Sunday, August 16, 2009

Uniforms and Metaphysical Guilt.

December 19, 2009 at 4:41 P.M. "Error" inserted in this essay. I have now corrected it.

August 16, 2009 at 11:33 A.M. The image that accompanies this essay at Critique depicts a group of women inmates in unshapely striped prison uniforms. That image and many controversial images continues to be blocked at blogger. My access to Critique is denied because MSN groups is said to be "closed." I cannot see my books on-line. One book will not be sent to on-line booksellers because of a single reference to Fidel Castro, I believe. The ISBN number that I purchased for that book may have been invalidated to prevent distribution of this work. Cyberharassment and cybercrime is a daily experience for me. Feminism is in the streets and on-line. This is a humble feminist statement from a supportive male. These are the issues where (I think) feminism is important, even a life-or-death matter.

February 12, 2009 at 10:59 A.M. "errors" were inserted in this essay. I will now correct them.

Do you think it helps in reintegrating incarcerated women into society to have them dress in cartoon-like uniforms? Do you think that providing every woman in prison with business attire that will allow her to interview, successfully, for a job when she gets out -- or even before leaving prison -- makes sense? I do. In the Internet age, office work and media outlets can employ women inmates for a fair wage, allowing them to have satisfying and creative employment PRIOR to returning to society.

Millions of jobs in personnel and data management, insurance and record-keeping now being shipped to China and India or Third World countries can be done by women inmates for decent money and benefits. If inmates can't go to the office, today, then the electronic office can come to them. Other societies -- like Denmark, I believe -- allow women to work for money in prison, to dress as they like, maintain all familial relationships -- and, especially, relationships with children -- living decently and facilitating reintegration into society.

This policy makes excellent sense. Women inmates can pay taxes, save for retirement, prove their ability as employees, stay in touch with people and events in society. As a result, they are much more successful in avoiding repeat offenses. Furthermore, I believe that women with such positions are less likely to commit infractions while incarcerated. ("Foucault, Rose, Davis and the Meanings of Prison.")

People are not born criminals. Despite the nonsense still being disseminated by social scientists and others suggesting that brain chemistry explains criminality, we all know at a visceral level that crime is mostly, overwhelmingly, about responding to desperate conditions. Most people would not choose crime. Most women do not dream of violating the law or a life in prostitution. There are few options in this world for millions of people. For a tiny number, there are no options.

Part of the reason for this lack of options is feeding back to people early in life a negative image of their worth and capacities, instilling the idea in women (mostly) that they are worthless, that they do not matter, reducing them to the status of fungible goods, easily replaced and unworthy of respect or consideration. You have to turn people into nothing in order for them to see others as nothing. My friend, Sam, was recently arrested for being poor and homeless. This arrest will be really helpful with any self-esteem issues that he may be struggling against. I have never been charged with a crime in my life. The ad hominem stuff put out by New Jersey is bullshit.

It is not difficult to persuade women to accept such a demeaning identity when they find themselves so often utterly powerless, hungry, poverty-striken and without even the emotional resources -- the sense of being loved no matter what -- which allows survivors to cope with such adversity. ("Beauty and the Beast.")

I am not suggesting that media images are entirely to blame for such horror nor do I suggest censorship, I am merely saying that giving poor and powerless young women a feeling for their options and rights to respect as well as the attention of society can begin with media, schools, churches, government. Let's not have them wear striped prison uniforms, for instance, and work on teaching skills and methods of self-presentation that not everyone learns at home.

Censorship, insults, death threats and other pleasant daily attacks directed against me or my writings will have little effect at this point in my life, after my experiences, but they are likely to be much more psychologically devastating for young men and women encountering the system and reality of power in America for the first time. Most female offenders are under 45 years of age. Perhaps, today, even under 35 years of age. Many people are shocked at the extent and flagrancy of government criminality. ("How Censorship Works in America" and "What is it like to be tortured?")

I am still angry about this unjust reality. I continue to believe and argue that millions of shattered lives is simply unacceptable in our -- until now -- rich society. We cannot live with this incalculable waste of human potential and creative power when those qualities are more desperately needed than ever before. I experience this insight as wounding and painful beyond my ability to describe because of the persons I know whose gifts are thrown away, whose chances for some joy and meaning in life are trashed, whose victimization by power is turned into an accusation against them.

Each day that the cover-up continues, Mr. Rabner, is a renewal of the tortures for many persons, including women -- women who have suffered enough in hard lives where judicial robes and deference have not featured prominently. ("Letter From a Torture Chamber.")

What are we teaching women forced to wear this cartoon-like striped uniform? We are teaching them to see themselves as criminals, as laughable sub-humans, who are worthy of mistreatment and deserving of no other life but the needlessly miserable existence to which they are relegated by unfeeling judges. Most of those women will be leaving prison. Why should it surprise us that they will commit more crimes as soon as they get out? Or that they will come to feel that they belong nowhere else? We -- and that includes YOU -- are telling such women, usually terribly victimized, exploited, abused women, long before they get to any prison, that they are less than human, that they are slaves.

Dehumanization in all its forms is something I find unbearable. Delight in cruelty, pleasure in causing pain and destroying emotional lives is far worse because it speaks of the self-chosen moral deformations of power-wielders (Alex? Diana?), whose grotesque cruelties come to define them in time. Women's prisons seem to be filled with such people in minor administrative positions -- people whose tiny bit of power makes them god-like within the confines of a prison, but still the intellectually and morally repulsive individuals they are and always will be in society. Dodi?

Every kind of imposition of power produces its resistance in a dialectical dance that will consume both partners. Incarcerated women develop ways of resisting the conditions of violation and struggling for their humanity. Perhaps they modify their uniforms slightly, or develop a code of behavior and language among themselves that excludes the people who exclude them, or they may struggle to learn and read enough to work on their own cases in order to speak their truths to power.

The most overwhelming burden by the time a person reaches middle age is the realization that, perhaps, 90% of the world's cruelties are unnecessary. Worse, the infliction of pointless suffering on powerless persons gives pleasure to their tormentors in the dungeons of America -- like Trenton, New Jersey. Something highly disturbing about human nature is revealed in the images accompanying this essay, assuming they haven't been blocked by New Jersey's Cubanazo hackers, which would be even more helpful to my argument. ("American Hypocrisy and Luis Posada Carriles" and "Does Senator Menendez Have Mafia Friends?") Neither Menendez nor Posada Carriles is in prison:

"There exists a solidarity among men as human beings that makes each co-responsible for every wrong and every injustice in the world, especially for crimes committed in his presence or with his knowledge. If I fail to do whatever I can to prevent them, I too am guilty. If I was present at the murder of others without risking my life to prevent it, I feel guilty in a way not adequately conceivable either legally, politically or morally. That I live after such a thing has happened weighs upon me as indelible guilt. ..."

Please see "America's Holocaust" and "Crimes Against Humanity in New Jersey." This is not about personal guilt, morons, it's about our collective guilt for this unjust state of affairs. (One new "error" inserted by New Jersey shit heads. I have now corrected that "error" until next time.)

" ... Metaphysical guilt is the lack of absolute solidarity with the human being as such -- an indestructible claim beyond morally meaningful duty. This solidarity is violated by my presence at a wrong or a crime. It is not enough that I cautiously risk my life to prevent it; if it happens and if I was there, and if I survive where the other is killed, I know from a voice within myself I am guilty of being still alive."

Karl Jaspers, quoted in, Norman Geras, The Contract of Mutual Indifference: Political Philosophy After the Holocaust (New York & London: Verso, 1998), pp. 53-54. ("Would you have helped Kitty Genovese?")

What have you become, Stuart Rabner? Are you not interested in New Jersey's "crimes against humanity." Governor Corzine? Stuart, this is not a matter that calls for "judicial minimalism."

Saturday, August 15, 2009

Skinny People Dressed in Black.

January 12, 2010 at 11:43 A.M. After making several additions to this text, the revisions were erased. I will now, once again, make the same additions to the text. ("Debbie Poritz Likes the Ladies!")

December 19, 2009 at 6:25 P.M. Several essays were vandalized, "errors" have been inserted and corrected.

November 10, 2009 at 3:34 P.M. "Errors" inserted and corrected. "Lesbian love-fest," Anne? ("Trenton's Nasty Lesbian Love Fest!" and "Jennifer Velez is a 'Dyke Magnet!'")

August 15, 2009 at 11:10 A.M. The usual harassment and cyberwarfare this week. This essay is controversial with the Femi-Nazi thought police. This is sufficient reason to post it again. Censorship from the Left or Right is equally offensive to me. Not only will publishing opportunities be denied to me -- and people like me -- but an effort will be made to suppress and censor my "controversial" writings. For my defense of feminist views, see "David Stove and the Intellectual Capacity of Women." For a sample of my experiences, see "What is it like to be plagiarized?" ("Barack Obama and 'The New Yorker.'")

June 4, 2008 at 12:29 P.M. I experienced interference with my cable signal as I tried to post this essay. My security system is under attack and cannot be updated. New "errors" inserted, presumably by Femi-Nazis, on November 1, 2008 at 12:16 P.M. ("What is it like to be tortured?")

Hackers have inserted new "errors" in this essay. July 27, 2007 at 9:44 A.M. I am blocking:

http://ad.N2434.doubleclick.net/ad/N2434.msn/B2 (NJ)
http://view.atdmt.com/von/iview/msnnkvos01200 (NJ)

How serious are we about our commitment to the First Amendment and freedom of speech? How much of our professed defense of free expression is a lie? "Doubleclick?"

More censorship and "errors" previously corrected, reinserted in the text. I think this is about exhausting me. I do not believe that it will be effective and it does give me the opportunity to reemphasize my arguments. I think my questions concerning the Constitution have now been answered.

November 22, 2008 at 10:59 A.M. More "errors" inserted and corrected.

January 11, 2009 at 3:51 P.M. Same old, same old. This revised essay was first posted in November, 2008.

I.

One of the strangest aspects of contemporary American politics is the intensity of the divisions in society. I believe that these divisions are primarily cultural and not political. They express themselves in political and legal warfare, as always, in America. The tone of political discussions and intellectual content has declined steadily over the past two decades. The nation is still about evenly divided between Republicans and Democrats.

We are witnessing one of the meanest eras in the politics of personal destruction -- which began with the Clinton impeachment effort and is approaching dangerous levels again -- at the dawn of a new presidential election season. I applaud Senator (now President) Obama's efforts to distance himself from the political attack machines used by both parties. ("President Obama and 'The New Yorker.'")

We feel powerless about the raging controversies and experiences of unfairness as well as oppression in some extreme cases within the American political and legal system. The analogy to rape is useful. The individual often experiences him- or herself as powerless against sinister forces in American society concerned to distract and cover-up the reality of power wielded against people, power used to exploit and abuse them, to steal from them, even to destroy them in pointless military struggles. "Them" means "us." ("Invicta Watch Company" and "The Invicta Watch Compnay Caper.")

We know we are being screwed. We know that it is illegal, unconstitutional, evil that so much of our tax money is stolen before our eyes. However, there is not very much that we can do about it -- our politicians are often sold out, coopted, complicit in the horror. We return to the Constitution for inspiration and struggle. We fight. We persevere. We must never give up. Sadly, it is the weakest of us who are made into instruments of oppression, utilized to provide ass cover for politicians. ("Terry Tuchin, Diana Lisa Riccioli, and New Jersey's Agency of Torture" and "What is it like to be censored in America?")

I read in The New York Times an account of a political speech focusing on Senator Clinton's "cleavage." Earlier I read an account of Mrs. Thompson's "cleavage." I think those descriptions are inappropriate and offensive. They are one indication of what I have been dealing with -- anything you read in these blogs is mild compared to what has been said about me and others that I care about -- from the sort of people found at the bottom of America's political barrel which is New Jersey.

Constitutional and copyright protection means nothing to some N.J. legal officials. I'd like to provide such persons with a little taste of their own medicine.

When politics plunges to such levels, there is a danger that democratic processes will be contaminated permanently. Alternatively, there are some persons who cannot understand the language of civilized discourse even as they expect to be addressed in polite terms by others. When courts and political institutions fail to enforce order and law, there will be a messy struggle in the public square. It is time for authority to exert itself, ensuring the enforcement of Constitutional and human rights, even in the Garden State.

I still cannot run a necessary security scan of my computer. My computer was eventually destroyed by hackers. ("How censorship works in America.")

President George W. Bush is a polarizing figure, mysteriously, even more than Reagan and Clinton were in their day. People HATE -- even loathe and despise -- good old, mild-mannered George W. Bush, much to his chagrin. And those on the Right -- including many who are less than crazy about G.W. because he is not conservative enough -- abominate the sort of people who attack G.W., even more than they dislike him.

I think each faction has a point. Regrettably, many innocent victims are caught in the crossfire. Among those victims is the U.S. Constitution. Collateral damage? ("Manifesto For the Unfinished American Constitution.")

Allow me to make it very clear to anyone who does not understand this: I do not care what you think of me. I probably think less of you and with good reason for my hatred and disgust after daily harassments and plagiarisms of my writings. (Again: "Terry Tuchin, Diana Lisa Riccioli, and New Jersey's Agency of Torture.")

I wish to examine these hostile feelings in U.S. politics (and they are mostly feelings, over and above carefully thought out positions on issues), very briefly, suggesting where common ground may and should be found. What G.W.'s enemies have yet to figure out is that the best thing that President Bush has going for him is his opposition. The same is true for Christopher Christie in New Jersey. ("Censorship and Cruelty in New Jersey.")

Why do I say that? Well, for one thing the source of those comments concerning "cleavage" is not, in my opinion, Republicans, but an extreme sector of the liberal wing of the Democratic party. The condescension and insulting patronizing to which minority intellectuals -- male or female -- are subjected in this society is beyond description. Such treatment must be experienced to be fully understood.

We are often silenced and marginalized. The same may be said for "disconnection" from reality on the part of people hurting you, denying you basic rights, while asking for your understanding and cooperation with their so-called "improvement" efforts. To commit crimes against me is to abandon any right to judge my ethics. Ethics? ("What is it like to be tortured?" then "New Jersey's 'Ethical' Legal System" and "The Office of Attorney Ethics in New Jersey" as well as "New Jersey is the Home of the Living Dead.")

Low-life scum buckets in New Jersey are hardly in a position to judge anybody's ethics. OAE? ("Have you no shame, Mr. Rabner?" and "Law and Ethics in the Soprano State.")

I live in Manhattan. I am a democratic socialist, agnostic, graduate degree, Latino -- and just about everything else that a Democrat is usually thought to be. However, the organized crime group governing New Jersey, ruthlessly and with unbelievable greed as well as stupidity -- while calling themselves Democrats -- together with the skinny-dressed-in-black, "we-know-better-than-you" fashionista-kiwi-munchers (of all ethnicities and sexual persuasions) have made the word "Democrat" affect me the way garlic affects Dracula. Many America feels the same way.

The trouble with stereotypes and cartoon-like reductions of others to sleazy jokes is that the tactic may be turned against its proponents. ("What a man's gotta do.")

I have been insulted and dismissed, denied opportunities to make use of free speech rights and to publish my work by liberal morons. I experience daily cyberviolations of my rights intended to produce violence through frustrations and continuing psychological harm. ("More Censorship and Cybercrime" and, again, "Censorship and Cruelty in New Jersey" then "How censorship works in America.")

People diagnosing the disease at the heart of Senator Clinton's 2008 campaign -- a campaign which I favored in many ways, as I also eventually supported Mr. Obama's efforts -- should look at this issue with care. It will not go away. For instance, New Jersey's caudillo controls judges and law enforcement. Hence, crimes may be committed against people opposed to the regime and their family members (including children and old people) with impunity.

Meanwhile, theft of public funds is a daily reality in the Garden State, all of which is covered up and regarded as "business as usual." Some crimes committed by "our" people in Trenton are O.K. The crimes of inner city kids -- especially African-Americans, Latinos, or working class whites -- are not O.K. ("New Jersey's Feces-Covered Supreme Court" and "Abuse and Exploitation of Women in New Jersey" and "So Black and So Blue in Prison.")

Let us hope that Mr. Christie will improve things. Thus far, little has changed in New Jersey. "Insensitivity to women's issues" seems more troublesome to Anne Milgram than Democrats stealing under her nose in Trenton. ("Anne Milgram Does it Again!")

The reason why many Democrats secretly supported Mr. Obama during the primaries, while claiming to support Ms. Clinton, is that the much-hated liberal attack machine (which is probably responsible for the smears aimed at Senator Harry Reid, who is not any kind of racist and who deserves a lot of credit for the health care bill despite his fondness for Bob Menendez) is, rightly or wrongly, associated with the Clintons.
Whether this attack machine was developed after the Clinton/Lewinsky scandal when the Republican storm troopers went after the Clintons -- developed for defensive reasons, that is -- does not obviate the reality of shared blame for this viciousness in contemporary politics.

Incidentally, I generally support the Clintons and have voted for Hillary. A plague on both your houses, Democrats and Republicans.

What more do you need to know before you take some action, Anne Milgram, Esq.? Mr. Chiesa? Ever heard of cybercrime, Anne? Conspiracies to violate civil rights? Attorney General? Why not comply with the Constitution, Anne Milgram? Do the right thing for once. You'll feel better about your karma, Anne. Therapy? Ms. Letitia James? (Again: "New Jersey's 'Ethical' Legal System.")

I recall sitting in a New Jersey Superior Court criminal session and noticing that every defendant was an African-American or Latino male. I also remember thinking that several lawyers and judges were much worse criminals than any of those defendants. ("Neil M. Cohen, Esq. and Conduct Unbecoming to the Legislature in New Jersey" and "Is Paul Bergrin, Esq. an Ethical New Jersey Lawyer?" then "Have you no shame, Mr. Rabner?")

It is not simply that many New Jersey Democrats are corrupt and arrogant, ignorant and pompous, but that they presume to "instruct" the rest of us concerning the state of a "real world" that they do not understand at all. How could they? They do not live in the real world. Judges? These are the same people who, much too often, are in control of media and publishing.

Which distinguished New Jersey official or judge is having a difficult time accepting the loss of an argument with me? Stuart? Sybil? Time to "adjust and move on." Philosophically, you didn't know what you were talking about, Anne. If it is any consolation, Anne, Senator Menendez knows even less than you do about ethics or politics, to say nothing of philosophy. "Jennifer Shuessler"? "Michiko Kakutani"? Jim Holt? Manohla  Dargis? Who comes up with these names? ("John Finnis and Ethical Cognitivism" and "Why I am not an ethical relativist.")

Yes, America, there is a liberal death-grip on media! New York media reads like the newsletter of a country club where everyone graduated from Yale and supports "progressive causes." Everybody has read the same six or seven books, holds pretty much the same opinions, and shares the same house in Long Island during the summers.

Did you like The Da Vinci Code? There is something about "Bee Keeping" and "Kite Flying" that is very popular with well-dressed imbeciles on the Upper East side who are each issued something called a "yoga mat." Whatever. ("Incoherence in 'The New York Times'" and "Incoherence in 'The New Yorker.'")

One's politics will always be less important than genuflecting to so-called "media elites" which I refuse to do. I debated people concerning philosophical issues and discovered shocking levels of ignorance among graduates of "elite" American universities and members of "learned professions" who see themselves as my intellectual and moral "superiors."

The realization that I was -- I still am -- more intelligent and better educated than most of these alleged assholes, even as an average guy, was grounds for my personal destruction by these politically-connected drinkers of designer water. Perrier? I am sure that these people also approve of America's drone weapons and starvation tactics as "soft power." I refuse to purchase (or wear) "biodegradable underwear." This is not a sign of "insensitivity to women's issues." Must we endure an hour-long program by Rachel Maddow? Melissa Harris-Perry? ("Genius and Lust.")

Care for some "organic" grapes? At Whole Foods in Manhattan a section of the store is reserved for fruits that are especially grown to be eaten exclusively by gay persons. Many of these fruits are said to be of the Buddhist persuasion. Try some Papaya, Anne? ("Oh, to be in India!")

There comes a point in one's life when insults and threats become intolerable, especially coming from people who are hardly in a position to feel "superior" on the basis of their own learning or scholarship, much less on the basis of their self-admired "ethics" -- like Jaynee LaVecchia or Stuart Rabner. ("Jaynee LaVecchia and Conduct Unbecoming to the Judiciary in New Jersey. "Stuart Rabner and Conduct Unbecoming to the Judiciary in New Jersey.")

One day you wake up and know that you won't take the bullshit anymore. ("Sybil R. Moses and Conduct Unbecoming to the Judiciary in New Jersey" and "Jay Romano and Conduct Unbecoming to the Judiciary in New Jersey.")
Jay writes for The New York Times, ostensibly in the English language, while acting as a Municipal Court Judge in North Bergen, New Jersey. I have no idea what Jay Romano or Kelly Anne Michaels may be up to these days. ("What is it like to be plagiarized?" and "'Brideshead Revisited': A Movie Review.")

What really pisses off some people about G.W. (or John McCain and, possibly, Mr. Romney) is that he is not into the trendy P.C. nonsense. Neither am I. Lots of intelligent Americans have just about had it with the cultural language police and bien pensant battalions who have appointed themselves as the guardians of our political virtue. These are the people who have made themselves the guardians of our intellectual lives: If you speak of God, then you are a Christian fundamentalist barbarian; if you compliment a woman on her appearance, then you are a sexist pig. Actually pigs have now organized and insist on being referred to as "swine beings." (Yes, "referred" can be written with one or two "r's," especially "down da shore" in New Jersey.)

Worse, if you dare to speak of right and wrong, good and evil, then you are a primitive, "unscientific" and uneducated person because there is no such thing as right and wrong, since everything is totally relative -- except for this one transcendent truth and all the P.C. stuff, which is objectively correct, and don't you forget it.

Philosophical ignorance of these concepts is an epidemic among the so-called educated "class" in America. The response when one points out the logical incoherence of such views is disdain, condescension, and censorship. ("Nihilists in Disneyworld" and "Whatever!")

This would be a good time for more inserted "errors," Ms. Milgram. More Jersey "Chics?" ("Diana's Friend Goes to Prison!" and "Wedding Bells Ring For Menendez!")

A recent article in the Times concerning the Heidegger controversy is an embarrassing example of philosophical illiteracy which should be unacceptable in America's premier newspaper. Was it written by Anne Milgram? "Patricia Cohen," Anne? Mary Anne Kriko? Has Ms. Kriko, finally, been disbarred? Gilberto Garcia? Nydia Hernandez? Lillian Munoz? Estela De La Cruz? (See my forthcoming essay, "The Heidegger Controversy.")

You will not make yourself more clever -- or obscure your areas of unforgivable ignorance -- by deleting a word from my essay, Anne Milgram. Cybercrime should not be a feature of any New Jersey Attorney General's standard operating procedure. Does the Cubanaza work in your office, Anne? Is it Nydia Hernandez? Estela? Do you find it difficult to get rid of this person because she has a "hook" in Senator Bob? Vice versa, as it were? Manohla? ("Manohla Dargis Strikes Again!")

Manohla (Nydia?), who is often "in the thick of things," is aptly called: "Manhola Dargis." How many people use that name at the Times? Who do these "journalists" belong to, Mr. Menendez? Iliana Ros-Leghtinen? Lizette Alvarez? Lourdes Santiago?

II.

Let me be clear about this: I am sure that there are good and evil, right and wrong. I want a political candidate who can tell the difference between these options and who is concerned to "do the right thing." I am not tempted to vote for a nihilist for high political office. I am sure that most Americans feel the same way. The only way that either Clinton or Obama will be elected to the presidency is by not being identified with the liberal wing of the Democratic party. Ask yourself why that is true. All of this hostility from the far Left makes John Edwards (or John McCain) look better every day. Rand Paul? ("Nihilism Against Memory" and "Nihilists in Disneyworld.")

Pictured above is the controversial cover of the New Yorker magazine featuring a drawing of Senator Obama, which may be blocked by N.J. hackers at any time. My access to my own blogs or MSN account may be obstructed or blocked dozens of times per day for harassment purposes or in order to maximize harmful frustrations. The number of intrusions, illegal spyware, hacks and blocking of images on my computer is a matter for daily speculation. My multiple scans reveal dozens of viruses attacking my system every day. Much of this cyberwarfare is only made possible by government technology and is part of much worse that has been done against me by New Jersey's corrupt politicians.

You are witnessing content-based, governmental censorship and violations of civil rights in America that are taking place PUBLICLY. ("Does Senator Menendez Have Mafia Friends?" and "Another Mafia Sweep in New Jersey and Anne Milgram is Clueless" and "Have you no shame, Mr. Rabner?")

I am "for" full equality. I never offend against political correctness unless I know that it will bother one of my self-styled social "superiors" for me to do so. Payback. (Diana Lisa Riccioli, this bud's for you.)

America wants the chi-chi political fashionistas to know: "We will make up our own minds about the issues and candidates, what we wear or eat, cultural options and loving relations as well as Doctor Phil-like 'relationship-issues,' including -- for those born with this bizarre sexual-orientation -- heterosexual relationships and their discontents."

Don't tell us with whom we can have sex or what persons we may love. Mind your own business if you are a politician or judge.

Who wrote the political advertisement for Senator Clinton that said: "We are America's women"? What gives you the right to speak for ALL of America's women, excluding supporters of other candidates who happen to be females as "lesser" or non-women? Is part of the definition of a woman in America a person who is a "liberal and pro-choice" and supports Ms. Clinton's political ambitions? Must a woman stare at MSNBC all day? I ask this question as a pro-choice Leftist, also as a pluralist and democrat (with a small "d"), not as someone who presumes to speak for women.

I happen to have voted for Ms. Clinton in several elections. I will probably do so again, someday, I hope, assuming that, outside of New York, men and non-lesbians are permitted to support Ms. Clinton. ("A Commencement Address by Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton.")

The problem is your arrogance and presumption, "female persons" (Ms. Wolf? Ms. Faludi? Ms. Klein?), in speaking for so-called "lesser" others, or presuming to govern the lives of others who are not interested in what you have to say, much less in being told by someone who attended Yale University and now has earned a driver's license, what we are permitted to think or say as male individuals of a certain age.

Is Christina Hoff-Sommers still a woman even if she rejects some items on the so-called "feminist agenda" and supports John McCain? I think so. I understand that women's political views may differ. I cannot understand a woman who facilitates rape, abuse, and theft of other women's dignity. Ms. Riccioli, are you sensitive to women's issues? ("Terry Tuchin, Diana Lisa Riccioli, and New Jersey's Agency of Torture" and "Neil M. Cohen, Esq. and Conduct Unbecoming to the Legislature in New Jersey" as well as "We don't know from nothing!" and "Diana's Friend Goes to Prison!")

How can you be an apologist for the state of New Jersey's notorious criminality that victimizes so many women, children, and others and call yourself any kind of feminist? ("New Jersey Superior Court Judge is a Child Molester" and "Judges Protect Child Molesters in Bayonne, New Jersey.")

I can't imagine how anyone can take a good look at New Jersey and avoid puking. "Ethics?" You are judging my ethics? 1988-today? You will first need to get some ethics yourselves in New Jersey before you will be in a position to comment on my character or morals. Maybe you should borrow some ethics from New York, or other states. ("New Jersey's Judges Disgrace America" and "New Jersey's Failed Judiciary.")

This would probably be a good time to delete a letter from one of my words. Thank God, they finally replaced Codey and Roberts in their positions, not to mention Corzine. Americans need Christopher Christie to be sworn-in soon as governor of the Garden State in order to rescue the endangered Constitution. Let's hope the good stuff is happening, finally, in Trenton. Lock 'em up, Mr. Christie -- after your stomach surgery, that is. Assuming that Christie manages to avoid prison himself the alternatives to his administration in New Jersey may be even worse than Mr. Christie. ("Christie Attacks New Jersey's Corrupt Judges!")

On the other side of this cultural divide are those good folks residing somewhere near the buckle of the Bible belt, who insist that New York is home only to homosexuals and sexual perverts, women of easy virtue and atheism. These were certainly the things that I was looking for when I moved here. To these good folks ("rock-solid-God-fearing-tax-paying" Americans), these sinful qualities of Manhattanites explain many of our troubles with terrorism and disease.

God is displeased with our sinfulness. We must repent before it is too late!

I would be happy to cooperate, after I have met some of those women of easy virtue. Sadly, there are none in my building. I am only interested in women my age, incidentally. I have only been involved with women exactly my age during my entire lifetime and very few of those, unfortunately -- or maybe fortunately.

The "Femi-Nazi" insistence on forcing everyone into stereotypical categories, whether they -- or we -- fit into those categories is irrelevant and offensive. ("Is he joking?")

This sort of "fire and brimstone" reasoning has an ancient pedigree, as Gore Vidal points out. For example, under the Code of Justinian, homosexuality was outlawed throughout the empire since it was generally recognized that gay sex causes earthquakes. Apparently, in the ancient world when people spoke of the earth moving, they weren't kidding. My guess is that when told this, our gay or straight friends today may respond that good sex still causes earthquakes, if you're very lucky. This is especially true in parts of Long Island, I am told.

These two sides of America are not going to "come together" (no pun intended!) any time soon. Most people are in the middle, as it were, since dad is a "gun-toting" Republican, and his much-loved daughter, Katherine -- who goes to Barnard and reads Sylvia Plath ("who is, like, the greatest writer ever!") -- is a liberal. Katherine and her friends insist on a spiritual politics without violence, except against Republicans like her dad, of course.

Again: I am a socialist and an independent. As a friend in Union City used to say, "I don't owe nobody nothing."

There is simply not enough room for compromise between such polarized positions. All of this makes for fun weekend get-togethers with the family, except that the United States can now count on the hatred of much of the rest of the world -- thanks to our adventures in Iraq and Afghanistan -- but, equally, because of such things as American cultural "hegemony" (we make movies that everybody wants to see) and our economic imperialism (everybody likes our fast food, music and fashions, it's our cars they can live without).

We are "greedy and insensitive" according to nations hoping to be even greedier and more insensitive than we are in the twenty-first century. We are "evil" say the millions who hope to get a visa so they can visit New York or L.A., several hundred thousand of whom have written a script that they hope someone in Hollywood will read. ("It is perfect for Sylvester Stalone ...")

A woman approached me one night when I was lucky enough to be smoking a good cigar, aiming a piercing glance in my direction and noticing that my attention was drawn to the posterior of a young woman walking directly ahead of me, she said: "Don't look at that woman's ass!"

I ask you -- the civilized reader of these words -- whether one may reasonably be expected not to look at an attractive (adult!) woman's ass?

I suggest that whether I look at and/or admire, aesthetically, any woman's ass is my business.

The cleavage issue is not a suitable or relevant matter in political debates. However, I guarantee you that men will notice cleavage "issues" and "asses." (Notice the quotation marks.)

Women know this about men, making fashion choices that are deliberately based on this forbidden knowledge. No one will live P.C. bullshit in their daily lives beyond the necessity to be polite for expedient reasons. Yes, you are welcome to call me an "ass" for pointing out the obvious. ("On Bullshit.")
In a free society, we should not censor or seek to alter the conduct of others by force. We argue and try to persuade one another concerning these matters. P.C. rules produce not a "kinder and gentler" society only a more hypocritical one. I urge you to read Philip Roth's The Human Stain.
Meanwhile, there really are evil people out there who wish to kill you and those you love merely because of your nationality or because you are wealthier than they are. There are people who wish to obstruct the progress of science in curing diseases and feeding billions because a "holy book" says we must not trust in anything but prayer.

We must find a way to oppose real terrorism without becoming terrorists or living in dictatorship.

Paradoxically, there are also some in the most affluent societies who believe, with equal irrationality, that because science yields accurate knowledge of the workings of empirical reality, it can somehow resolve moral or political controversies, or "explain" such cultural mysteries as romantic love in evolutionary terms (it can't); or tell us what is the meaning of life, or even define the role of science in society (it can't).

These questions of meaning and values must be decided dialogically, not through some experiment or imposed solution. You certainly will not condition me into accepting slavery.

Values questions are not scientifically resolvable or they would not remain "open" questions. We will not find our moral meanings "out there," in nature, existing independently of us in the empirical world; values will not be seen under a microscope; rather, moral truth and beauty may be achieved only by us, through reasoning and dialectics, neither of which are ever entirely dispassionate. (Kant, Hegel, Blanshard. )

This does not make such things unreal or unobjective, much less pointless or untrue. By the same token, no matter how much we learn about the brain, we will not discover the mind "in" the brain, even after we figure out how it is that consciousness arises from cerebral processes, if we ever do.

Vandalism and censorship do not help you to prevail in an argument nor can such tactics prove that you are right about something. When you resort to such tactics, you are admitting defeat on a substantive issue, then seeking to compensate for this inability to respond, effectively, to an adversary by silencing or hurting him. This was traditionally the reaction to WOMEN'S creative and intellectual efforts -- suppression, censorship, trivializing. I will continue to write, focusing on more New Jersey judges and municipalities, seeking the truth in my life. ("New Jersey's Feces-Covered Supreme Court" and "New Jersey's Political and Supreme Court Whores.")

An "error" was inserted by New Jersey's hackers in this essay to start the new year. I will focus on former Chief Justice Poritz's "allegedly" corrupt lesbian relationship. Was Ms. Poritz given sexual introductions to young women by Diana Lisa Riccioli in exchange for "favors"? What contacts (if any) did Ms. Poritz have with Marilyn Straus when Diana Lisa Riccioli was simultaneously involved with Ms. Straus and/or "other women, including Ms. Poritz? ("Deborah T. Poritz and Conduct Unbecoming to the Judiciary in New Jersey.")
This is my response to New Jersey's continuing defacements of this essay as well as on-going efforts to censor and suppress my work. Struggle. I am not the sort of person who is easily intimidated.

I wonder why the number of visitors to my blogs has not changed despite thousands of "hits" that have come to my attention? Coincidence? "Approximate?" The number of hits at this blog are not counted in increments of one hundred. Mysteriously, the number listed at my profile has suddenly changed in weird ways. How curious? I wonder whether MSN groups is still "closed" and why my book is suppressed? ("How censorship works in America.")

The mind is an abstract concept, whereas the brain is an organ in the physical body of an individual. You need a brain to develop a mind. However, a brain will not be sufficient without language and social setting. Mental development will be warped or stunted and deformed in any person growing up alone in a deserted island.

We are social animals, whose mental health -- even flourishing "minds" -- depend on the presence of others, especially others who are loved by us and who love us in return. Hence, the irreversible injury that is done to a victim whose closest relationships and professional identity are shattered, together with damage to self-esteem, as part of an involuntary "program of testing, secretly, our latest psychological warfare techniques." ("An Open Letter to My Torturers in New Jersey, Terry Tuchin and Diana Lisa Riccioli.")

The very sight of persons cooperating with such efforts directed against a "targeted" professional makes me physically sick. When those who cooperate claim to be friends or relatives, the disgust and anger I feel is much greater. If there is anyone more loathsome than the individual willing to spy upon and inform against family members for a small fee, I cannot imagine who it might be. Ridgewood, New Jersey? Do you really believe that forced association will be helpful, Terry? Think again. ("Jennifer Velez is a Dyke Magnet!")

We live as subjects, also in objective categories that are only meaningful socially -- like the categories of "male, American, father, middle-aged," etc. I need other people. So do you. This is not some shameful weakness. Despite the truly moronic opinions of Dr. Phil, Barbara Streisand had it right: "People who need people are the luckiest people in the world." No wonder Barbara's picture is found in many bodegas in Manhattan. Poisoning or destroying those needed relationships is evil. ("God is Texting Me!")

We are in this situation together folks, as Americans or just as human beings. We need one another. If we are at one another's throats then none of us will make it. The United States, with all of its faults, is a great and good nation -- with the exception of the corrupt power-structure in New Jersey -- and it occasionally needs to be defended from the enemies of freedom in the world. This is not to deny our right to criticize any U.S. government for its policy failures or crimes. ("NSA Spying is Illegal.")

Iraq is a colossal catastrophe for America, not just one party. No one should be thrilled about a catastrophe afflicting all of us in America, for decades, even if it gets your guys and gals elected to office. The nightmare has spread to Afghanistan and Pakistan, India may go up in flames. Syria? Some Americans believe that a confrontation with China, Korea, or Cuba would add spice to our lives. I am "for" peace and an end to these costly and increasingly pointless military adventures that are destroying America's economy.

"Victory is within reach" will always be said by politicians, even as helicopters remove the last Americans from a burning city and enemy troops swarm the airport. You already know this about freedom in the U.S. You prove it by protesting against the government that guarantees your right to do just that. Yes, there are terrorists in the world. The very people who would instantly wipe out all of those who are "different" -- gays and racial minorities, religious and cultural eccentrics. Those who are different and who do not fare well in lots of other places in the world seem to like it here just fine.

Mr. Obama, sending more troops to Afghanistan and Iraq may be likened to jumping into quicksand to join a drowing person. Why not extend a tree branch and "pull out" the victim? I am old enough to remember daily assurances that more troops would bring victory in Vietnam. 50,000 American deaths later, there was no victory in Vietnam. How many deaths will convince us in Afghanistan? Iraq? Pakistan? America's "secret war" in Pakistan is no secret. Anybody remember Cambodia? Yemen? Syria?

Part of what is at the core of the United States is tolerance of diversity, a desire to make the world safe for "weirdos" (like me, you say!), that is, for persons who wish to think differently, originally and creatively ... or just to think at all. Censorship, destruction of written work, secret proceedings, experimenting on people and then lying or stone-walling about it are all criminal actions, so is stealing a good watch -- even when New Jersey Democrats do it. Terry? Diana? Debbie Poritz? When do I get those reports, Anne? ("No More Cover-Ups and Lies, Chief Justice Rabner!" then "Mafia Influence in New Jersey Courts and Politics.")

The deepest truth at the heart of the American experiment is a confidence in human goodness and in the hope for a better world. The American Constitution was a fragile paper boat cast adrift on the stormy seas of history -- a paper boat which is still sailing along very nicely even as the great steel battleships of Fascism and Communist totalitarianism (Stalin) have (deservedly!) sunk to the bottom of the sea.

Do not underestimate this fragile hope for humanity or the power of love. ("Manifesto For the Unfinished American Constitution.")

We have to learn to live between subjective and objective, particular and universal -- because we are both -- which is another way of saying that we live in languages, not only verbal languages. Maybe a way for me to explain what it "feels" like to be reduced to a category of vilification, again, is to give others a taste of the experience. It seems to be working.

See the essays in the General section at my MSN group, Critique -- if it still exists -- and my forthcoming essay concerning Judge Tolentino (possibly the most stupid person I ever encountered in the legal profession) that will serve as my response to these continuing censorship efforts. Many N.J. lawyers shared this view concerning Judge Tolentino. I will be delighted to name them, publicly. Did you join the "lesbian love-fest," Luisa? Is it "Luisa Gutierrez, Esq."? Why were you, Luisa, involved in trying to harm me behind my back? Gilberto Garcia? Mary Anne Kriko? Do you enjoy being called a "skinny-person-dressed-in-black-kiwi-munching-fashionista," Ms. De La Cruz? I know that I would. (What exactly did you say about me behind my back, Estela? And what name did you give to Marilyn Straus when you raped her, Estela de La Cruz?)

Do not suppress or destroy speech by anyone, especially not the expressions of persons who are compelled to speak out, to write and publish their ideas. Don't destroy people's creative work appearing on the Internet. Feel free to respond to it -- if you don't agree or dislike it -- be open to their responses. There is much that we should agree on, as Americans, like our right to disagree. Let us build on that foundational agreement and cooperate. We need each other, as I say, now more than ever. The problems that we face are very great.

Being subjected to behind-the-back slanders for years has caused me to seek public confrontations with my enemies and discussion of their insults as well as being very explicit in my responses in kind.

Do not oppose everything that a U.S. president proposes merely because the idea comes from the White House. Examine suggestions and proposals on the merits. Think of ways in which someone different from you is like you. That person is your fellow citizen, brother or sister, and he or she will share many of your flaws and experiences in life, including the ultimate and unavoidable ones: love and death. Think of how that person sees you. I will do my best to make it clear to New Jersey officials how I see them. ("New Jersey's 'Ethical' Legal System.")

Any more inserted "errors" today? "Ladies"? No.

What would you wish to explain to those who have never spoken to you, but who have made up their minds about you on the basis of your nationality, ethnicity, religion, economic category or music and fashion choices, based on what they're told by others, especially when you're not around to respond?

I was told, I believe, by a New Jersey lawyer and official: "Latinos are not smart enough to be philosophers."

I have enjoyed a twenty-nine year version of this experience of insults and denigration. Take another look at the photos accompanying this essay -- that is, if any have not been been blocked! -- then ask yourself whether being reduced to a stereotype will help a person understand how I feel, every day.

Friday, August 14, 2009

Hegel's Philosophy of Politics and Law.

Numerous attacks on earlier versions of this essay make it necessary for me to try to put the pieces together, again.

G.W.F. Hegel, Phenomenology of Spirit (trans. A.V. Miller) (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1977).
Fredrick Beiser, Hegel (London: Routledge, 2005).
Terry Pinkard, Hegel: A Biography (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2000).
Ronald Dworkin, Justice in Robes (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 2006).
Drucilla Cornell, Beyond Accomodation: Ethical Feminism, Deconstruction, and Law (Oxford: Rowman & Littlefield, 1999).
Judith Butler, Precarious Life: The Powers of Mourning and Violence (London: Verso, 2004).

"The most lasting contribution of Hegel's Logic -- [is] the insight that identity is constituted in and through otherness."

Drucilla Cornell, The Philosophy of the Limit (London: Routledge, 1992), p. 21.

With the appearance of Popper's The Open Society and Its Enemies, Hegel has become a target for those who are hostile to all metaphysics and speculative thinking, both of which are highly necessary. Hegel -- along with Popper's other target, Plato -- is often demonized as a "totalitarian" and "anti-scientific" thinker. I doubt that Hegel was either of those things.

"Hegel is one of those thinkers just about all educated people think they know something about." Terry Pinkard comments: "His philosophy was the forerunner to Karl Marx's theory of history, but unlike Marx, who was a materialist, Hegel was an idealist in the sense that he thought reality was ultimately spiritual, and that it developed according to the process of thesis/antithesis/synthesis. Hegel also glorified the Prussian state, claiming that it was God's work, was perfect, and was the culmination of all human history. All citizens of Prussia owed unconditional allegiance to the state, and it could do with them as it pleased. Hegel played a large role in the growth of German nationalism, authoritarianism, and militarism with his quasi-mystical celebrations of what he pretentiously called the Absolute."

Pinkard concludes: "Just about everything in [this] paragraph is false except for the first sentence." (Pinkard, p. ix.)

Philosophy is vital to intellectual life. The cost of abandoning disciplined rational speculation of a philosophical sort -- that is, theory -- is the popularity of that mixture of New Age mysticism and psychobabble which is often mistaken for wisdom in America today. Worse, rampant scientism that denies the reality of anything that can not be examined in a laboratory.

Feminists have to be better than the options presented to them, usually by a male-dominated power-structure that wants you to believe that heavy philosophy is not for you, whereas chi-chi, fashion magazine "light" feminist theory ("feministing!") is the best you can do. That's bullshit. Feminists cannot afford to be stupid or ignorant of philosophy. ("Judith Butler and Gender Theory.") Feministing is fine; real feminism is in the streets.

Women who are philosophers are doing some serious thinking about political and legal theory, reinventing the work and traditions of guys and gals like Kant and Hegel, Marx and Nietsche, Wollstonecraft and De Beauvoir, Sartre and Weil, Butler and Davis. The best women thinkers on these topics today have figured out that culture is where the action and power is found in postmodernist societies. If we are going to rumble with antifeminists, then culture is where the brawl will take place. You better be ready. ("David Stove and the Intellectual Capacity of Women" then "Let's Hear it For the Boys" and "Thoughts of a Domestic Revolutionary.")

Culture "wars" does NOT mean censorship. It means a willingness to engage with intelligent adversaries and to consider and weigh opposing philosophical views, also a willingness to engage in life-long study and effort in order to achieve political objectives. You always have to be in shape for that title fight.

You can still be a scientist, by the way, and a philosopher -- in fact, you can be philosophical about science. You can do better than Full Frontal Feminism. True science -- as distinct from "scientism" -- is not something that any rational person is against. As I say, Hegel certainly was not anti-science. Hegel was not opposed to scientific inquiry. Hegel believed that science (like spontaneity) has its time, place, and concerns. But then, so does philosophy. ("A Doll's Aria.")

What's wrong with Full Frontal Feminism? Well, for one thing, it is ghettoizing. Feminism is relegated to the status of an eccentric taste for a discreet group of people, like the chess section of the bookstore. Yes, you can spell "discreet" that way. Either feminism is about everything in society changing, or it's about not very much that matters. There's nothing wrong with "in your face feminism." But if you're going to address issues of government policy with respect to war and poverty, conflicts between religion and developments in popular culture for all of humanity, as a feminist (and you should!), then you have an obligation to engage with adversaries in an intellectually sophisticated way and not to be stupid and angry for the wrong reasons. ("Mary Wollstonecraft and William Godwin.")

You must display the scholarship and intellectual daring -- not mere spouting of slogans -- that commands the respect of intellectuals disagreeing with you or hostile to your views. You cannot read only a small list of canonized feminists and imagine that you are in a position to debate complex issues with rivals. By the way, I am not a rival of feminism. I am only opposed to stupidity and intolerance regardless of the "faction" endorsing these things. ("Skinny People Dressed in Black" and "David Stove and the Intellectual Capacity of Women.")

At the center of much of this contemporary debate concerning Hegelian dialectics is the issue of whether Hegel was an apologist for Prussian proto-fascists in the nineteenth century, whose work was amenable to later use by Nazis and other dictators in the twentieth century, or whether Hegel was a "utopian" who was ahead of his time. "Utopian" is a dirty word in American academia and society, which happens to be highly utopian and idealistic, especially about what it calls "realism" and "pragmatism."

" ... we share what we might call an aspirational concept of law," Ronald Dworkin writes, "which we often refer to as the ideal of legality or the rule of law. [emphasis added] For us this aspirational concept is a contested concept: we agree that the rule of law is desirable, but we disagree about what, at least precisely, is the best statement of that ideal. [emphasis added] Some philosophers hold that the rule of law is a purely formal ideal: that legality is fully secured when officials are required to and do act only as established grounds permit. Other philosophers argue for a more substantive conception of the ideal: they think that legality holds only when the standards that officials accept respect certain basic rights of individual citizens." (Dworkin, p. 5.)

To have a proper sense of Hegel's politics, however, one must see what Hegel meant by the State. He did not encourage an uncritical worship of those in power nor a total deference to the wishes of the aristocracy in his native land. What Hegel understood by the State, as set forth in The Philosophy of Right, is "the actuality of the ethical idea." This is really a proposed reconciliation of individualism with communitarianism through a system of law. ("Manifesto for the Unfinished American Revolution" and "The 'Galatea Scenario' and the Mind/Body Problem.")

Hegel agrees with the second group of American legal philosophers to which Dworking refers -- and so do I. There is no law separable from our understanding of justice and ethics. To analogize further to the American situation, for Hegel, the United States is not the messy actuality of what and how we do things at any given time; rather, the U.S. is the best understanding of the Constitutional order "called into being" by the appropriate interpretative community of "philosophers."

The "philosophers" includes the Supreme Court, legal interpreters and critics, participants in government and the intellectual community, that is, the people. The State is the "moral project of the community." This means the "coming into being of freedom and justice" within our Constitutional system is the only truth of the American national "idea." ("What is Law?" and "A Commencement Address by Secretary of State Hillary Rodham-Clinton.")

"The State" does not refer to one of "the things in flux," but to an idea and a standard of judgment, to what states would be like if they lived up fully to their reasons for being. The State -- our legal community -- is always now:

"... This reason is to be found partly in a higher sphere ... The whole realm of Objective Spirit and human institutions that culminates in the state is but the foundation of a higher realm of Absolute Spirit that comprises art, religion and philosophy." (Kaufman)

Students of the film "Gladiator" will recall the emperor's question to Maximus: "What is Rome, Maximus?" The answer from Maximus was "Rome is an idea." Well, the United States is also an idea. Revolution? Law? These are ideas and ideals.

America is an idea of the dignity of individuals who are guaranteed inviolable rights under law, rights even against government. Those of us who have reason to believe that -- much too often -- this promise is a cruel lie may nevertheless continue to believe in that promise as a hope if not a reality. I admit that, in New Jersey, such a hope may be naive or an impossible wish. Fortunately, New Jersey is not typical of the United States of America. ("Manifesto for the Unfinished American Revolution.")

Discussions of the State lead immediately to the concept of Law. The word is capitalized when referring to Law in the abstract, as an idea. Hegel uses the word Recht. Law must not be corrupted, violated, tainted or deviated from merely for the sake of momentary expediency in a Constitutional democracy, especially not by the State or mechanisms of law enforcement. Rights must never be sacrificed to expediency or social experiments:

" ... the hatred of law, of right made determinate by law, is the shibboleth which reveals and permits us to recognize infallibly, fanaticism, feeble-mindedness, and the hypocrisy of good intentions, however they may disguise themselves." (Hegel)

Professor Drucilla Cornell (I love the two "l's" -- twice!) is really smart and scary in her knowledge of Hegel and every other intimidating Continental thinker of the last two hundred years. You do not want to tangle with her in any debate on these issues nor would it be wise to bump into her in a dark seminar room when she's pissed off. Get this:

"As we have seen in Hegel, legal rules are given ethical meaning by reference to the realized Good of relations of reciprocal symmetry. Let me emphazise that when I use the word meaning, I am not referring to institutionalized linguistic meaning in the sense of the intelligibility of sentences, but instead to ethical meaning. Hegel understood that the dilemma of legal interpretation does not turn on whether we can cement linguistic meaning. Legal rules are justified in Hegel through the appeal to the realized relations of reciprocal symmetry which give them ethical justification. [Justice of Legal Institutions.] The Good, in the strong sense of the ultimate universal, in Hegel, is imminent in social institutions and therefore capable of being grasped by the human mind." (Again: "What is Law?" and "A Commencement Address by Secretary of State Hillary Rodham-Clinton.")

If you're a philosopher, then Aristotle, Spinoza and Kant should immediately leap into your mind when reading Hegel. The philosopher's "anxiety of influence" may be even greater than what is felt by poets. (Harold Bloom's The Anxiety of Influence.)

The truth of the U.S. Constitution is not to be found in a realm of Platonic forms, in other words, but here on earth, in better realizing the meaning of its provisions through constant revisions and progress towards completion of our "unfinished" American revolution. The truth of the American idea, in Hegelian terms, is historical. That truth consists in the progressive realization of freedom and also equality through overcoming the economic and political or military challenges faced by every generation of Americans.

What is the third movement that reconciles freedom and equality? Hegel says: "Right" or "Law." (See my discussion of Bradley's "Concrete Universal.")

Individually and socially, we grow in self-knowledge -- which is the same as liberation in Hegelian terms -- in order to become the nation we are. It follows that the truth or meaning of legal rules is found in their purposes and in the purposes of the legal system -- of legality as a whole -- as opposed to being identified with a mechanical and technical adherence to the narrowest interpretations of specific rules in particular cases. ("What is Law?")

Ronald Dworkin's discussion of judges interpreting and adding to a collectively constructed narrative comes to mind at this point. We do not sit back, contemplate our navels and ponder the meaning of it all in order to "realize" our Constitution or America; but rather, we look around us and study the evolution of our flawed and oh-so human institutions, together with the crises that we have survived and that we face at this historical moment, in order to decide how they make clearer the always hidden (or only partly revealed) meaning of the Constitution, as an ideal. We are practical romantics, idealists in a cynical world -- in other words, we are Americans.

Michelangelo said that he imagined the figure he hoped to carve was buried in the stone and that he was trying to "free" it from excess marble. Great jurists -- according to this Hegelian understanding -- seek to liberate the proper Constitutional order or to define the relationship between individuals and the State, through an ever-sharper clarification of what "is," of the legal reality all around us, by the resolution of very specific disputes.

This process of Constitutional interpretation is historical because it always means coming to terms with what has happened. In other words, how we got to where we are now. It is also forward-looking, since it is an attempt to take the next step towards where we should be. Transcendence is a goal. Constitutional adjudication is like dancing the mambo. One new member of the current U.S. Supreme Court may have an edge in that dance competition. I bet Scalia is taking lessons.

For Hegel, this is also what each of us must do, personally, if we are to be free. This Hegelian insight concerning "self-knowledge as liberation" is mixed with Schopenhauer's ideas concerning the will and the ubiquity of sexuality, when it resurfaces in Freudian psychoanalysis almost a century later. ("Arthur Schopenhauer's Metaphysics of Art.") I will give the final word to Hegel:

"One word more about giving instruction as to what the world ought to be. Philosophy in any case always comes on the scene too late to give it. As the thought of the world, it appears only when actuality is already there cut and dried after its process of formation has been completed. The teaching of the concept, which is also history's inescapable lesson, is that it is only when actuality is mature that the ideal first appears over against the real and that the ideal apprehends this same real world in its substance and builds it up for itself into the shape of an intellectual realm. When philosophy paints its grey in grey, then has a shape of life grown old. By philosophy's grey in grey it cannot be rejuvenated but only understood. The owl of Minerva spreads its wings only with the falling of the dusk."

Wednesday, August 5, 2009

Corzine Hit by Corruption, Xanadu Falls Apart!

August 6, 2009 at 7:53 P.M. Several attempts to renew my security system have been obstructed this evening. We continue to be knocked off the Internet. I will try throughout the night and during the day tomorrow to renew my system. If I am not successful, then I will try to do so in some other way. If I cannot continue to work at this computer due to the hackers and spyware, then I will move to a public computer. No matter what happens to me, I will try to continue writing from some computer, somewhere.

August 6, 2009 at 1:24 P.M. "Errors" inserted since this morning have now been corrected.

August 6, 2009 at 9:21 A.M. Only one letter deleted from a word overnight. I will make the necessary correction.

August 5, 2009 at 9:07 A.M. I am still denied access to my home e-mail by N.J. hackers or whoever needs or wants to access the contents of my computer for a government entity. The FBI and U.S. Attorney's office, probably, are well aware of the situation. The Feds want to see who will show up at my sites or home computer. My Constitutional rights are expendable. Hence, your rights are expendable to further their law enforcement goals. Everybody will lie and pretend that this is not so -- that is, if this situation hits the front pages. I am told that there is increasing international coverage combined with seemingly orchestrated media silence in America.

The scams surrounding the Xanadu mall have become a little more obvious, along with Corzine's efforts to distance himself from that catastrophe while conveying the "appearance" that he is "in control" of the corruption scandal -- despite the transformation of Ridgefield into the Alamo. Mr. Suarez needs to "move on," after he gets the all clear from Menendez. Menendez does not want to lose access to police and other resources in Ridgefield that allow him to "do things" (secretly) without using Union City resources that would, immediately, identify him as the "dark power" behind the scenes. ("Does Senator Menenedez Have Mafia Friends?" and "Senator Bob, the Babe, and the Big Bucks.") Ms. Li Causi (Luchese?) doing O.K., Bobby? ("Stuart Rabner and Conduct Unbecoming to the Judiciary in New Jersey.")

The nonsense concerning Christopher Christie's "undisclosed" loan to a friend, neighbor and co-worker is smoke from the Jersey Boys. Never worry about politicians losing or spending their own money. I didn't care about Corzine spending his cash on Carla. It is when politicians -- like Senator Bob -- seem to receive money that you should worry about what they're doing for that cash. This allegation against Christie is bullshit that is intended as a distraction from the massive and pervasive corruption afflicting New Jersey's mafia-Democrat machine. Christie will file an amended disclosure form. End of story.

Menendez is losing a lot of his people and feels a little surrounded at the moment. Nobody knows when the grand juries looking into Menendez and his many "fun friends" will hand down an indictment or several indictments. Rumors of an investigation of Menendez by the "Ethics Committee" (probably corrupt) of the N.J. Bar Association and the Ethics Committee (probably not corrupt) of the U.S. Senate can neither be confirmed nor denied at this time. Politicians in New Jersey are desperately trying to keep the media away from my sites. Maybe that's why they are suppressing my books and seeking to prevent me from publishing my work. A good time will be had by all in the weeks and months ahead. Here is one of my favorite Internet items:
Larry Anderson, "How Stupid is Senator Menendez?," http://www.americanthinker.com/blog/2008 (alleged videotaped failure of New Jersey's junior Senator to grasp the difference between personal income and capitol gains taxes.) "On the one hand, but on the other hand ..."

John Brennan, "Cabela's Delays Its Opening at Meadowlands' Xanadu," in The Star Ledger, August 4, 2009, at p. 14.
Murray Weiss, "City Graft Shocker: Mob-Tied Building Inspectors in Bribe & Drug Scandal," in The New York Post, September 8, 2009, at p. 4. (N.J. Luchese family figures invade New York construction industry and management companies. Further F.B.I. investigations are expected.)
Mark Mueller, "Corzine Inks Rule Against Corruption," in The Star Ledger, August 4, 2009, at p. 1. (Are you kidding?)
William K. Rashbaum, "Leader of Carpenters' Union and 9 Others Indicted in Corruption Inquiry," in The New York Times, August 6, 2009, at p. A20. (Union with N.J. and New York "contacts," allegedly -- and suspected "mob affiliations" -- in legal trouble. Will they call Senator Bob for help?)
David M. Halbfinger, "With Scandal as Backdrop, New Jersey Race Heats Up," in The New York Times, August 6, 2009, at p. A20. (Mr. Christie is widely seen as vitally necessary to fix a state that, according to The Wall Street Journal, has become a GLOBAL "byword for corruption.")

I don't like to quote from the Star Ledger because it gives a patina of legitimacy to a newspaper that is, too often, only the house organ of the political establishment in New Jersey. I am not particularly interested in reading news feeds from the mafia's minister for public information. Mr. Bazzani? Scott Bazzani, Esq. paid his dues in North Bergen, as Municipal Prosecutor before the Jay Romano era, then Bazzani married into the Corzine clan. North Bergen is La Cosa Nostra territory, allegedly.

Most other large newspapers are not very attentive to events in New Jersey. This is due to the fact that the state is an embarassment to America -- including the people unfortunate enough to live there. No one wants to be reminded that there are places called "ho-ho-hokus" (aptly named!) where your money is stolen on a regular basis. Nevertheless, there are times when we must bite the bullet and hold our noses to ponder the grim metaphysical reality of the Garden State. New Jersey is America's legal shit hole. (Only one letter deleted from a sentence since yesterday means that the hackers from Trenton are getting a little winded.)

North Bergen went after me because I would not "genuflect" to them. I still don't take the bullshit. You guys wanna disbar me again? Mafia evaluations of my "ethics" do not trouble me.

"A key partner in the Meadowlands Xanadu project has anounced that it does not expect to open its doors until late 2010. [If at all?] Cabela's -- a publicly traded, Nebraska-based hunting and outdoors store -- made that anouncement as part of its second-quarter earnings call."

What do you think? Mob front, allegedly? Senator Bob anounced in 2006 (as I recall) the anticipated COMPLETION of the project by August, 2009. Noise fills the room in which I write, perfect timing.

They got the money to open the store. Now they will create something smaller than anticipated -- or a fraction of what they've already received money to create -- provided that they get more money from the chumps (that's you) and the economy improves.

What's Senator Bob's cut? Big Nicky Sacco? Do they gotta take care of Richard J. Codey, Esq.? Your brother likes the public job, Richard? Is he alive, your "brother"? ("New Jersey is the Home of the Living Dead.")

"News of the latest delay for struggling Xanadu comes as Colony capital, the project's parent, has begun seeking $500 MILLION in financing to complete the $2 BILLION project."

After $2 billion, there's some "additional expenses and costs that were not anticipated" with this project. They will need $500 million in additional financing (from stimulus funds, perhaps?) in order to open a store at which they will make more money, for which the consumers and taxpayers have already provided twice the necessary funds, and maybe they will request and receive tax credits. "Money for nothing and the chics for free." Now they want more money for less than nothing. Not bad. Only in New Jersey. Did you say something about "ethics"?

The store and mall that were to open this month will be delayed: " ... This project has been delayed a number of times, and we now expect the store to open in late 2010. Since this is a leased facility, we do not have a material investment in the site. [You pay for it, you pay us and buy our inventory for us to sell at no risk, and then maybe we'll actually open a store someday.] ... we have significantly slowed our planning to match the progress of the development."

Translation: "Nobody's doing nothing because we're getting all the money anyway. What's the rush? Eventually, the politicians won't want to get stuck with a hole in the ground. They'll throw more money at us to put something in there that they've already paid for ten times over. We kick back ten to fifteen percent to Trenton and throw anything in there that looks like a mall. Everybody's happy and we made millions. Then we'll flip it back to the government or some idiot immigrant."

The rest of this article is about all the pie in the sky associated with Xanadu, which is mostly bullshit. Daniel Robinson is the person in N.J. to go to on this issue. Lots of luck. My friends who have searched for the Xanadu mall in the Meadowlands tell me -- "There ain't nothing there!"

Your money sure isn't there:

"In his boldest play yet to force the resignation of Ridgefield's mayor" -- Mayor Suarez needs the O.K. from Menendez -- "Gov. Jon Corzine signed an executive order yesterday freezing state approvals for development projects in any city or town where a mayor has been charged with public corruption but refuses to step down."

"The order, which took effect immediately, makes no reference to Mayor Anthony Suarez by name, but comes a day after Suarez publicly repeated his intention to remain in office while he fights charges he accepted a $10,000 BRIBE from an FBI informant posing as a developer."

This guy is amazing: "I did nothing wrong," Mayor Suarez said. Why else would you become mayor of a place like Ridgefield? Obviously, the deal is you get cash on the side from bribes, like tips for a waiter. They have to make it worthwhile for someone to actually live in a place like Ridgefield. Ridgewood may be worse. Did Suarez keep the F.B.I.'s money? Probably.

Hey, is this New Jersey or what? Corzine looks like a moron who was out to lunch when all this shit was going down. Anne Milgram, Esq. clearly is a moron. Corzine wants to look like he's on top of this. Corzine puts out an order that says, basically, "we won't let you get nothing done or steal anymore money unless you get your ass out of town -- if you've been busted by the federales -- so we can get a new guy or gal in there in order to steal legally or in time-tested ways."

Mr. Christie was quoted reacting to this nonsense in The New York Times. " ... Mr. Corzine [has] harmed the cause of combating corruption by calibrating his response depending on who was in trouble and their political importance."

More importantly, "Mr. Corzine was 'desperately grandstanding' when he demanded resignations by the Hoboken mayor, Peter J. Cammarano III, and the Ridgefield mayor, Anthony R. Suarez, who were both charged last month. But he said the governor's 'silence was deafening' when powerful Democrats like Wayne R. Bryant, who was a state senator, and Sharpe James, the former Newark mayor, were indicted in earlier cases."

That's because Corzine needed the votes James and Bryant could deliver, but he does not need the two imbecile mayors or their friends from Hudson and South Bergen County. I am afraid that New Jersey's political mafia is expected to deface this text, again, in the future because they anticipate no trouble from a Democrat in the White House. Let us hope that they are mistaken about this assumption. Nydia Hernandez, disbarred? I cannot say whether Ms. Hernandez has been disbarred. Jose Ginarte, allegations of trust account troubles? True or false, Jose? More problems ahead for Hudson County lawyers. If it is any consolation, fellas, the OAE lawyers ("walking turds") are worse than you guys.

Anne Milgram's incompetence is not diminished by having her friends and "co-religionists" insert nice things about her in New York Times articles concerning the new U.S. Attorney in Manhattan. We know the Jersey Boys have "newspaper people on the payroll."

Corzine is playing politics with Suarez. Suarez gives Corzine the finger. Menendez has to figure out how to play this while remaining invisible in the media. "I am for all the people of New Jersey," Menendez said while munching on a chicharron at the Union City Cafeteria. Here's a napkin, Senator. Try the tostones.

The real issue is why Corzine's people are so incompetent. Milgram has no clue what's up, but she's backed by the Dyke mafia for some reason. Lesbians, I know in New York, are a lot more intelligent than Anne Milgram, Esq. Corzine can't wait to get Milgram into a bakery and out of his life so he can find a competent Attorney General. My suggestion: look outside New Jersey, Jon. Lesbians also pay taxes and tend to get a little miffed when their money is stolen, Anne.

Scott Bazzani, Esq. has a lot of stress figuring out how to make Corzine look competent. Joe ("Joe the Enforcer") Doria, Esq. has to figure out where his next crew is coming from and how to get back on the government tit. Agida. Youz guys know from agida or what?

Christopher Christie, why do you want to be governor of New Jersey? Masochism? You like headaches, Chris? You don't have enough troubles? Is that what you went to law school for? If you wanted to deal with criminals, you could have stayed at the U.S. Attorney's Office. There's always the U.S. Congress if a life with criminals interests you.

Saturday, August 1, 2009

Nihilism Against Memory.

February 15, 2013 at 2:30 P.M. Attempts to edit and revise my essay "Manifesto For the Unfinished American Revolution" were obstructed by New Jersey hackers. I am in the midst of posting (I hope) an essay "What is Memory?" I will continue to struggle to write freely, despite sanctioned cybercrime from New Jersey. ("What is it like to be tortured?" and "How censorship works in America.")

December 1, 2010 at 5:10 P.M. "Errors" inserted and corrected.

October 27, 2010 at 9:22 A.M. Previously corrected "error" restored to the text and corrected, again, by me.

August 4, 2009 at 4:24 P.M. My access to my home e-mail account is blocked by hackers. This usually means that new attacks on my computer are planned or that efforts will be made to interfere with (or prevent) renewal or updates of my security system. "Errors" will be inserted in essays and other damage to my drafts or posted writings, in addition to violations of privacy, may be expected. I will do my best to continue writing.

"There is always competition between affects and the dominion of one of the affects over the intellect."

Friedrich Nietzsche, #613 (Spring-Fall, 1887) The Will to Power, at p. 329.

The worst controversy that I encountered in expressing philosophical ideas resulted from what I regard as the most innocuous and obvious observations that one can make concerning ethics. I said, publicly, that there is such a thing as being right -- which means that we can also be wrong -- in our ethical opinions, that our ethical beliefs may be objectively valid or the opposite.

My (allegedly) "hateful" views may be found in my essay "Why I am not an ethical relativist." That original post will be the lead essay in my forthcoming collection, which I hope will outrage ethical relativists everywhere, who will feel obliged to purchase many, MANY copies of the book for purposes of public burning. I have submitted my manuscript to a publisher. I am keeping my fingers crossed. If the book is published, then I will sell it everywhere shamelessly. I will happily stand on my head naked and juggle, if necessary, to get people to buy the book and read it. I will donate the proceeds to charity. Alas, mysteriously, the book is not being distributed to book sellers, despite the provisions of the First Amendment. How strange? Who is "Publish America"? Are there state actions or connections between "Lulu" and New Jersey? ("How Censorship Works in America" and "More Censorship and Cybercrime.")

I was nearly assaulted, subjected to everything from harassment campaings and flaming to deliberate sabotage of a forum that I created at MSN. Probably efforts are underway to direct "viruses" at my blogs now, or to put needles in a doll with my name on it, as a result of my outrageous opinions. True, I like to point out political corruption when I see it. I will always annoy corrupt politicians and their friends in the legal system, as well as nihilists. How flattering. I can say anything about sex and no one cares, but if I suggest that morality is real and that we ignore it at our peril I awaken the sleeping dragon of "political correctness."

"You are being intolerant -- and we will not tolerate that!" This is usually shouted at me by a young woman in Goth attire, with a nose ring, wearing black Converse high tops, or "clogs" or "pumps," majoring in women's studies, who is "into" Silvia Plath's poetry and performance art. Inevitably, she is wearing a political button featuring a picture of President Bush that says: "A thousand points of light and one dim bulb." Another button says: "I Love My Choice!" ("Whatever" that means.)

This is a weird reversal of nineteenth century mores. Sex used to be the forbidden topic because of society's obsession with morality, now morality is prohibited because of society's obsession with sex. In fact, sex and morality are far from "coextensive concepts," as they say in English Departments, so that the most important moral issues may have nothing to do with sex anyway. Oscar Wilde's "love that dare not speak its name," according to Gore Vidal, has now become "the love that won't shut up." ("Whatever!" and "Nihilists in Disneyworld.")

Sex between consenting adults is not a matter of moral concern (as opposed to envy) for me. I don't think society should care about that issue. Private morality should remain private; but public morality is a matter of societal concern. I am "for" the legal recognition of the unions of adults, in any combination. Having removed that matter from the table, floor and/or bed, we can move on to examine why we need some sense of right and wrong beyond any trendy, wishy-washy "to each his or her own" ethical relativism. I am "for" saving whales.

This sort of vague relativist position (I call it American "Whateverism"), which is the ideology taught by our educational system to college students -- especially to anyone majoring in education, law, or the social sciences at Smith College -- is incoherent. In his perceptive criticisms of Richard Rorty's philosophy, Richard Wolin comments:

"[Rorty's] thought comes close to becoming a 'have a nice day' philosophy tailored to suit the needs of a postmodern era, in which we react with relief at no longer having to confront the intellectual responsibilities of earlier epochs -- responsibilities that revolve around our capacity to make 'strong evaluations.' It is an era which, according to Frederic Jameson, is dominated by a hypothetized sensibility in which the distinction between 'appearance' and 'essence' has been effaced, resulting in an overidentification with mass-engendered simulacra -- that is, with the illusion-proferring powers of the 'culture industry.' In consequence of this situation, we have, as it were, even lost the capacity to feel our own alienation."

I was so gratified to discover an inserted "error" in the quotation that appears above, especially one that was previously corrected, because I was concerned that my adversaries had forgotten this beautiful little essay. It is always a sign that I am hurting them when they resort to these tactics of desperation. I have corrected this newly-inserted "error." (Again: "Nihilists in Disneyworld.")

Use those illusions to free yourself from them or you're dead. What if, in your "opinion," others do not have the right to disagree with you? Well, every person has to respect the right of others to their own opinions. Why? Because each person can think whatever he or she likes. Who says so? What if I don't agree with that claim? On this relativist premise, who is to say that I am wrong?

To say that I am wrong, is to be intolerant of my opinion and right to disagree. But to say that I am right -- to allow me to conclude that I do not have to respect the opinions of others -- is to undermine the very tolerance that, allegedly, justifies relativism in the first place. Are all opinions created equal? Or are some opinions better than others? If so, what makes them better? Inconsistently, this so-called tolerance is not a "relative" value for relativists, who still claim that all values must be relative. Naturally, they exclude their own values which are "just the way things are," ethically speaking.

If we reject relativism, then we certainly do not find ourselves disarmed against dogmatism. The opposite is true: "You can't beat something with nothing," in the immortal words of Chicago's notorious Mayor Richard Daley. You must adopt some values (say, pluralism) to critique the values of others (dogmatic monism, for example), even if this is only by implication. Relativists, unless they are much more sophisticated than any that I have ever encountered, run into serious problems regarding self-consistency.

Among the most sophisticated thinkers, philosophers and literary theorists, the rhetorical song and dance gets much fancier, but the problems are still there. It is usually possible to corner relativists of all sorts, eventually.

We want to be able to say: "That's just wrong or evil." At the same time, in America, we don't want to be "judgmental" or to "think we're right about everything," except that we're right about not being right about everything. Notions of right and wrong, truth and falsehood are built into the rational discussion of these metaethical issues. You cannot step outside of that discourse, even as you seek to resolve these issues. It won't work. Ethical relativism leads, almost always, to self-referential paradoxes and contradictions. Furthermore, I believe that nihilism -- in all of its forms -- is soon found to be unlivable, even if it is determined to be coherent or defensible, philosophically, which I doubt.

Let me try again to make this point clear: To think is to use a language; all languages contain moral precepts and principles that are essential to their use and to the project of successful communication with words or symbols. Chomsky's work is very helpful on this point. So is George Steiner's theoretical work and the ethical theory of T.L.S. Sprigge. Almost as part of language-use, then, there is a kind of ethics that is accepted in the linguistic community. The ultimate source of that ethics I discuss elsewhere. Remember that even the rejection of truth is a use of language. ("Is it rational to believe in God?" and "Is this atheism's moment?")

These foundational linguistic precepts and principles are expressed through the primary function of language, which is representation and symbolizing, allowing for successful communication. Hence, to use a language in thinking is to make a commitment to a kind of ethics of communication and interaction, placing us immediately in the social realm, a commitment to the notion that you can -- that it is at least possible -- to speak truthfully to the Other, so that you should at least try to do exactly that. This will come as news to politicians and judges in New Jersey. OAE attorneys will be puzzled by this concept. This is because they specialize in "ethics" issues, "means and ends questions" where everything is "relative." Like language, ethical awareness is a foundational feature of our humanity.

Yes, you can also lie, but you can only lie if there is such a thing as not lying. I can appeal to the works of thinkers as diverse as Immanuel Kant, Ernst Cassirer, or even to Noam Chomsky's contemporary "Cartesian-Kantian" speculations to support aspects of this view and to Derrida's cryptic pronouncement that "there is nothing outside the text":

"The notion that there may be innate principles of mind that on the one hand make possible the acquisition of knowledge and belief, and on the other, determine and limit its scope, suggests nothing that should surprise a biologist as far as I can see."

Chomsky quoting Jacques Monod in Problems of Knowledge and Freedom.

Let us begin with the concept of humanity. I am a human being and I will assume -- in the absence of contrary evidence -- that you are also a human being. (It would be fascinating if this essay were some day read and understood by a conscious machine.) There is a basic equality in our ontological conditions or "existential situations." And no, I don't think that human beings are just conscious machines. The machine metaphor doesn't work (for me) beyond a certain basic point because mechanisms are detachable from their environments, their parts can be replaced and they can be returned to their tasks, without impairment in functional capacity or change in essence. Atomistic thinking works for inanimate machines, not for persons in society. ("Behaviorism is Evil.")

Persons are never reducible to Leibnitz's "monads" (without windows). They are always deeply involved in and shaped by a social setting or relationships, even in terms of their self-understandings and "functionings." To isolate a person by destroying his or her network of social relationships -- to destroy any possiblity of trust in a person's life and disconfirm identity -- is to remove the conditions that make his or her humanity possible. Perhaps this social need is also true of other animals. We need other people, just as we need food, water, and air. All languages are communities inclusive of their histories. Languages are the oceans in which we human fish must swim. ("Terry Tuchin, Diana Lisa Riccioli, and New Jersey's Agency of Torture.")

Besides, just as natural languages immediately arise (for Chomsky's reasons), so must moral and spiritual realities arise for persons in communities, as a natural part of human life in groups. Being human means both being an individual (Kant), and also a participant in a network of relationships conferring meaning, purpose, identity (Hegel), and that means morality.

I go further and suggest that being human means some capacity for love and (if you're lucky) being loved, especially in childhood (McTaggart, MacMurray). If I'm right about this, then the denial of love and exposure to violence or hatred in childhood, is bound to have devastating psychological consequences for life. The destruction of a person's network of relationships will have a destructive effect, for all concerned, at any time. The most fundamental and important language of humans is love. To be human means to speak and understand love. ("What is it like to be tortured?")

Are psychobabblers getting this? Is your only possible response inserting "errors" in this text? The encounter with hatred and envy expressed in the violation of my writings is a daily renewal of twenty-two years of torture, an immersion in the barrel of shit that is New Jersey's corrupt power-structure and the mechanisms of denial, obstruction, obfuscation used to hide the truth from victims of the state's evil.

When the culprits responsible for such crimes are persons entrusted with enforcing the laws and ethics rules they systematically violate, then all legitimacy and respect is lost not only to New Jersey's tainted tribunals, judges, and corrupt politicians, but (worse) there is a defecation on the Constitution and Bill of Rights. It is this desecration which must be placed at the doorstep of the New Jersey Supreme Court. Have you no sense of shame, Mr. Rabner? ("No More Cover-Ups and Lies, Chief Justice Rabner!")

I am willing to grant you exactly what I claim for myself, because I wish to have these claims respected by others (and the State) as regards myself: 1) I have the right to safety in my person and property, so I must refrain from threatening or injuring others, or taking their stuff, even when it comes to annoying relativists dressed in black; 2) I wish to express my thoughts and feelings freely, so that I should respect the free expressions of others; 3) I wish to love and be loved by others, who should be present in my life because they wish to be. Accordingly, I must grant to others the same opportunity to love and be loved in their turn -- this includes gays and lesbians; 4) I must act, generally, in the manner that I am willing to see others act towards me or towards society. ("Is there a gay marriage right?")

Think of this as "Kantianism Light," a zero calorie solution in ethical theory, aiming a sort of Hegelian realization. Old fashioned Christianity or Judaism, Islam, or any other religious ethic will do very nicely, provided that these conclusions are defended. Even science, gulp, may make you "good." At least, it keeps you off the streets at night. This list may be extended, but I hope that this is sufficient to get the basic point across, making it clear why, say, hurting others is bad and buying holiday gifts for poor kids is good; why loving others and facilitating relationships "for" others is good; while preventing those who love one another from getting together is bad, really bad. Get it? 4 out 5 psychobabblers agree!

You have no right to invade the lives of others in order to rearrange their personalities in accordance with what you decide is for their own good. This sort of invasion is called "enslavement" and torture which are crimes and evil. ("'Revolutionary Road': A Movie Review" and "Terry Tuchin, Diana Lisa Riccioli, and New Jersey's Agency of Torture.")

It is presumptuous to decide moral matters, substantively and with particularity, for others; presuming to judge the relationships of our neighbors, even if we are "therapists" armed with twelve-step plans. To say that others (or we ourselves) must either be right or wrong in moral judgments, wise or unwise in life-choices, is not to decide matters "for" others. It is merely to be rational.

Truth is a matter of either/or; knowledge of truth may not be. It's no good saying: "Isn't it all relative?" Because this assumes that the "relativeness" (or "relativity"?) is not relative. Ontological and metaphysical issues must be distinguished from epistemological ones. Nihilism -- Darwinian or otherwise -- is an epidemic doing severe damage to inner city kids and entire neighborhoods. Cornel West has written eloquently about this harm.

Blighted city neighborhoods have become moral wastelands, devoted to money and sex as the new currency of status, where belief in anything is a joke. This is to make human life cheap. The predictable result is that human lives become cheap. Persons will be killed for sneakers or a crack hit. The situation is not much better in suburbia, where adultery and a 'Benz become the tokens of status, along with designer divorces, but the reasoning is the same. How do I get the maximum pleasure for me, since right and wrong are "subjective" and it doesn't matter what I do anyway. (Only one inserted "error"?)

In a heterogeneous society, where equity and respect for others are no longer regarded as moral obligations, the social bond disintegrates, resulting in a collective loss of humanity. (See the film Crash.) Luckily, the important answers in ethics are known to you already. They always have been. Setting aside all of the relativist bullshit, we know when we have screwed up because we try to duck the consequences. One day, if we're lucky, we realize that the right thing to do is to accept the consequences and attempt to learn from our experience. This "adjustment" allows one to recognize the failures of others -- especially the powerful -- and to be fearless in speaking out against them. I took my medicine and so can you. I'll help with that, if I can. We'll both learn from our experiences. We will make things better for others. But you won't get away with what you've done, New Jersey. ("Law and Ethics in the Soprano State" and "Mafia Influence in New Jersey's Courts and Politics.")

I will now ask you to recall, for a moment, what you felt in childhood when you unintentionally (a key concept here is "intentionality") hurt another person. We may fail to recognize the moral significance of our actions and be in need of having this significance pointed out to us. But it was not always so. Once the world made sense to us and we felt at home in it. ("What is it like to be plagiarized?")

It is also true that the effects of cruelty or horrible violations of a person, trauma, may numb and/or harden one's moral sensibilities, as with torture for example, so that moral unawareness may not be entirely a matter of individual fault. We must struggle against this desensitizing tendency in ourselves, whatever the cause -- even if it hurts to do so -- we must allow ourselves to feel.

We must not be afraid to feel and express the full range of human emotions, so that we will appreciate the importance of avoiding those destructive and anti-social capacities of the human psyche. Avoidance of feelings is the least healthy and potentially most self-destructive attitude to the emotions. Lack of feeling, failures of affect, define all torturers and violators of others, monsters who refuse to empathize with their victims -- victims who are usually described as body parts ("ass") or rodents, "specimens" to be "learned from" by the happy social scientist. You getting this, Diana? Terry? How's retirement treating ya, Debbie? Anne Milgram? ("An Open Letter to My Torturers in New Jersey, Terry Tuchin and Diana Lisa Riccioli" and "Another Mafia Sweep in New Jersey and Anne Milgram is Clueless.")

Feelings of shame and guilt, together with a desire to make amends, should not always be eliminated from consciousness (despite Freud and the armies of psychobabblers). This is because they are sometimes appropriate emotions in the aftermath of wrongdoing, emotions leading to redemption and atonement, allowing us to feel "at home" again in the world. This condition of being at home or at peace, is another way of speaking of love. Atonement is a social emotion. How do you live with yourself, Mr. Rabner? ("Stuart Rabner and Conduct Unbecoming to the Judiciary in New Jersey" and, again, "No More Cover-Ups and Lies, Chief Justice Rabner!")

For the same reason, we must speak out against corruption and bias among the powerful, to make societies amenable to our moral wishes and expectations. Emotions and reasoning -- as well as "emotional reasoning" (not the same thing) -- are essential to moral life. Emotions are feeling states and ways of perceiving and constructing reality (Husserl, Sartre); "emotional reasoning" is one part or kind of reasoning or cognition (Bradley, Bergson). Emotions are how we develop the phenomenological tools for reality-construction.

There are other ways of doing so: the sciences, for example, may become windows on reality. Ideally, these perspectives (humanistic and scientific) may be combined. We can repair the moral fabric of our lives if we recognize fault, but not if "everything goes" or morality is a matter of "whatever" strikes the fancy. It isn't. And you knew that much when you were seven. To the accusation that I am being "childish" in suggesting that there is such a thing as right and wrong, my answer is -- "I sure hope so." The following quote is from Existentialism, by James Collins:

"Marcel does not require a Kierkegaardian 'crucifixion of the understanding' as the price of entering the region of being, mystery, and subjective truth. All that needs to be foregone, in this context, is one manner of research which is unfitted for examining questions about being as such, ... and the human person. Metaphysics, which addresses itself to such inquiries, has a method of its own, adapted to its distinctive range of interests. Its procedure is that of secondary, recuperative reflection, or, in a word, RECOLLECTION. In reviving this Augustinian term, Marcel seeks to give contemporary significance to the ... advice to enter into oneself. Recollection is literally a recovering or repossessing of one's self. This regaining of the sense of one's existence is made by recognizing the divine source of the personal self. To enter into oneself is to find the gift of being as it comes fresh from God's hands. [Or from nature, if you prefer, "in" language.] It is to discover that a man is not his own, that he does not belong to himself alone [but also to others, especially to those he loves]. The only satisfactory answer to solipsism is given in the metaphysics of participated being, not in the epistemology founded upon the subject/object relation. ... "