaissance and late Mannerist version of this image) are works shaped by Platonism. Michelangelo's "Mary" is Woman, the ancient goddess of the Mediterrenean world, who remains ageless and eternally loving. (My short story "Pieta" touches on many of these themes.)
I. The Da Vinci Code: Rose and Cross.
A. The Plot.
"Robert Langdon" is a "symbologist" (there is no such thing, by the way) at Harvard University, who is lecturing in Paris. He is brought to the Louvre to find that a colleague "Jack Sauniere" is murdered, but has left a number of clues to a mystery which the novel will seek to unravel. The murder victim has arranged himself in the form of Leonardo's drawing of "The Vitruvian Man," which is mistakenly described as a representation of the masculine subjection to the feminine, as a clue to goddess worship, or some such nonsense. (See pp. 38-39.)
Sauniere has also found time to write invisible clues on a number of Leonardo's masterpieces, while bleeding to death very painfully. Brown's discussion of the meaning of Leonardo's naming of the "Mona Lisa," incidentally, is rendered ludicrous by the fact that this was not Leonardo's name for the painting, but Vasari's much later title for the work. (See pp. 129-131.) For Leonardo, the portrait was called "La Gioconda." No, this is not to be confused with Ponchielli's Opera, Gioconda. (Like "Enzo," I am now singing "Ciello e' Mar.")
It is doubtful that Leonardo would have called this partial self-portrait "Mona Lisa," since the work is much more obviously a religious work and a form of veiled autobiography as well as a philosophical essay. For Leonardo, the distant lady of Platonic adoration was a young man called "Salai" and (sometimes) Saleri, but not Mozart's nemesis, "Salieri." Emil Moller, "Salai und Leonardo Da Vinci," in Jarbuch der kunst historichen Sammlungen in Wien (1928), pp. 139-161. This work is avaliable in German and French. For those who prefer to have others do the legwork, try Charles Nicholl's recent massive biography that explores this crucial relationship. Salai is Mary/Mary Magdalene for Leonardo Da Vinci. Any person who earns that sort of love is welcome, since it is the love itself that is "holy." Next, try Shakespeare's Sonnets. (Look at the face of Leonardo's "Bacchus" and then at the smile of Mona Lisa.)
Narrative plausibility has been lost in The Da Vinci Code for the sake of allegory. And the allegory is not so hot either. The five pointed star has any number of symbolic interpretations, usually having to do with universal harmony. It is a distant cousin of China's Ying/Yang symbol. The deeper meaning of Leonardo's drawing I will leave for later in this review.
"Sophie Neveu" is a grandaughter of the murdered man. She is the intended recipient of several of his clues, also serving as the "Babe" found in every guy's action novel, which is strange in a supposedly feminist work. I would have preferred Irene Jacob in the movie, but that's just me. Mr. Brown obviously wants to make some money and has a little fantasy of his own going on. He clearly loves the idea of teaching a beautiful French ingenue all about the Grail myth by displaying his own vast erudition, which is (regrettably) non-existent.
"Oh, Dan ... You are sooo smart." These words, when spoken by -- let us, say, Juliet Binoche or Julie Delpy, maybe Irene Jacob or Emmanuelle Beart -- definitely can make your evening special. I am with you on that, Dan. Unfortunately, it is the kind of thing that rarely happened to me when I was very young. Women I met in discos rarely wished to discuss, say, Kant's derivation of the categories in the Critique of Pure Reason.
The reference here is to the Grail quest of legend: Sauniere is "Amfortas" (dead this time, not just wounded), Sophie is "La Belle Dame" of courtly romance, and Robert is the "knight of sound heart," who proves as much in answering his teacher's ("Philemon's"?) questions. By answering these questions, Robert finds a path through the forest. The result of all this madness is the alleged association of the Grail with the historical person of Mary Magdalene, strangely identified as the feminine principle and inheritor of the goddess myth (what happened to the Virgin Mary?), wife of Jesus and source of woman's power, neglected by the, allegedly, "evil" Catholic Church. ("Duality in Christian Feminine Identity.")
The two Marys are actually aspects of a single set of relations associated with femininity that are always in balance or interaction. See again Marina Warner's work on "transformations" and her book, Alone of All of Her Sex. Compare Leonardo's drawing of "The Virgin with St. Anne" with Vidal's Two Sisters. Da Vinci returned to the theme of the Virgin and St. Anne on several occasions, not only in his painting of the "Virgin of the Rocks," but also in numerous drawings where the image of the Virgin and young Christ/Apollo/Bacchus are overlaid. The central image of Christ in the last supper may be superimposed on Leonardo's drawings of the Virgin with surprising results, a point not seen or noted by Mr. Brown. (See Kenneth Clark above, also Charles Nichols' recent biography of Leonardo, again, which I enjoyed at the cafe at Barnes and Noble just before returning the book to the shelf.)
Instructive in pursuing this discussion concerning feminine duality or ambiguity is A.S. Byatt's transformation of "Melusina" in Possession for obvious feminist purposes and (less obvious, but much more interesting) erotic goals. The myth of the "serpent"-woman dates, at least, from the seventeenth century. For those who are curious, you cannot do better than Marina Warner, From the Beast to the Blond: On Fairy Tales and Their Tellers (New York: Farrar, Straus & Giroux, 1994), pp. 4-9.
Opus Dei's albino monk (there is no order of Opus Dei monks, folks, so you can relax!) is running around assassinating people in the novel. Supposedly, this is because the Church does not wish this information about Mary Magdalene to get out. Meanwhile, the Church has made these texts available to scholars for years and will be placing many of them on line, free of charge, for students. Others are available in libraries around the world, including the Gospel of Mary Magdalene, who happens to be Saint Mary Magdalene, whether or not she was a prostitute.
Was she a prostitute or wasn't she? "Only her hairdresser knows for sure," as an old t.v. commercial used to say. I have news for you: It is irrelevant to her status as a Saint in Catholicism. Jesus felt great love for this woman, who is described in any number of the gnostic texts as "the beloved Apostle," and placed his trust in her. Magdalene played a leading role in the early years of the Church, as explained by Elaine Pagels and others. Jesus has rightly been called the first great feminist, though "Eve" deserves that honor. Mary Magdalene, along with many women, discharged priestly functions in the first years of Christianity, a point which is made by Professor Pagels. We even had a "Pope Joan." Some scholars describe Mary Magdalene as the first Pope.
Many of the women posing for nudes and as saints in Renaissance pantings and in later epochs, especially in Venice, happened to be prostitutes. It is entirely possible that worshippers in many of the great churches in Europe have been admiring and adoring some of the best whores of sixteenth and seventeenth century Italy. I don't blame them at all. Titian is having a chuckle right about now. ("'The American': A Movie Review.")
I am confident that women will return to leadership roles in the Church soon, probably in less than a century. I may even live to see another woman sit on the Thrown of Peter. See Nancy M. Malone, Walking a Literary Labyrinth: A Spirituality of Reading (New York: Riverhead Books, 2003), pp. 149-179. Ms. Malone led me to Elizabeth Johnson's theological writings -- which I have only glanced at, since her book is not cheap at $27.00! -- but her works are recommended, especially to those with some training in philosophy and theology. For a discussion of the feminine in our understanding of divinity, see Professor Johnson's She Who Is.
I believe that Professor Johnson (Fordham) is a religious person. She is highly talented and learned, exceptionally philosophically adept -- based on what I have seen and read of her book -- providing readers with an exploration of divinity, as feminine, within the Catholic tradition and beyond. Peter Stanford, The Legend of Pope Joan: In Search of the Truth (New York: Berkeley Books, 2000), pp. 84-98. (Eroticism and homosexual love in the Church of the Middle Ages.) Elizabeth Johnson, She Who Is: The Mystery of God in Feminist Theological Discourse (New York: Crossroad, 1992). (Why your mother was right.)
Robert and Sophie figure out all of these clues, discover Mary's final resting place and (in the movie, anyway, over a three minute "close up") find "the" Grail. I figured out how the plot would unfold around page 90. This novel is, to use medieval Latin, shlock. In the words of St. Woody of Allen, "Yes, but they'll definitely sell a lot of books!" True, Woody, unfortunately there are people who will take this novel seriously. Don't, boys and girls, it's just fun and games. There is not a shred of evidence that Jesus and Mary Magdalene married, had children, or ever lived in Connecticut while driving a station wagon to bingo games on Saturday night. ("'Revolutionary Road': A Movie Review.")
Despite the angry resistance to this assertion, there is no such thing as "symbology." The Da Vinci Deception (Pennsylvania: Ascension Press, 2006), p. 17 points out: "... there is no academic discipline known as symbology." There are semiotics and semiology. Symbols are only one kind of sign, so that a discipline called "semiotics" includes what Langdon calls "symbology." These terms and academic fields are confused by Mr. Brown, who also is not too clear on the meaning of "hermeneutics." Try Umberto Eco's The Name of the Rose and A Theory of Semiotics.
Next, the issue of characters' names is always important in reading literature. Robert "Langdon" may refer to "langue d'oc" or the southern French kingdom (anybody seen the "Merovingian?") where troubadors invented the twelfth century courtly romances "inspiring" this novel. Lancelot and Parzifal hover in the background of this character's persona. While you're at it, look up the "Carolingian" dynasty and the "Cathars." Forget Holy Blood, Holy Grail. Try this baby: Leopold Von Ranke, History of the Popes: Their Church and State, Three Volumes (New York: Frederick Ungar, 1966), Volumes I & II, up to Leo X. (Lots of gay sex in the Medieval clergy.) Either "Parsifal" or "Parsival" is hunky-dory.
"Sophie Neveu" is the "New Wisdom" meant to replace the "Good News" of the Canonical Gospels. The Da Vinci Code is supposed to be a new Gospel? Lots of luck, Dan. There are so many historical errors that a quite lengthy essay might be devoted merely to listing them. Why bother? I plan to concentrate on two colossal blunders of substantive interpretation or understanding that undermine this work as anything other than pop entertainment. This method of criticism is hermeneutic in the true meaning of the word.
First, I examine the antihistorical blunder of interpreting ancient texts and symbols -- dating from the first century of the Christian era (or earlier) -- in terms of themes, meanings and canons of construction associated with the courtly romances of the late medieval era, around the thirteenth century. Second, I point to Brown's failure to appreciate the theological significance or meaning of the Grail myth in terms of a Christian universe of metaphors and theological principles communicated to a mostly illiterate population, by means of symbols, just as the first stirrings of the Renaissance began to be felt. Brown fails to grasp both the theological purposes of the Grail story and its historical significance. The crucial work at this point is Huizinga's The Waning of the Middle Ages.
Finally, a return to Brown's sources is wise for serious students, Elaine Pagels, The Gnostic Gospels (New York: Vintage, 1979), pp. 64-67 notes the difference between the Gnostic texts and later Gospels concerning the role of women. Jesus is represented in the earliest texts of Christianity as speaking most closely and respectfully to Mary Magdalene, something which the other apostles could not accept: "But if the saviour made her worthy, who are you indeed, to reject her?" (Gospel of Thomas)
This selection of Magdalene as the "beloved apostle" and Peter as "fisher of men" has been interpreted as a division of power between masculine and feminine personas, as EQUALS, in the governance of the Christian Church. Later institutional judgments and political calculations -- especially, in the 4th century Council of Nicea -- altered this dynamic by disempowering women, who immediately regained power, indirectly, both in the medieval world when women were among the few educated "thinkers" (Hildegard of Bherens) and power-brokers, as well as in the early Renaissance when women were tough negotiators for kingdoms and wealth.
The Medici women ruled through their men, until dispensing with them by means of a little poison now and then. Some things never change. After all, it was "Catharina" of the Medici clan (at age fifteen) who developed an amorous interest in Michelangelo, insisting to the skeptics that the young man had some talent. History seems to confirm her opinions as sound.
B. Rose and Cross.
Mr. Brown also fails to understand the protean quality of great symbols. Like great art, symbols have different meanings in alternative chronological and cultural settings. In fact, symbols are found in most great art. These symbols resonate with meanings that multiply down through the centuries. They are not a treasure map or a police report pointing to one specific meaning or location, but explosions of associations delivering archetypal wisdom to the human psyche. Among the richest such symbols -- for me, the very richest -- are the "cross and rose," which are connected to Hebrew theology (rose is a distant cousin of the five pointed star) and also to pagan mythology and Mithraic mysteries. Symbolic communication, again, was vital in the medieval world since the bulk of the population was illiterate:
"God gave man two sources of knowledge, the Book of Scripture and the Book of Nature. Behind each are hidden meanings to be searched out; the universe is a vast cryptogram to be decoded. The history of Job's sufferings, for example, has, on the surface, a value as a great human story; secondly, it prefigures Christ's death; and thirdly, it represents the trials of the Christian soul. All that is red reminds artist and writer of the blood of Jesus, every stream brings a remembrance of rebirth through baptism, fishermen lowering their nets remind men of their redemption, the crab walking sideways makes one think of the fraudulent, and the Pelican, which was supposed to nourish its young with its own blood, was the analogue of Christ. There was no end to this type of symbolism inside the mind of the Middle Ages."
Frederick B. Artz, The Mind of the Middle Ages: An Historical Survey A.D. 200-1500 (Chicago: Phoenix, 1980), p. 377; and C.S. Lewis, The Allegory of Love (New York: Oxford, 1958), pp. 112-157 ("The Romance of the Rose"). One of the great errors by commentators and a myth among contemporary "educated" persons is the so-called body-hating and antierotic quality of Catholicism. There is a turning away from the flesh in one Catholic interpretation of Platonism, but there is also a spiritualized eroticism which is expressed through the body. Reservations concerning lust are not relevant to the celebration of eros, as in Bernini's depiction of "St. Teresa in Ecstasy," which has always been identified with the approach to God.
The great British scholar and writer Desmond Stewart in The Foreigner: A Search for the First Century Jesus, traces Jesus (at least in terms of myth) to Africa, specifically, Egypt, and connects the "myth of the Christ" to Platonism. Anthony Burgess, "Christography," in But Do Blondes Prefer Gentlemen? (New York: McGraw Hill, 1986), pp. 30-32. ("Desmond Stewart" will be changed to "Desmond Morris" by hackers on a regular basis -- knock yourselves out.)
The letters of Abelard and Heloise may be helpful on this matter of Christ and Platonic "Eros." Many mystics describe the approach to divinity as akin to orgasmic bliss -- for instance, St. John of the Cross or St. Teresa of Avila, whose pre-Freudian imagery concerning the angel who visited her "with a long golden spear which penetrated her" is pretty explicit. St. John of the Cross is unaware of writing highly erotic literature in describing his ascent from the "dark night of the soul." Some of the filthiest imagery is found in the unconsciously erotic writings of Christian celibates. The erotic power and hidden images in the letters of Heloise to Abelard are as devastating as the highly charged prose of the most lurid and explicit writers of the twentieth century:
"You know, my beloved, as the whole world knows, how much I have lost in you, how at one wretched stroke of fortune that supreme act of flagrant treachery robbed me of my very self in robbing me of you; and how my sorrow for my loss is nothing compared with what I feel for the manner in which I lost you." (Heloise to Abelard!)
The Letters of Abelard and Heloise (London; Penguin, 1974), p. 113.
Symbolizing becomes a prominent feature of Western literature, once again, in the nineteenth century with Romanticism and French symbolist poetry, see Frank Kermode, Romantic Image (London: Routledge, 1957) and Michael Roberts, T.E. Hulme (Manchester: Carcanet, 1982). Symbols operate at a deeper than conscious level and feature in all great cinema. Spielberg's A.I. is a mythic text that deserves to be included with the great religious narratives of our history. To do justice to that film you will need to spend weeks studying the history of art, mythology, political philosophy, psychology of children, fairy tales and much more. In addition to Hinduism, A.I. is Spielberg's Catholic masterpiece. I am aware that Steven Spielberg is Jewish.
The influence of this form of symbolic thinking and communication can be found in the great surrealists, from Salvador Dali to Jean Cocteau. "Transmogrification" or "syncretism" points to the universality of religious themes or concerns. It does not undermine religious faith. A reading of Joseph Campbell would have helped Brown to write a better book. There is a wealth of scholarship concerning Cuban and Brazilian "Santeria" that is also relevant to these issues. The blending of pagan and Christian themes ("love/death") is one obvious example of "layering" in mythic narratives. ("'Inception': A Movie Review.")
Science lovers should note that this concern on the part of Catholic monks, mostly, to "read the book of nature" during the late medieval period led to the methods and interests of the Italian Quatrocentro and to the rebirth of humanism, a new secularism, and the scientific revolution, not to mention a little thing called "Capitalism." The Grail is only very superficially interpreted as concerned with any single woman or historical figure, since it is too powerful a myth in Western Civilization for such a reading to be plausible. It is about much more complex and profound themes of a theological and philosophical nature rooted in Christianity and Judaism, also older than both of those religions. Africa gave birth to many of these themes. For example, the myths of feminine divinity are found in ancient Egypt, where Isis holds the dying Osiris (as Mary will hold Jesus), also in many works of art that have survived from antiquity. I regret that racists may be upset to learn this historical fact. Actually, I don't mind upsetting racists. You may wish to insert another "error" right about now.
These images and archetypes form the background for "seminal" discussions of love among ancient philosophers, such as the dialectic in Plato's Symposium. There is a lineage from Isis to Socrates' philosophical partner "Diotima," but also from this Greek figure's theory of love to the Virgin Mary by way of Pauline Christianity, then Augustine and Neo-Platonism. A multi-year conversation about love and civilization beginning with the ancients and culminating with the so-called "death of eros" in our time is a complete education in the humanities and human sciences. These themes recur not only in later Christianity, also in Judaism, notably in Cabala (Campbell's spelling). Jacob Burckhardt, The Civilization of the Renaissance in Italy (London: Middlemore, 1944), then John Hall, The Civilization of Europe in the Renaissance (New York: MacMillan , 1994). (Harold Bloom's essay on kaballah is highly recommended to Jews and non-Jews.)
The "Jewish Jesus" is the interpretation of Jesus in light of the Jewish people's hope and idealization -- in a later post-exilic setting -- of an Annointed one or Messiah, who appeared or was sought as "symbol of unity and fulfillment of Scriptures," to compensate for the many sufferings and tragedies of Israel. Jaroslav Pelikan states bluntly, in Jesus Through the Centuries (New York: Harper & Row, 1985), p. 11: "... Jesus was a Jew." Those who are under the impression that Jesus was, say, Belgian, are simply mistaken. I always recommend reading the books of theologians who get in trouble with the Catholic Church. Inevitably, these are the reigning theologians a generation after their troubles. For example, on Cristology, see Edward Schillebeeckx, Christ: The Christian Experience in the Modern World (London: SCM, 1980) and Hans Kung, Christianity: Its Essence and History (London: SCM, 1995). Joseph Campbell explains a more interesting difficulty:
"In Christian hermeneutics the crucifixion of the Savior had always presented a great problem; for Jesus according to Christian belief, accepted death voluntarily. Why? In Abelard's view ... it was an act of willing self-immolation in love, intended to invoke in response the return of mankind's love from worldly concerns to God. ... " ("The Soldier and the Ballerina.")
This leads to a startling claim:
"Indeed, the very idea of a descent of God into the world in love to invoke, in return, man's love to God, ... [leads to the insight that] as mankind yearns for the grace of God, so God [yearns] for the hommage [or love] of mankind, the two yearnings being reciprocal." ("Pieta.")
Myths to Live By, p. 158. ("Is this atheism's moment?")
The union of Christ with his "bride," the Church -- of the Holy Spirit with Her suffering children, humanity -- is symbolized by the Grail. The Grail is the place of transcendence, beyond opposites: male or female, young or old, good or evil. The Grail is the "unity of the Holy Spirit." This worship of the feminine -- as unity or nurturing care in the form of the Virgin Mary -- is a Medieval idea, based on Hellenistic Platonism, which would have seemed strange to Jesus. Jesus was closer to the mystics of Judaism and classical thinkers for whom sex was not a source of guilt or "displaced." The worship of the feminine in most other cultures is explicitly erotic. Catholicism makes eros a symbolic feature of feminine images of the Virgin Mary who is usually represented as youthful as well as maternal.
There are similar figures to Jesus in the history of Judaism, i.e., the Bel Shemtov and other distinguished mystical rabbis who taught by example, mostly figures emerging in the Hebrew Enlightenment of the eighteenth century among Ashkenazi jewry. If you do not like the fact that Jesus was certainly a Jew, too bad.
This key phrase with crucial "loving" overtones ("in the unity of the Holy Spirit") is still spoken in celebrating the Catholic mass. The phrase points to the homecoming of humanity in, with, and to God, which is ultimate self-realization. Integration of feminine and masculine, human and divine with love is "Being." This is the so-called "Christianizing of Eros." To be is to be with others in a loving manner of self-realization. Now take another look at Da Vinci's drawing of "The Vitruvian Man." What do you think the drawing is saying about the UNITY of human and divine? You have forty minutes. The real title of Da Vinci's drawing is "in the unity of the Holy Spirit."
The "meaning" of the great Christian symbols is the unity of the rose (feminine) and cross (masculine) in the person or Being of Christ, who transcends all opposites. God is beyond gender. Such a transcendence is LOVE, which is the Kingdom of Heaven. In the Gospel of Thomas, Jesus tells his puzzled Apostles: "The Kingdom of Heaven is within you ... and you do not see it."
The Kingdom of Heaven is not a place, but a state of being with God which is symbolized by the Grail. Loving someone is that state of being with God. Biologists tell us that all human embryos begin as both masculine and feminine in posse. (Potentiality) One theological interpretation of this fact is that we return to a state beyond gender in coming home to God/Love. Please read my essay "Judith Butler and Gender Theory" and "Pieta." Both of those works have been subjected to a great deal of vandalism, along with this essay. Judith Butler will be astonished to learn that she is one of our best Catholic theologians. ("Judith Butler and Gender Theory.")
"The Grail finds you," Sophie says, echoing Wolfram Von Eschenbach medieval author of "Parzival." Unfortunately, neither Dan Brown nor his character, Sophie, understands what this means. It means that you already have the Grail. You had it from birth. It is within you. It is called LOVE. Von Eschenbach's purpose, as Campbell explains, was to dramatize the fulfillment of human nature for which we hope: "... the achievement of that supreme spiritual goal of which the grail [sic.] was the medieval symbol."
To search outside of yourself for the Grail, as an object or person, is a doomed venture. The Grail is your love directed towards others. By finding love within yourself, you will discover (by creating) love in the world. This finding of love within yourself is your encounter with what you may call "God."
II. Defending the Catholic Church.
It has become fashionable to attack Catholic institutions and the Vatican as evil. The Vatican is a human institution, which readily admits to fallibility -- as does the Pope -- on all earthly or political matters. I am not claiming to be a good Catholic, by the way. I am not in any official capacity with any Catholic organization. Yet I find these attacks on Catholicism as well as the Church increasingly irrational and annoying. The Pope -- no Pope -- condones child molestation by anyone.
It is in terms of the Vatican's attitudes to women and outdated notions of gender that criticism should be taken seriously by this Pope and his successors. To deem "instant excommunication" appropriate for anyone who ordains a woman as a priest is to seek to excommunicate Christ who clearly held Mary Magdalene in this priestly regard. Given the hesitation in excommunicating priests charged with child molestation this official harshness towards women is offensive and absurd.
The "doctrine of infallibility" has to do with narrow issues of faith in Catholic theology, which is rarely invoked, and never about political or administrative matters in which Church officials may be involved. There are some bad priests. There are some bad anything you like -- dentists, cab drivers, plumbers, all have been known to be both good and not-so-good. Only lawyers are universally admired for their moral beauties.
The Vatican is an institution doing charitable work in many places in the world, caring for the sick, feeding the hungry, serving and educating children and young people who, otherwise, may not be educated. I am one of the recipients of Catholic schooling. However, the Pope certainly should not be held responsible for my disturbing opinions. In many instances, the Church is doing these valuable services free of charge. The Vatican is not the source of evil in the world. The Pope's recent visit to Auschwitz (where many Christians also died) is part of a continuing effort at reconciliation and love directed at the Jewish people, whose suffering and history must be shared. Priests can be mistaken about moral issues, like any of us. There are some vicious and bizarre anti-Catholic attacks in this novel and contemporary society:
"What about those who look at the cruelty in the world and say, where is God today? Those who look at the Church scandals and ask, who ARE these men who claim to speak the truth about Christ and yet lie to cover-up the sexual abuse of children by their own priests? ... What happens ... if persuasive scientific evidence comes out that the church's version of the Christ story is inaccurate, and that the greatest story ever told is, in fact, the greatest story ever SOLD." (p. 288.)
These words are spoken by Teabing in The Da Vinci Code, but they clearly meet with Mr. Brown's approval. Similar comments are scattered throughout the text. To refer in these terms to the leadership of any religious group in America would be shocking. Somehow it is permissible to refer to Catholics or the Vatican in these terms, which disproves many of these allegations, since the Church has not ordered a fatwa against Dan Brown. The Church only points out that Brown is mistaken and that his book is not exactly Shakespeare. I agree on both counts. Scriptures are not an accountant's statement of assets and liabilities. "Accuracy" in discerning the message contained in these sacred texts is a more subtle and profound process of interpretation. ("Incoherence in 'The New Yorker'" and "Is this atheism's moment?")
I wish to deal with these charges in detail. First, "where is God today?" This is an issue debated, at length by Catholic theologians, by Christians and non-Christians. As Kierkegaard noted, when you ask this question, you are already revealing an obsession and concern with God suggesting that you cannot avoid the problem of faith. If you reject God, then you are making a theological judgment. You are involved with God, even in rejecting Him. If you despair, says Kierkegaard, that is excellent because it means you are very close to Him. "Why despair? Are you missing something or someone?" Kierkegaard poses these annoying questions. Guess who it might be that you are missing? We love other human beings, in Catholic teaching, because we see God within them. (See again my story "Pieta.") What do you think Holy Communion symbolizes?
Yes, some priests have committed sexual offenses and the Church has disciplined them and cooperated with the authorities in seeing them punished. Also, millions have been paid for compensation of injured persons in civil suits, often (tragically) at the cost of the Church's charitable work. You have said NOTHING about Catholicism by pointing to individuals who are flawed in the Church. There are no "unflawed" persons, not even in radical political movements where atheism is a trendy opinion and people munch on tofu at lunch time as they peruse The Village Voice.
If only New Jersey's Supreme Court and legal system were as concerned to do the ethically and legally correct thing as the Vatican, I might receive recognition of my injuries and appropriate apologies. Instead, I am afraid that we can expect more vandalism of these writings and censorship. I believe the number of hits at these blogs has now passed 100,000. MSN has not closed, mysteriously enough, although I still cannot reach my sites. How curious?
I am an agnostic, in the sense of not believing in a personal God with a white beard floating around in heaven. I am also a democratic socialist (so are many Catholics). I do not read Scriptures as literal accounts of anything. To do that, to read religious texts as police reports, is to diminish those texts. Not all religious persons are fundamentalists. Not everyone who recognizes the importance of human spirituality is ignorant or foolish. I think it is foolish to deny human spirituality. What the word and imagery associated with the concept of "God" points to is the awesome mystery of love. The ambiguity in great religious texts is deliberate in many cases because they are invitations to interpret that are respectful of human freedom.
There is no possible evidence that can show that religious stories are false because categories of empirical, historical, literal truth and falsehood are irrelevant to religious texts. Such texts are concerned with meaning and moral truth, as well as life-wisdom. Religion is a symbolic language-structure connected to the release of universal archetypal wisdom, which (if denied in ancient forms and texts) will reveal itself in science or commerce, in all other aspects of life, because it is fundamental to humans, like the morality to which it is allied. You cannot eradicate religion, which "re-connects" (re ligare) people with their nation, species, universe and (for believers) with God.
Now I am going to shock Catholics. It makes no difference if Jesus "married" (how do you define "marriage"?) Mary Magdalene, whom he obviously loved. The truth that Jesus intended to communicate, I believe, he succeeded in communicating. That truth is concerned with love and meaning for everyone. It is deeply rooted in Hebrew culture and history. The Christian Scriptures tell us, in every line, that Jesus is a Jew. If you see Mel Gibson's "The Passion of the Christ," the Aramaic word for God is "Abba," which means "father" and links "Jeshua" (Jesus) to an ancient Hebrew tradition associating God with a loving (but stern) father. Yes, I know the Freudians are salivating. Ignore them. Hence, anti-semitism is hatred of Jesus. None of this precludes us from sending Bernie Madoff to prison for theft by deception.
Religious truth is so powerful, psychologically, that it can only be conveyed by means of symbols. Pay attention to the symbols in the scriptures. Read them as important and meaningful poetry. The best I can do to approximate the ethical and spiritual truth at the center of Christianity is to recall the image of the Grail, as individuation or moral self-realization in unity with others, or full humanity. Now take another look at Spielberg's A.I.
In "The Spirit of Christianity," Hegel concludes that "love heals all wounds [because it] is the only solution to the severing of the human being into warring aspects." Most of us are fragmented, divided against ourselves and from one another, body from soul or spirit, masculine from feminine, material striving from happiness, desire from consumption, sex from love. We yearn for integration and meaning through purposefulness. That meaning and purpose that we desire is, and can only be, love. It is love which reconciles us to one another -- even to our enemies -- by not allowing us to do to them what they have done to us. I don't want to deface anyone's writings nor to rape or steal from others. I leave such things to members of the bar in New Jersey. ("Terry Tuchin, Diana Lisa Riccioli, and New Jersey's Agency of Torture" and "What is it like to be tortured?")
It is only love that allows us to embrace the alienated parts of ourselves, or others who are similarly alienated -- poor people, AIDS victims, old and mentally ill people, our own baser selves. Love allows all that is lost in life -- every person we love who is separated from us -- to be recovered, or returned to us. It is love alone which restores life to itself. With love, fate is reconciled. The Christian ethics of love I know is true and important. I find a similar message in Judaism and Islam, also in other world religions and in secular ethics. The message is that, with love, "everything we look upon is blessed." ("Beauty and the Beast.") Hegel says:
"... the stings of conscience are blunted and the evil spirit is expelled from the deed." This reconciliation is Holderlin's "rose in the cross." Hyperion (1797-91). Furthermore: "Love which becomes Spirit makes all members of a living whole [community,] the life that animates that whole must have a wider definition, -- it must be a life which comprehends even death itself. Pain, disharmony, evil, must be seen to be incapable of breaking through the all-embracing unity, and even to be themselves the means of realizing it. Unreason itself must find a place, were it only a place to annihilate itself, under the universal rule of reason, which impartially rains its fertilising showers upon the evil and the good, and stimulates each in turn to show what is in it; since just in this impartiality lies the security for the triumph of good." (Hegel, Das Leben Jesu.)
With the appearance of the awesome scholarship displayed by Yale University's Professor John Boswell, it is very difficult for anyone (including the Vatican) to argue that sexual-orientation has any bearing on this message of love or that "marriage" is a sacrament that should be denied to same-sex couples by persons claiming to remain faithful to the Christian texts. Marriage is the community of erotic love. "Eros" is an aspect of divinity and its expression, for example, in the sentimental representation of "an older Christ and youthful St. John [that] is strongly evocative of the tradition of passionate friendship common among the monastic clergy of the Middle Ages" -- to say nothing of the various gay Popes in our history -- "and romanticized earlier by writers like Saint Aelred of Rievaulx." John Boswell, Christianity, Social Tolerance, and Homosexuality: Gay People in Western Europe From the Beginning of the Christian Era to the Fourteenth Century (Chicago & London: University of Chicago, 1980), p. 202. (If Mr. Rubio in Miami is, in fact, a homosexual -- as so many people say -- then he should be free to come out of the closet without being affected in his political ambitions by his sexual-orientation, or even to marry the person of his choice.)
From the iconography of St. Sebastian to Christ and St. John, to many other representations, it becomes clear to art historians and theologians that same-sex love and all love is not only "o.k." in terms of religious teachings in Christianity, but (I suggest) love is what Christianity is all about. Inserting "errors" in this essay will not change this reality. Ultimate self-realization is only possible in community, through love, where each PERSON becomes him- or herself, through self-discovery in the Other. ("John Finnis and Ethical Cognitivism" and "Is there a gay marriage right?")
You cannot deny the erotic nature of a person at one moment, then exchange the sign of peace and recognition that we are taught the Catholic mass is concerned to establish. Recognition and the sign of peace means that we must welcome our gay and lesbian "brothers and sisters" to the Community of the Faith. St. John teaches us: "You must see and love God in your brother and sister ..." Please welcome gay and lesbian Catholics to the St. Patrick's Day festivities, in your families and friendships, not to mention in parades down Fifth Avenue. None of this precludes us from sending a lesbian who steals public funds to prison. ("Jennifer Velez is a 'Dyke Magnet!'')
This message of inclusion and unity is symbolized in the shared absorption of "the Body of Christ." The Church is no prude, but it rightly dismisses pagan sex cults (Brown messes up his discussion of "Hieros Gamos") because they limit their focus to the sexual act, allegedly, as opposed to its spiritual meaning. Sex is not always love-making. Love-making is always a spiritual act. This is true regardless of sexual-orientation. Love-making is reverential, a kind of prayer. Sex is very nice; love-making is much greater. Love is finding the Grail. You do not need to decipher a bizarre code. You do not need to fly to Paris. Although it sure would be nice to do so! You do not have to worry about albino monks. The Kingdom of Heaven is right here and now. The Grail is looking for you. All you have to do is to be. I hope that you will be.
Monday, August 24, 2009
Friday, August 21, 2009
La Traviata.
"To be in opposition is not to be a nihilist. And there is no decent or chartered way of making a living at it. It is something [that] you are, and not something that you do." -- Christopher Hitchens.
Anything that one says concerning a controversial issue is bound to anger someone. Any cultural opinion may be interpreted as a rejection of an alternative view. Hence, by liking Opera, I may appear to be "judging" (horrors!) another person's fondness for, say, traditional yodelling during the mating season of the Norwegian mountain yak. To prefer Mozart's great piano concerto played by Maurizio Pollini to the guy on the corner playing "Camp Town Ladies" on a tin can, is a sign of my insensitivity to the plight of the common people and an obnoxious form of "elitism," whereas I think of it simply as musical taste. ("A Night at the Opera" and "What you will ...")
We are told (sometimes by English professors!) that Shakespeare is no better than Tom Clancy; Plato and Kant are nothing compared to Depak Chopra; and Freud and Jung are from Mars, whereas John Gray is from Venus -- the Beverly Hills section of Venus, that is. All establishment of preferences in culture or learning is frowned upon as "elitist." Despite my radical politics I am described as an "elitist," right before I am condemned as a "Communist" opponent of all standards of decency. I am, in fact, against middle class standards of decency (that is, hypocrisy) and in favor of what Freud and later Marcuse called, "polymorphous perversity."
"Political correctness" is bullshit. In a very few instances, good taste and moral concern should dictate what language may not be used -- excluding certain offensive terms barred from civilized discourse -- but censorship is never justified when it comes to the discussion of ideas or art for adults in a free society. Some art and intellectual work is better than others, even when it happens that such art is created by white males. In order to explain why I bother to say this, however, I will need to digress a bit to discuss the forbidden subject of class in America.
To the extent that I have made contacts with the privileged class in American society, it has been far from a pleasant experience for me. For those who are mentally defective or who have been staring at television for too long, allow me to explain the facts of political life. Despite what you may have been told, there is no human society without a class system. This includes U.S. society. There never will be. The criteria for admission to the "upper crust" in America is ostensibly enormous wealth, which will certainly get you an invitation to a charity dinner. On the other hand, there are subtle signs and rituals involved in membership in the old, WASP (oh, oh ... I was just "politically incorrect" again!), cultural and intellectual "elite," class, group, or tupper-ware party which usually excludes the stereotypically crude billionaire real estate developer -- whatever his or her ethnicity -- from membership.
This exclusion from society (to the extent that there still is such a thing) will result not merely from his or her not recognizing a Henry James title (which may be a plus), but for having very little idea of what a novel or even a book may be. Money is still not enough for admission to the best homes, though it sure helps to have a lot of it if you want to buy one. You will not enter the "best society," as Oscar Wilde would say, if you pick your feet at the dinner table or tend to discuss topless mud wrestling -- admittedly a fascinating subject -- though either interest will get you on a reality t.v. show.
It is also a fact, as Gore Vidal and such notables as Luis Auchincloss (both writers were "to the manor born") would be the first to point out, that every ruling class will open its doors to a witty and charming, intellectually daring and attractive person, regardless of that person's origins. Every hostess has to figure out how to entertain the proverbial dull-witted Grand Duchess (of either gender) in her dotage. The charming young man who can sit next to her at dinner and amuse her for hours is "paying his dues" for admission to what used to be called, "The Great World."
The division of human society into classes is instinctive and can be observed even in the playground, where small children will arrange themselves naturally into groups on the basis of which of them are most attractive, intelligent, athletic and so on. No one is going to legislate any of this away. People will find a way to get around any and all legal codes in order to do what they want to do, especially when it comes to selecting social and/or sexual companions. Incidentally, this fondness for getting around laws is usually accomplished with the help of lawyers, who will happily discover the means by which to circumvent (violate) the law "legally," at the dop of a fee. No, that is not what they are supposed to do.
There are always corrupting factors when it comes to such divisions and stratifications, that is, unfair advantages conferred by birth and wealth or natural endowment. Persons at the bottom of the society, like me, are well-aware that they are being screwed and denied important opportunities in life by this informal system of rewards and demerits that governs such things as admissions to "elite" universities and to the ranks of power in the State. Post-coital cigarette or are you getting the munchies? Bend over and say thank you.
We members of despised minority groups tend to focus, by way of compensation, on the ways in which we are -- often unwillingly and undeservedly -- the beneficiaries of social injustices too. Most of the important ways of screwing people in America are decided secretly, behind closed doors, so they can then be denied by the powerful, who tend to wrap themselves not so much in the flag, as in the minute provisions of administrative procedures. My instinct is to say "fuck 'em" (a very useful phrase), face-to-face, and only then to move on.
British actor Richard Burton -- who came from a humble Welsh mining family -- said that when he got to Oxford University, he made it a point to "look down on people from below." Albert Finney said pretty much the same thing. Curiously, affluent people then find themselves struggling to be liked by the person who has snubbed them and doing their best to be admired by their prospective butlers. In an egalitarian age, this becomes fodder for P.G. Whodehouse-like novels. While the very real suffering that results from a fiercely powerful class system and its rules is explored in some of the greatest literature in Western history. For example, it is the subject of the novels of Edith Wharton and Henry James, and is also at the center of Marcel Proust's Remembrance of Things Past, where these issues are dramatized at the very higest level, as in Shakespeare's historical plays.
Some social hierarchies are indeed illegitimate; others are not. If there were such a thing as a "pure" scale of aesthetic merit, then it would be democratic and fair to rank the cultural achievements of persons on the basis of genuine merit. It may well be that such a thing is impossible, since it is said (usually by "skinny people dressed in black") that there can be no fully "objective" determination of what constitutes merit -- when it comes to the arts or philosophy -- or maybe in any intellectual work, including philosophy. We are told that "it's all relative." Not surprisingly, this sort of claim ("there is no truth!") is rarely extended to scientific work, which is deemed to be objective and true, if corroborated. I have my doubts about this distinction.
There are comparative judgments that we can make, I am sure, with a great degree of confidence which allow us to arrive at accurate assessments of merit in the arts and in philosophy. Shakespeare is better than Agatha Christie, better than everybody else too, come to think of it; Tolstoy is better than Tom Clancy; Immanuel Kant is better than Ayn Rand; Leonardo Da Vinci matters more than Andy Warhol; Beethoven is better than Brittany Spears, who definitely has her merits. I would happily vote for Ms. Spears for the U.S. Presidency. Notice that the first in each of these pairs of names belongs to a white European male. "That's elitism!" No, that's just good taste.
In educating young people and helping to form their tastes and judgments in the humanities, it must be the goal of a university to expose students to what Mathew Arnold famously described as the "best that has been thought and said." Yes, there is such a thing. This is a category that is flexible, which should and must remain open, to include new people who clearly fit the bill -- like Toni Morrison or James Baldwin, Ralph Ellison and Paul Robeson, Cornel West and Angela Davis, Gabriela Mistral, Pablo Neruda, Jorge Luis Borges, Gabriel Garcia Marquez and Carlos Fuentes, along with many others who are now, FINALLY and appropriately studied in university classrooms.
Nevertheless the core group of great names will not change much and will be made up, overwhelmingly, of white males of European extraction. This is for the excellent reason that such persons were, traditionally, the only ones permitted to acquire an education or encouraged to develop and express opinions on important subjects. Is this fair? No, but it is our history.
We simply cannot ignore the achievements of white males in science and the humanities because they were the only people, for the most part, who had the opportunity to "achieve" anything significant in these fields. True, there are exceptions that prove the rule. This only confirms my point. We must not be afraid to say what we mean without being intimidated by the possibility of offending people who will disagree with us. Censorship is not justified because our words or expressions will offend people, since "offense" -- as John Stuart Mill demonstrated -- is not the same as "harm."
I wish to delve into this moral minefield with a little help from Camille Paglia, known hereafter as "La Traviata" -- so as to set everyone straight, as it were -- and I will then provide my own opinions concerning this controversial issue. I have decided to refer to Professor Paglia as "La Traviata," or "the lost one," not because she reminds me of Verdi's Operatic character, but because she shares with that character a fondness for shocking the conventional pieties of a hypocritical society and violating its prudish sexual mores. Besides, for all I know, she may be quite capable of tossing off an occasional B flat aria for the hell of it. Think of this essay, then, as a duet.
My sources for Professor Paglia's position are two essays "An Open Letter to the Students of Harvard" and "The Nursery School Campus: The Corrupting of the Humanities in the U.S.," both of which may be found in Camille Paglia, Vamps and Tramps (New York: Vintage, 1994), pp. 117-121, pp. 97-102. I like to think that I am a bit of a "vamp and a tramp" myself, in the right situation. Naturally, this is only after I have been taken to dinner.
"Anyone concerned with the future of literature and art in America should be repelled by that witch's brew of hypocrisy and sanctimony called 'political correctness,' which has poisoned the professional life of the elite colleges and universities." (p. 117.)
"The Lost One" goes on to distinguish the true tradition of Sixties radicalism from the false and distracting nonsense about political correctness: "Political correctness, with its [class-based] speech codes and puritanical sexual regulations, is a travesty of Sixties' progressive values." (p. 118.)
She then offers a brilliant diagnosis of what is really going on with this P.C. nonsense:
"The multiculturalists and the politically correct on the subjects of race, class, and gender actually represent a continuation of the genteel tradition [George Santayana] of respectability and conformity. They have institutionalized American niceness, which seeks, above all, not to offend and must therefore pretend not to notice any differences or distinctions among people or cultures." (p. 98.)
Professor Paglia is a self-professed lesbian and feminist, as indeed am I. No one has the right to determine the language that people "should" use in order to be deemed good, sensitive and intelligent persons. This authority to "cleanse" the language is a power which must be contested, for it is a true political power that will determine how people see the world. Attempts to control forms of erotic expression or consumption for adults in a free society are equally totalitarian. It's O.K. for adults to enjoy erotic or naughty stuff every once in a while, especially in the right company.
Thought cannot be extricated from language, which is far from concluding that, therefore, "there is no truth." To concede this authority to define "niceness" is to give away too much, including the ability to distract us from what really matters -- like who has the money and how did they get it. ("Law and Ethics in the Soprano State" and "New Jersey is the Home of the Living Dead.") "Niceness" will always be defined in terms that are suspiciously convenient for those very same self-proclaimed altruists whom heaven has placed above us on the social scale. Yet we need the concept of "niceness" and the standards implied by it for social cooperation. Let us struggle to define niceness from "below."
George Orwell would have been the first to recognize the hypocrisy of "political correctness" for what it is: a power-grab by those skinny people dressed in black, being driven to demonstrations in their expensive German cars, then rushing to that proverbial thousand-dollar-a plate dinner for the poor. It is not up to the affluent Upper West Side matrons to hand down to the rest of us, the hoi-polloi, a "correct" view of reality from which the "unwashed masses" (meaning you and me) are not to stray, much less are they welcome to do so on the basis of some assumed noblesse oblige benevolence on their part. What is "for my own good" is only for me to decide.
Civility is a democratic value. It should not be confused with snobbishness. The essence of politeness and civility is a concern for the comfort and well-being of others, as they define these things, not the attempt to "act all superior." Tom Wolfe's "social X-Rays" -- skinny people dressed in black, again, who are usually sun-bronzed and wear expensive, but discrete jewelry -- have no right to instruct us concerning how to refer, for example, to our own children in the privacy of our homes. I can attest to this affront from personal experience. I will not be "controlled" (without having committed a crime), legitimately, by agents of the State; nor will I be enslaved by anyone for any reason; nor will my values or opinions be "prescribed" to me by any "authority."
No one can tell me whether it is appropriate to use pet names for my child beyond a certain age; nor which names are appropriate; nor whether I am permitted to admire attractive members of the opposite sex, or to imagine fantasy sex partners (who doesn't have those?); nor the language that I may use to refer to persons from different -- or even from my own -- ethnic or racial group. I know what is offensive. Condescension is offensive. I will not put up with anyone telling me which works of art I may admire. Much less will I be told by anyone what I may not admire or read with approval. My inner life is my business. Do I need to say this again? ("Terry Tuchin, Diana Lisa Riccioli, and New Jersey's Agency of Torture.")
When people take it upon themselves to decide such matters for the rest of us, we are simply dealing with our old enemy Fascism in the guise of a new sensitivity and touchy-feely "concern" and "care" for us, for those of us "in need of instruction and care." Inferiors. This was the view of Dr. Josef Mengele regarding Jewish children. These children were in need of Mengele's determinations concerning what was "for the best" and how they could best contribute to society. Jewish persons were seen as "objects" to be exploited by Mengele for his purposes. ("Richard A. Posner on Voluntary Actions and Criminal Responsibility.")
There is condescension and insulting as well as patronizing so-called "instruction" in such guidance, which self-professed "superiors" would be the first to reject if it were imposed on them "from below" by those they mean to "help." This is exactly why I recommend doing so. ("Why I am not an ethical relativist" and "John Finnis and Ethical Cognitivism, then "Nihilists in Disneyworld" and "Nihilism Against Memory.")
One of the great surprises resulting from my multi-year experiences of suppressions of speech and censorship in America is the appalling ignorance among so-called "elites" in positions of authority in an American jurisdiction, many of whom lack the cultural awareness and knowledge of European high school graduates. I wish that I could say that this is unusual. Ignorance among the powerful in America, sadly, is not unusual at all. This would be a good time for further censorship, boys. ("Nihilists in Disneyworld.")
An "error" was inserted in this essay overnight. A letter was deleted from one of my words. No images can be posted at these blogs. The true number of hits at this site cannot be determined. In response to such frustration tactics from the home of the mafia -- which is the Garden State -- I will focus on the "politically correct" lesbianism of Anne Milgram, Esq. in New Jersey and whether this "hobby" has led to Anne's corrupt or incompetent practices or to those of her "friends." Do you wish to insert another "error" in this text? ("Deborah T. Poritz and Conduct Unbecoming to the Judiciary in New Jersey" and "Another Mafia Sweep in New Jersey and Anne Milgram is Clueless.")
Tact and sensitivity are not dirty words, except when extended to proponents of censorship. Offend, if you must, by expressing your opinions freely and fearlessly. Read the foregoing paragraph again. But try to do it "nicely." By all means, tell the disloyal opposition to go "fuck themselves" -- if you must. Why not offer a smile and a curtsy as you do so? I especially recommend this to men. I guess it is a "real job" for many of them to read books without pictures in them.
Woody Allen reminds us that, if we must be bigots, then let us be bigots for the Left, never for emaciated fashionistas concerned to make it into to the pages of People magazine. Genius transcends all rules -- which is my serious point -- by creating its own forms of "niceness." Physician heal thyself! And get off my back and front while you're at it. ("What is it like to be tortured? and "What is it like to be plagiarized?")
Anything that one says concerning a controversial issue is bound to anger someone. Any cultural opinion may be interpreted as a rejection of an alternative view. Hence, by liking Opera, I may appear to be "judging" (horrors!) another person's fondness for, say, traditional yodelling during the mating season of the Norwegian mountain yak. To prefer Mozart's great piano concerto played by Maurizio Pollini to the guy on the corner playing "Camp Town Ladies" on a tin can, is a sign of my insensitivity to the plight of the common people and an obnoxious form of "elitism," whereas I think of it simply as musical taste. ("A Night at the Opera" and "What you will ...")
We are told (sometimes by English professors!) that Shakespeare is no better than Tom Clancy; Plato and Kant are nothing compared to Depak Chopra; and Freud and Jung are from Mars, whereas John Gray is from Venus -- the Beverly Hills section of Venus, that is. All establishment of preferences in culture or learning is frowned upon as "elitist." Despite my radical politics I am described as an "elitist," right before I am condemned as a "Communist" opponent of all standards of decency. I am, in fact, against middle class standards of decency (that is, hypocrisy) and in favor of what Freud and later Marcuse called, "polymorphous perversity."
"Political correctness" is bullshit. In a very few instances, good taste and moral concern should dictate what language may not be used -- excluding certain offensive terms barred from civilized discourse -- but censorship is never justified when it comes to the discussion of ideas or art for adults in a free society. Some art and intellectual work is better than others, even when it happens that such art is created by white males. In order to explain why I bother to say this, however, I will need to digress a bit to discuss the forbidden subject of class in America.
To the extent that I have made contacts with the privileged class in American society, it has been far from a pleasant experience for me. For those who are mentally defective or who have been staring at television for too long, allow me to explain the facts of political life. Despite what you may have been told, there is no human society without a class system. This includes U.S. society. There never will be. The criteria for admission to the "upper crust" in America is ostensibly enormous wealth, which will certainly get you an invitation to a charity dinner. On the other hand, there are subtle signs and rituals involved in membership in the old, WASP (oh, oh ... I was just "politically incorrect" again!), cultural and intellectual "elite," class, group, or tupper-ware party which usually excludes the stereotypically crude billionaire real estate developer -- whatever his or her ethnicity -- from membership.
This exclusion from society (to the extent that there still is such a thing) will result not merely from his or her not recognizing a Henry James title (which may be a plus), but for having very little idea of what a novel or even a book may be. Money is still not enough for admission to the best homes, though it sure helps to have a lot of it if you want to buy one. You will not enter the "best society," as Oscar Wilde would say, if you pick your feet at the dinner table or tend to discuss topless mud wrestling -- admittedly a fascinating subject -- though either interest will get you on a reality t.v. show.
It is also a fact, as Gore Vidal and such notables as Luis Auchincloss (both writers were "to the manor born") would be the first to point out, that every ruling class will open its doors to a witty and charming, intellectually daring and attractive person, regardless of that person's origins. Every hostess has to figure out how to entertain the proverbial dull-witted Grand Duchess (of either gender) in her dotage. The charming young man who can sit next to her at dinner and amuse her for hours is "paying his dues" for admission to what used to be called, "The Great World."
The division of human society into classes is instinctive and can be observed even in the playground, where small children will arrange themselves naturally into groups on the basis of which of them are most attractive, intelligent, athletic and so on. No one is going to legislate any of this away. People will find a way to get around any and all legal codes in order to do what they want to do, especially when it comes to selecting social and/or sexual companions. Incidentally, this fondness for getting around laws is usually accomplished with the help of lawyers, who will happily discover the means by which to circumvent (violate) the law "legally," at the dop of a fee. No, that is not what they are supposed to do.
There are always corrupting factors when it comes to such divisions and stratifications, that is, unfair advantages conferred by birth and wealth or natural endowment. Persons at the bottom of the society, like me, are well-aware that they are being screwed and denied important opportunities in life by this informal system of rewards and demerits that governs such things as admissions to "elite" universities and to the ranks of power in the State. Post-coital cigarette or are you getting the munchies? Bend over and say thank you.
We members of despised minority groups tend to focus, by way of compensation, on the ways in which we are -- often unwillingly and undeservedly -- the beneficiaries of social injustices too. Most of the important ways of screwing people in America are decided secretly, behind closed doors, so they can then be denied by the powerful, who tend to wrap themselves not so much in the flag, as in the minute provisions of administrative procedures. My instinct is to say "fuck 'em" (a very useful phrase), face-to-face, and only then to move on.
British actor Richard Burton -- who came from a humble Welsh mining family -- said that when he got to Oxford University, he made it a point to "look down on people from below." Albert Finney said pretty much the same thing. Curiously, affluent people then find themselves struggling to be liked by the person who has snubbed them and doing their best to be admired by their prospective butlers. In an egalitarian age, this becomes fodder for P.G. Whodehouse-like novels. While the very real suffering that results from a fiercely powerful class system and its rules is explored in some of the greatest literature in Western history. For example, it is the subject of the novels of Edith Wharton and Henry James, and is also at the center of Marcel Proust's Remembrance of Things Past, where these issues are dramatized at the very higest level, as in Shakespeare's historical plays.
Some social hierarchies are indeed illegitimate; others are not. If there were such a thing as a "pure" scale of aesthetic merit, then it would be democratic and fair to rank the cultural achievements of persons on the basis of genuine merit. It may well be that such a thing is impossible, since it is said (usually by "skinny people dressed in black") that there can be no fully "objective" determination of what constitutes merit -- when it comes to the arts or philosophy -- or maybe in any intellectual work, including philosophy. We are told that "it's all relative." Not surprisingly, this sort of claim ("there is no truth!") is rarely extended to scientific work, which is deemed to be objective and true, if corroborated. I have my doubts about this distinction.
There are comparative judgments that we can make, I am sure, with a great degree of confidence which allow us to arrive at accurate assessments of merit in the arts and in philosophy. Shakespeare is better than Agatha Christie, better than everybody else too, come to think of it; Tolstoy is better than Tom Clancy; Immanuel Kant is better than Ayn Rand; Leonardo Da Vinci matters more than Andy Warhol; Beethoven is better than Brittany Spears, who definitely has her merits. I would happily vote for Ms. Spears for the U.S. Presidency. Notice that the first in each of these pairs of names belongs to a white European male. "That's elitism!" No, that's just good taste.
In educating young people and helping to form their tastes and judgments in the humanities, it must be the goal of a university to expose students to what Mathew Arnold famously described as the "best that has been thought and said." Yes, there is such a thing. This is a category that is flexible, which should and must remain open, to include new people who clearly fit the bill -- like Toni Morrison or James Baldwin, Ralph Ellison and Paul Robeson, Cornel West and Angela Davis, Gabriela Mistral, Pablo Neruda, Jorge Luis Borges, Gabriel Garcia Marquez and Carlos Fuentes, along with many others who are now, FINALLY and appropriately studied in university classrooms.
Nevertheless the core group of great names will not change much and will be made up, overwhelmingly, of white males of European extraction. This is for the excellent reason that such persons were, traditionally, the only ones permitted to acquire an education or encouraged to develop and express opinions on important subjects. Is this fair? No, but it is our history.
We simply cannot ignore the achievements of white males in science and the humanities because they were the only people, for the most part, who had the opportunity to "achieve" anything significant in these fields. True, there are exceptions that prove the rule. This only confirms my point. We must not be afraid to say what we mean without being intimidated by the possibility of offending people who will disagree with us. Censorship is not justified because our words or expressions will offend people, since "offense" -- as John Stuart Mill demonstrated -- is not the same as "harm."
I wish to delve into this moral minefield with a little help from Camille Paglia, known hereafter as "La Traviata" -- so as to set everyone straight, as it were -- and I will then provide my own opinions concerning this controversial issue. I have decided to refer to Professor Paglia as "La Traviata," or "the lost one," not because she reminds me of Verdi's Operatic character, but because she shares with that character a fondness for shocking the conventional pieties of a hypocritical society and violating its prudish sexual mores. Besides, for all I know, she may be quite capable of tossing off an occasional B flat aria for the hell of it. Think of this essay, then, as a duet.
My sources for Professor Paglia's position are two essays "An Open Letter to the Students of Harvard" and "The Nursery School Campus: The Corrupting of the Humanities in the U.S.," both of which may be found in Camille Paglia, Vamps and Tramps (New York: Vintage, 1994), pp. 117-121, pp. 97-102. I like to think that I am a bit of a "vamp and a tramp" myself, in the right situation. Naturally, this is only after I have been taken to dinner.
"Anyone concerned with the future of literature and art in America should be repelled by that witch's brew of hypocrisy and sanctimony called 'political correctness,' which has poisoned the professional life of the elite colleges and universities." (p. 117.)
"The Lost One" goes on to distinguish the true tradition of Sixties radicalism from the false and distracting nonsense about political correctness: "Political correctness, with its [class-based] speech codes and puritanical sexual regulations, is a travesty of Sixties' progressive values." (p. 118.)
She then offers a brilliant diagnosis of what is really going on with this P.C. nonsense:
"The multiculturalists and the politically correct on the subjects of race, class, and gender actually represent a continuation of the genteel tradition [George Santayana] of respectability and conformity. They have institutionalized American niceness, which seeks, above all, not to offend and must therefore pretend not to notice any differences or distinctions among people or cultures." (p. 98.)
Professor Paglia is a self-professed lesbian and feminist, as indeed am I. No one has the right to determine the language that people "should" use in order to be deemed good, sensitive and intelligent persons. This authority to "cleanse" the language is a power which must be contested, for it is a true political power that will determine how people see the world. Attempts to control forms of erotic expression or consumption for adults in a free society are equally totalitarian. It's O.K. for adults to enjoy erotic or naughty stuff every once in a while, especially in the right company.
Thought cannot be extricated from language, which is far from concluding that, therefore, "there is no truth." To concede this authority to define "niceness" is to give away too much, including the ability to distract us from what really matters -- like who has the money and how did they get it. ("Law and Ethics in the Soprano State" and "New Jersey is the Home of the Living Dead.") "Niceness" will always be defined in terms that are suspiciously convenient for those very same self-proclaimed altruists whom heaven has placed above us on the social scale. Yet we need the concept of "niceness" and the standards implied by it for social cooperation. Let us struggle to define niceness from "below."
George Orwell would have been the first to recognize the hypocrisy of "political correctness" for what it is: a power-grab by those skinny people dressed in black, being driven to demonstrations in their expensive German cars, then rushing to that proverbial thousand-dollar-a plate dinner for the poor. It is not up to the affluent Upper West Side matrons to hand down to the rest of us, the hoi-polloi, a "correct" view of reality from which the "unwashed masses" (meaning you and me) are not to stray, much less are they welcome to do so on the basis of some assumed noblesse oblige benevolence on their part. What is "for my own good" is only for me to decide.
Civility is a democratic value. It should not be confused with snobbishness. The essence of politeness and civility is a concern for the comfort and well-being of others, as they define these things, not the attempt to "act all superior." Tom Wolfe's "social X-Rays" -- skinny people dressed in black, again, who are usually sun-bronzed and wear expensive, but discrete jewelry -- have no right to instruct us concerning how to refer, for example, to our own children in the privacy of our homes. I can attest to this affront from personal experience. I will not be "controlled" (without having committed a crime), legitimately, by agents of the State; nor will I be enslaved by anyone for any reason; nor will my values or opinions be "prescribed" to me by any "authority."
No one can tell me whether it is appropriate to use pet names for my child beyond a certain age; nor which names are appropriate; nor whether I am permitted to admire attractive members of the opposite sex, or to imagine fantasy sex partners (who doesn't have those?); nor the language that I may use to refer to persons from different -- or even from my own -- ethnic or racial group. I know what is offensive. Condescension is offensive. I will not put up with anyone telling me which works of art I may admire. Much less will I be told by anyone what I may not admire or read with approval. My inner life is my business. Do I need to say this again? ("Terry Tuchin, Diana Lisa Riccioli, and New Jersey's Agency of Torture.")
When people take it upon themselves to decide such matters for the rest of us, we are simply dealing with our old enemy Fascism in the guise of a new sensitivity and touchy-feely "concern" and "care" for us, for those of us "in need of instruction and care." Inferiors. This was the view of Dr. Josef Mengele regarding Jewish children. These children were in need of Mengele's determinations concerning what was "for the best" and how they could best contribute to society. Jewish persons were seen as "objects" to be exploited by Mengele for his purposes. ("Richard A. Posner on Voluntary Actions and Criminal Responsibility.")
There is condescension and insulting as well as patronizing so-called "instruction" in such guidance, which self-professed "superiors" would be the first to reject if it were imposed on them "from below" by those they mean to "help." This is exactly why I recommend doing so. ("Why I am not an ethical relativist" and "John Finnis and Ethical Cognitivism, then "Nihilists in Disneyworld" and "Nihilism Against Memory.")
One of the great surprises resulting from my multi-year experiences of suppressions of speech and censorship in America is the appalling ignorance among so-called "elites" in positions of authority in an American jurisdiction, many of whom lack the cultural awareness and knowledge of European high school graduates. I wish that I could say that this is unusual. Ignorance among the powerful in America, sadly, is not unusual at all. This would be a good time for further censorship, boys. ("Nihilists in Disneyworld.")
An "error" was inserted in this essay overnight. A letter was deleted from one of my words. No images can be posted at these blogs. The true number of hits at this site cannot be determined. In response to such frustration tactics from the home of the mafia -- which is the Garden State -- I will focus on the "politically correct" lesbianism of Anne Milgram, Esq. in New Jersey and whether this "hobby" has led to Anne's corrupt or incompetent practices or to those of her "friends." Do you wish to insert another "error" in this text? ("Deborah T. Poritz and Conduct Unbecoming to the Judiciary in New Jersey" and "Another Mafia Sweep in New Jersey and Anne Milgram is Clueless.")
Tact and sensitivity are not dirty words, except when extended to proponents of censorship. Offend, if you must, by expressing your opinions freely and fearlessly. Read the foregoing paragraph again. But try to do it "nicely." By all means, tell the disloyal opposition to go "fuck themselves" -- if you must. Why not offer a smile and a curtsy as you do so? I especially recommend this to men. I guess it is a "real job" for many of them to read books without pictures in them.
Woody Allen reminds us that, if we must be bigots, then let us be bigots for the Left, never for emaciated fashionistas concerned to make it into to the pages of People magazine. Genius transcends all rules -- which is my serious point -- by creating its own forms of "niceness." Physician heal thyself! And get off my back and front while you're at it. ("What is it like to be tortured? and "What is it like to be plagiarized?")
Tuesday, August 18, 2009
"God is Texting Me!"
I was working in my first job as a lawyer. I was twenty-eight, an associate in a small law firm doing mom-and-pop legal work: accident cases, divorces, small criminal cases, workers' compensation and some real estate. I liked criminal law best. The work was often meticulous, requiring long hours and lots of time at the law library. As a result, I usually left the office late. I made it home to the "Upper West Side" (that's an independent territory in Manhattan governed on socialist principles).
"Thank you. I got the bathrobe as a Holiday gift from my mother."
I had forgotten the joy of living with a woman. Somehow, I got to sleep. Next thing I know bells are ringing, trumpets are blaring, birds are singing.
can bide the beating of so strong a passion
As love doth give my heart: no woman's heart
So big to hold so much; they lack retention.
Alas, their love may be called appetite, --
No motion of the liver, but the palate, --
That suffer surfeit, cloyment, and revolt;
But mine is all as hungry as the sea,
And can digest as much: make no compare
Between that love a woman bear me
And that I owe Olivia."
In faith, they are as true of heart as we.
My father had a daughter loved a man,
As it might be, perhaps, were I a woman,
I should your Lordship."
But let concealment, like a worm i' the bud,
Feed on her damask cheek: she pined in thought;
And, with a green and yellow melancholy,
She sat like patience on a monument,
Smiling at grief. Was this not love indeed?
We men say more, swear more; but, indeed,
Our shows are more than will; for still we prove
Much in our vows, but little in our love."
So do our minutes hasten to their end;
Each changing place with that which goes before,
In sequent toil all forwards do contend.
Nativity, once in the main of light,
Crawls to maturity, wherewith being crown'd,
Crooked eclipses 'gainst his glory fight,
And Time that gave doth now his gift confound.
Time does transfix the flourish set on youth,
And delves the parallels in beauty's brow,
Feeds on the rarities of nature's truth,
And nothing stands but for his scythe to mow.
And yet to times in hope my verse shall stand,
Praising thy worth, despite his cruel hand.
I lived in an apartment that had previously been a closet in someone's home. I didn't mind the tiny elevator in my building. I welcomed the proximity to Columbia University. The women walking around at all hours were a bonus. It was worth it to use a Coke bottle to shower and cook by placing food over my cigarette lighter. The place was rent stabilized. The monthly bite was tolerable. What more could I ask?
I didn't know how I'd get a woman into the apartment while I was still in it, since there was so little room. For the first few months there was no reasonable prospect on the babe watch, so the issue didn't come up. My starship failed to detect suitable female lifeforms in my building.
Anyway, this particular Friday night I was heading home after a massive sandwich experience at "Artie's." I saw a guy I know selling books at a sidewalk table. I stopped and browsed, searching for something by Jack Finney or Richard Matheson, maybe a great scary Steven King novel that I could read on the subway train in the morning. This guy had a few old items of jewelry, including a cameo broach from, like, the twenties. The broach had a picture of this amazingly beautiful woman in a classic flapper outfit. She looked like a blond Louise Brooks wearing a string of pearls and with big eyes that went right through me. I didn't know whether the image in the cameo -- which was dusty and seemed not to have been touched for years -- was a painting or photograph that had been decorated with watercolors.
I opted for a Scott Turow legal thriller and shelled out five dollars extra for the cameo. I made it home in time to see one of my favorite old movies, Bell, Book and Candle. I must have fallen asleep on the couch because I woke up at around 3:00 A.M., when some pots and pans fell in the section of my "one room paradise with a view" devoted to kitchen events. I turned on the lights and went to see what happened. There was a woman standing in my apartment wearing a long string of pearls and a kind of feather or something in her hair. She was in my bathrobe.
"Hi, I'm Bernice."
She looked like Drew Barrymore with a kind of silent film-style, just like the woman in the cameo.
"You know, Bernice ... like in the F. Scott Fitzgerald story 'Bernice Bobs Her Hair' ... I met him, you know."
"I don't know how you got in here. If you're a junky or something, you should know that I am not interested in anything illegal. I'm a lawyer. I don't need any trouble."
"Oh, don't be silly." She made herself comfortable on my couch. "Can't you tell that I'm a ghost?"
"What?"
"I'm a ghost, silly. I mean, isn't it rather obvious? You've read enough of these stories. You've been to the movies. You know how it works."
She was lying on my couch, staring up at me, sparkling green eyes, perfect smile, dimples on her cheeks.
"If you need medication," I tried to be patient, "I am sure that there are hospitals that provide emergency refills."
"I'm a ghost. I don't need medication, but I do get hungry. There's nothing in your ice box. What do you call it now? 'Refrigerator'? You see, I'm trying to earn my angel's wings. I was a chorus girl when I died in a car crash -- only twenty-five! -- it really breaks your heart. That was right before the Great Depression."
She just stared at me and made this melting little girl's face, drying an imaginary tear from her eyes.
"Do men still like that sort of approach?" She laughed.
"I admit that you're very beautiful, probably somewhat disturbed, not dangerous maybe. I am sure that there are people worried about you. If you tell me the name of the facility where you live, I will do my best to get you home."
I tried to sound reasonable. She thanked me and beamed a smile for the compliment, then shifted into female anger and outrage: "I live in heaven, pal. You're sooo silly ..."
I was stunned and (for once) at a loss for words. Some evil part of my soul was pondering a sexual act --
" -- Don't even think about it, buster. This is strictly heavenly business. I'm here to help you return to your spiritual essence and release your capacity for love (not that kind, you're too one-track-minded!), creative, other-regarding love. If I can bring you to a higher state of consciousness where you open up to the world around you, I may get my wings and a penthouse suite. Heaven looks just like the Waldorf Hotel."
She got up and went to the kitchen where I keep my menus from local restaurants. Bernice was humming an Al Jolson tune.
"Are you telling me that you're dead?"
"Well, I couldn't be a ghost if I were alive, right? I mean, it's pretty elementary. By the way, are you single?"
This was getting out of hand. "I may have to call the police. I don't know what you're planning, but you're in my home and wearing my bathrobe --"
"-- It's really nice. Smells great. You wear eau d'cologne? Most men in the twenties wore terrible cologne."
"Thank you. I got the bathrobe as a Holiday gift from my mother."
"You're Jewish! Me too!"
I thought that the safest thing was to play along: "I would have guessed that you're a Jewish ghost."
She smiled her "Fanny Price smile."
I decided to go with a hunch: "In fact, you probably went to Brandeis University and experimented with the wrong drugs because your parents wanted you to marry a dentist from Long Island, right?"
I had met her type before.
"You really are kind of slow, aren't you? Look!"
Suddenly, right before my eyes, Bernice disappeared. Then she reappeared. Bernice is not unusual in possessing this female ability to be present and absent almost at the same time -- sometimes women manage this effect when having sex with their husbands!
"My God!"
"No, I'm not God. Just a ghost. I'm here for you. You need a nice woman in your life."
"You're definitely Jewish."
"So is God. She's shopping today at Bloomingdales. She said that she needs a new handbag with all the gadgets that she carries around, especially her big cell phone. We didn't have cell phones in the twenties. Now all the apprentice angels get them, standard issue. Hold it, God's texting me!"
I felt dizzy all of a sudden.
"She wants to have lunch this week so I can provide a progress report. You'd never know it, but God looks like Barbara Streisand and she loves to sing."
"You mean religious music?"
"No, Broadway show tunes."
"O.K., that's it. You're out of here."
"You can't throw me out of your apartment because you're my project. Don't you want me to become a full angel?"
She placed her hands on her hips, tilted her head at me, and lifted an eyebrow.
"Look, I don't want you to get in trouble. I will sleep in the living room. You can go into my bedroom -- which is on the small side -- but there's air conditioning. You can wear some of my pijamas and stay here tonight. Tomorrow, you have to go and rescue someone else. That's fair, right?"
"Well, it's a start. I can see that you're going to be a lot of work. You are seriously out-of-touch with your chi!"
Bernice stormed into the bedroom and closed the door. I was just getting to sleep when there was a loud knock at my front door. I got up, groggy and in a foul mood. I opened the door to discover the delivery guy from "La Caridad" on 78th Street. I paid the man $32.00, plus a $5.00 tip.
Bernice came out of the bedroom wearing my pijamas and in my Rolling Stones t-shirt. Without a single word (to me), she took the food from my hand and said something in Chinese to the delivery guy. Then she went right back into the bedroom and slammed the door.
I had forgotten the joy of living with a woman. Somehow, I got to sleep. Next thing I know bells are ringing, trumpets are blaring, birds are singing.
"Good morning, sunshine! Are you ready for our adventure?"
I could only open one eye. My brain had suffered a terrible trauma. One ear had been damaged severely by this blaring wake-up call. Bernice stood before me in a beautiful dress, pastel shades with hand-painted flowers, a twenties' length on the hem line, sporting a parasol and jet black hair now in a Clara Bow-style. Oceans of elegant perfume flowed in my direction, together with a powerful charge of female energy. The smell of coffee and a huge breakfast at my portable tray greeted me as I rose to my feet.
"Bran muffin?"
I have never tasted such a great breakfast.
"Where'd you get this stuff? It's great."
"There's a guy in heaven who used to work as a chef at the 21 Club. He's sweet for me. Anything I want, he cooks up in minutes -- everything is perfect in heaven's kitchen -- and then he sends it to me. I figured you'd need your strength for today."
"What do you mean?"
"Well, first I want to go shopping on Madison Avenue. I haven't been to the shops in ages! I want to see all the new clothes. We got an expense account and bonus from Heaven's accounting office! They think you're a difficult project and they want to help me. I need everything to be right."
I just stared at Bernice. I didn't know whether some terrible stroke had affected my cerebral cortex. I guess the same thing happens when you fall in love because this feeling was just as weird.
"Do you not read the papers? Do you know what's happening today?"
Bernice sat accross from me as I ate. She sipped some coffee from my favorite mug that said: "Juan in a million!"
"No, what's happening today?"
"Shakespeare in the Park, silly. What? Are you hostile to culture?"
"No."
"O.K., so we're going to try to develop your capacity for feelings and higher emotions. For you, this will be very difficult. Most lawyers do not go to heaven. But I love a challenge."
"I like Shakespeare. What's the play?"
"Twelfth Night. Somebody named 'Anne Hathaway' is in it. Isn't that the living end? First, I thought we'd do a little shopping, like I said. That way, I'll be up-to-date in my fashions. All the men will envy you because you're with me. The women will feel sorry for me, of course, but that can't be helped."
I was trying to absorb these new developments. I ate a full hearty breakfast, showered, dressed casually -- polo shirt, khakis, black penny loafers, plus my Mickey Mouse watch from when I went to Disneyworld. I know, I know ... "You're a grown man!"
I agreed to the whole shopping expedition, provided that Bernice would accompany me to the MET Museum to see some of my favorite canvases before heading to the park to see the play. We made the bargain and signed it in blood, metaphorically speaking. I thought that, after the museum, I'd show her to my favorite little French Bistro, not far from "The Corner Bookstore."
We left the apartment around 10:00 A.M. I made sure to stop and say hello to "Sam," our local homeless man, who is a sweetheart. Sam keeps an eye on my place when I am away. I usually get something for him during my morning rush into the local Dunkin Doughnuts. Sam was impressed by Bernice:
"How you doing today, beautiful?" Sam said.
"You talking to me, Sam?"
I couldn't resist the one-liner since I rarely make Sam laugh. He couldn't get enough of it.
"No, man ... you're as ugly as ever. What's she doing with you?"
Bernice loved it.
"I'm her project."
"That what they call it now?"
Bernice took some notes to see if she could "fix up" Sam with a nice deceased woman. Sam is very well informed on current events. We discuss politics in the mornings.
"I haven't been on the subways since before I died."
"The subway could have caused your death in the twenties. It's a lot better now. There's air conditioning."
The MTA guy spilled his coffee when he heard this. The trains are packed tighter than a can of sardines at this hour. We split up the morning Times. I got the "Arts" section; Bernice was perusing the "Style" section. She loves the "Science Times." We agreed to share the news and editorial pages. Bernice is tempted to vote for FDR. He wouldn't be a bad candidate. We went downtown to 42nd Street. Bernice ran to the middle of the block, then she began tap dancing and singing. Bernice is really good!
"Finally, I made it to the Big White Way!" She said. Bernice insisted on walking to the East Side singing in the middle of street, then heading uptown by way of the department stores and boutiques. Bernice wanted to teach me a dance that she learned from Vernon Castle and Bill "Bojangles" Robinson.
We were in the middle of the street and she was dancing -- like in the movies -- cars were honking and tourists were snapping our picture. A police officer suggested that we head over to our favorite lunatic asylum without causing a traffic snarl-up.
Bernice was about to mention the cop's "chi," when I decided to take his advice and, gently, persuaded her to stroll with the rest of the "mortals" on the sidewalk.
"You're no fun."
"Neither is the city jail, Bernice."
The day was beautiful. Madison Avenue in the morning is packed with well-dressed people strolling to offices and meetings, some going to college classes, others window shopping or heading to Central Park for a "play date." I could not believe this woman's effortless elegance and grace, the way she moved efficiently and strongly. Bernice's reflection, like a shadow, mimicked her actions in the "real world" (is it real?), as it glided by on the shop windows when we walked up the street. I walked with twins -- a self and her shadow, Sebastian and Viola all in one -- both involved in an intricate dance with me. The afterlife must be great for good people. The Waldorf, huh? ...
We stopped in some jewelry stores, but made no purchases. Shoes were a religious experience for Bernice. She bought Italian shoes that matched her outfit. Bernice couldn't get enough of seeing them glitter on her feet, like ruby slippers. I loved making her laugh, purchasing an ice cream cone on the sidewalk, seeing her with a smudge of cookie dough ice cream on her nose was priceless. I gently wiped the ice cream away, then I snapped a picture with a disposable camera.
I remember a woman's face many years ago, after a dance, as I drew the hair back from her forehead. I remember seeing her turn away, smile, and wave. Borges said in a short story that, until his death, he would remember the face of Beatriz Viterbo. Beatrice. I close my eyes, sometimes, and see a woman in a wedding gown with a tear in her eyes, looking at me.
Bernice felt that I needed a make-over. We went into several men's stores, none seemed right. She insisted on a new shirt from the "Tie and Shirt Shop" -- all the clothes are English there -- then we set out to find new trousers for me. A powder blue shirt was matched by cream-colored slacks, new shoes, the leather seemed soft and fitted to my foot. Bernice opted for a new watch, then insisted that I get a Breitling. Instead, I selected an Orient watch. We pretended to be Fred Astaire and Ginger Rodgers, improvising a dance number on the sidewalk, earning the applause of some observers. My life became a scene from My Man Godfrey, or Topper.
The hours seemed to disappear. I realized that "The Cafe Luxembourg" on West 70th Street, I think, is a watering hole for movie people. Bernice would love the atmosphere in that place. After a quick lunch, there would be time for a visit to the MET museum, then a light snack at the French place before heading to the theater.
Women who really love you and think that you're "perfect" always want to make a few minor changes in your life. I figured Bernice would insist on brain surgery (for me) before the day was over. Bernice wanted everything to be perfect. She insisted on improving every detail in order to "fix" my problem. I went along with everything that she wanted. I tried to be patient. It all seemed really important to her. I wanted her to be happy.
For some women happiness is "fixing" other people in order to achieve a "perfect" life, like in magazines or movies. I wanted Bernice to feel that she succeeded in her efforts, that her life was that magazine cover, because I wanted to see her smile forever. I wanted Bernice to believe or know that she is a "star" -- for me. And she is a star, always.
Bernice was so concerned about my chi that she seemed unconcerned about li. The idea of balance and harmony, within the self and in relation to nature. We ate together. Bernice ordered my lunch -- no need to ask what I wanted -- because she was sure that I don't eat "healthy meals!" Bernice mapped out a schedule for the afternoon: museum, shopping for groceries, coffee at my favorite French place, where we could talk about the paintings we had seen, finally a DVD for movie viewing at home with "organic" microwave popcorn after the play and more coffee. Bernice explained that she needs "everything to be flawless!"
The meal was superb. Bernice waved to people in the movie business. She explained to the movie actors that their grandparents had been her friends. To movie people, apparently, this sort of behavior seems normal. Kate Winslet and Sam Mendes waved to us as we left the restaurant. Melanie Griffith whispered something in my ear about the power of crystals. Melanie loves my "Antonio" cologne. Robert Downey. Jr. insisted that he had met Bernice's grandfather in a previous life. The two of them compared notes on the chi of the various people in the room.
We made our way to the MET museum, being especially entranced by the portraits painted by the great Baroque masters, Velazquez and Rembrandt. I noticed the merciless, scalpel-like attention to the psyche on the part of the great Spanish painter. His depiction of these powerful persons in their finery and of all that seemed false, uncertain and uncomfortable in their personas somehow reflecting the station to which life had assigned them. Velazquez liked and accepted their money. He clearly did not admire these powerful patrons too much beyond their wealth. These paintings contain a protest at having to associate with and paint these people, even as the artist is clearly fascinated by his subjects. I know the feeling.
The adjacent portrait of a Dominican servant in finery was a scathing comment on these people. Here was a man beneath their notice -- almost like a mouse to these aristocrats -- yet filled with authenticity and more life and intelligence (or genuineness) than they could ever achieve. More than their equal, the artist sees the illiterate servant's simple humanity and delights in it, judging it superior to the pompousness of his ruthless patrons, patrons whose blindness prevents them even from seeing the artist's harsh evaluations of their arrogance and conceit. Superiors?
I am sure that movie people, actors and directors as well as writers, are like Velazquez in their ability to see other people and tell them (all of us) what we're really like. Is that why we care so much about them?
Bernice began to cry before the great Rembrandt self-portrait, which is really the Dutch painter's Hamlet. The work is a meditation on life and death as well as meaning. I think Bernice understood something then about real wealth. She was overwhelmed with a feel for the distance between authentic value and "gaudy display." Perhaps Bernice saw something also about herself that she had not seen in a brief lifetime, understanding my willingness to follow her anywhere, my willingness to accept anything to make her happy.
It was at that moment that I realized that I was here for Bernice. I could have sworn that I heard Streisand singing something about "People who need people ..."
The pieces all fell into place after the play -- which is free for the people of New York and the world -- as we left the Delacorte theater in Central Park to find a coffee shop. Not far from Central Park West, on Amsterdam Avenue, I found a place called "The Illyria Cafe."
Twelfth Night is a holiday gift -- like the toys received by children on "Three Kings' Day" in Cuba, which is the same holiday -- a gift for the "Feast of the Epiphany." I am sure that the play is about unmaskings and revelations, identity and love. This play provides an occasion for the "epiphanies" of love. Shakespeare wishes us to "see" one another and accept ourselves for who and what we are.
People interpret the work -- only tenuously described as a comedy -- as concerned with the mysteries of identity and gender, erotic loss and melancholy. Bernice sat next to me and listened to my whispering monologue as she sipped some iced coffee while trying to keep her eyes from closing. I wonder whether the identities and genders in question are those of our loves rather than ourselves? Are there masculine and feminine loves? Do some men love as women love? While some women feel love only as a man feels it? I remember some lines from Scene IV in the play:
Duke: "There is no woman's sides
can bide the beating of so strong a passion
As love doth give my heart: no woman's heart
So big to hold so much; they lack retention.
Alas, their love may be called appetite, --
No motion of the liver, but the palate, --
That suffer surfeit, cloyment, and revolt;
But mine is all as hungry as the sea,
And can digest as much: make no compare
Between that love a woman bear me
And that I owe Olivia."
Viola: "Ay, but I know, --
Duke: "What dost thou know?"
Viola: "Too well what love women to men may owe.
In faith, they are as true of heart as we.
My father had a daughter loved a man,
As it might be, perhaps, were I a woman,
I should your Lordship."
Duke: "And what's her history?"
Viola: "A blank, my Lord. She never told her love,
But let concealment, like a worm i' the bud,
Feed on her damask cheek: she pined in thought;
And, with a green and yellow melancholy,
She sat like patience on a monument,
Smiling at grief. Was this not love indeed?
We men say more, swear more; but, indeed,
Our shows are more than will; for still we prove
Much in our vows, but little in our love."
Imagine speaking of your love to a person who does not know it is he (or she) that is the object of such devotion, like Viola/Cesario speaking to Orsino. How much must one adore a creature to ache with unbearable pain at not being seen or recognized -- not remembered -- even as one's life is all a gift or offering to, and for, that person? Imagine a love whose every utterance is agony and bliss, equally, which must be chosen (every day) or "chaos is come again."
This play is a tale of longing and loss where one character's love is a woman and another character's love is a man. "Two loves have I ..." The love that is a woman is all for the other; the love that is a man is a receiving of the other's passion. Masculine and feminine loves are no respecters of gender or propriety, class boundaries mean nothing. Our love is all air; the other's love is all earth. Her absence is like a death ...
Like as the waves make towards the pebbled shore,
So do our minutes hasten to their end;
Each changing place with that which goes before,
In sequent toil all forwards do contend.
Nativity, once in the main of light,
Crawls to maturity, wherewith being crown'd,
Crooked eclipses 'gainst his glory fight,
And Time that gave doth now his gift confound.
Time does transfix the flourish set on youth,
And delves the parallels in beauty's brow,
Feeds on the rarities of nature's truth,
And nothing stands but for his scythe to mow.
And yet to times in hope my verse shall stand,
Praising thy worth, despite his cruel hand.
Bernice, slowly, drifted off to sleep and held me close. I kissed her hair which smelled of lilacs and the sea. I noticed that, on our tables, there were some wings made of paper to be placed on the stirrer that came with our frozen coffee drinks. I placed the wings, briefly, in her hair ... like a garland:
" ... [Shakespeare] is able to combine an old theme with a newer one, the theme of rebirth with the theme of sexual love and growth, and the freeing and educative function of erotic ambiguity and sexual disguise. Viola as a boy, though carefully described as high voiced and clear-complexioned, is able to educate both Orsino and Olivia in love, as Rosalind did Orlando in As You Like It, because she is herself in a middle space, [integrated?] in disguise, and in both genders. [Sebastian and Viola are one.] Once again the fact that boy actors played the roles of women on the public stage meant that a boy played a young woman playing a boy -- one reason for the plentiful reminders in this play that Cesario is not a man, but a woman in disguise. ... "
Marjorie Garber, "Twelfth Night," in Shakespeare After All (New York: Pantheon, 2004), p. 508.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)